• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Don't have any issues at all with our drafting. Dave Morrison and co have been solid, IMO.

Viktor Stalberg
Korbinian Holzer
James Reimer
Carl Gunnarsson
Chris DiDomenico
Juraj Mikus
Matt Frattin
Jerry D'Amigo

Good use of 4-7th rounders.
 
I think Paradis will stick around in the NHL as a third liner, I think Tlusty will be out of North American hockey within two years. Tlusty certainly did both of those things. I could be wrong, but I view Paradis as a more valuable asset unless your AHL team is making a playoff run.
 
I think Paradis will stick around in the NHL as a third liner, I think Tlusty will be out of North American hockey within two years. Tlusty certainly did both of those things. I could be wrong, but I view Paradis as a more valuable asset unless your AHL team is making a playoff run.

So you're deciding this based on your own personal professional scouting opinion and predictive ability.
 
yeah, well, our scouts > you

Paradis is a horrific use of a first rounder, always has been.

Tlusty at least had the talent to be a good player.
 
I imagine we're just going to disagree there. Well except the bit about leaf scouts > me.

I can't speak to Tlusty, never saw him play until he got the call up as a leaf so my opinion of him is overly negative because he's never looked good at the NHL level.

Paradis, I never like much from what I've seen of him play but I don't think it was a horrific use of that pick. I think he can be a quality third liner.
 
Paradis was a pretty bad waste of a first. First of all he was a huge reach, the probably could have gotten him later. Secondly, why would you take a guy that projects as a bottom liner with a first round pick.

May as well trade the pick for someone who is already better than that.

Carolina obviously thought he had some upside, and they were dead wrong, and therefore stupid.
 
yeah, well, our scouts > you

Paradis is a horrific use of a first rounder, always has been.

Tlusty at least had the talent to be a good player.

So you're deciding this based on your own personal professional scouting opinion and predictive ability.
 
you're the one arguing that a mediocre junior player is a clearly better use of a first round pick than an active NHL player.
 
Seeing that Paradis was quickly flipped for Versteeg, I have to think that Tlusty was dealt for an asset that had yet to sign an ELC, making Paradis a better trade option to a team looking for cap relief.
 
you're the one arguing that a mediocre junior player is a clearly better use of a first round pick than an active NHL player.

Or arguing that the guy who has yet to play in the NHL has a better potential to play there than the player who has had

Jiri Tlusty- GP 104 G12 A16 P28 PIM20

to show for his career thus far. Neither is good. We can probably just move on.
 
Seeing that Paradis was quickly flipped for Versteeg, I have to think that Tlusty was dealt for an asset that had yet to sign an ELC, making Paradis a better trade option to a team looking for cap relief.

I think Burke legitimately liked the kid and didn't like Tlusty. This was during the more vocal part of his truculence phase and regardless of everything, Paradis is certainly more truculent than Tlusty. Leafs signed him before the trade anyway though.
 
He could be better than Eller. Not likely but he certainly could be. Eller wouldn't be available at 27th overall in most drafts though. I agree that towards the top of the draft, picks should be used on skilled players.
 
I think Burke legitimately liked the kid and didn't like Tlusty. This was during the more vocal part of his truculence phase and regardless of everything, Paradis is certainly more truculent than Tlusty. Leafs signed him before the trade anyway though.

Did it ever occur to you that maybe Burke felt it was in Tlustly's best interests to be traded, to go to a team thats in a less hellish hockey market, where he can get his career back on track? You say Burke doesnt like Tlustly, prove it, provide a quote directly from Burke that says this, otherwise I'm just going to go on your full of it.
 
Did it ever occur to you that maybe Burke felt it was in Tlustly's best interests to be traded, to go to a team thats in a less hellish hockey market, where he can get his career back on track? You say Burke doesnt like Tlustly, prove it, provide a quote directly from Burke that says this, otherwise I'm just going to go on your full of it.

I started with "I think" because it was my opinion that Paradis struck me as more of a Burke player than Tlusty was. I have no statements to back that up. But he did trade Tlusty for Paradis. Maybe he made what he thought was a bad hockey deal and was trying to turn Tlusty's career around but I'm skeptical.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top