• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Rumour out of Florida is that David Booth might be on the block.

Big physical skilled winger. 26 years old. $4.25m for 4 more years after this one.

Big time concussion worries.

Burkie has to be tempted.
 
The kid scored 29 goals as an 18 year old rookie and has two 49 point seasons to go with his three 20+ goal campaigns. All that and a Selke nomination by the age of 21... and somehow his potential is just a big bodied 20 goal 45-50 point player??? C'mon.

Nobody can claim that they know what he could do as a #1 center but I assume it would be a bit better than what he's done as a 3rd liner.

Let's look at Versteeg's potential from the age of 21... oh look, he's going to be a potential smallish 2 goal and 4 point winger.
All of that perfectly describes why he's a solid player that anybody would love to have on their team. And hey, back in 2006, I was dying to see this kid in a Leaf jersey. But that's the point, it's not 2006 anymore, it's not his rookie year where he scored 29 goals as an 18 year old and I'm not just judging him based on one season. I've personally been able to see the guy play a lot of hockey at the NHL level, and I don't see a ton of offensive skill there. And backing that up, his offensive numbers in junior were underwhelming, and as of his fourth NHL season, he hasn't been able to improve substancially on his rookie year. Now again, this doesn't speak badly on him, or mean that he's not a good player. Some guys just blossom early and stay at the same level, rather than progressively become better players each season. Unfortunately for us, it looks as though Phil Kessel might be another example of this kind of player.

As for Versteeg, he's the complete opposite of Staal in that he's a late bloomer, but he's all-around a pretty weird anomaly. If I'm recalling correctly, he's one of the only outliers in ME's statistical analysis of a player's production in junior hockey, and how it translates to their level of production in the NHL. And even so, he's still only a 50-55 point player at the NHL level. It's pretty damn rare for first line production to suddenly appear out of nowhere after years of playing professional hockey.
 
At the moment I am thinking more about zeke and LeafGM arguing that Versteeg is better than Jordan Staal.

I clearly remember all the arguments about how good Kessel is and would be because he scored at a 40 goal pace at the age of 21. Yet somehow when you have a kid that scored 29 goals (including 8 SHG) as an 18 year old and then put up a couple 49 point seasons before the age of 22... he's pretty much peaked. He's done this while being used on the 3rd line in a defensive role. Even the most skeptical of this assertion would certainly agree that he has been used in somewhat of a defensive role rather than a top 6 offensive role.

Well no, it has to do more with the fact that Jordan Staal's junior statistics (one of the best measures of prediction available to us and remarkably consistent across leagues and players) are completely underwhelming and likely point to a lesser offensive ceiling when compared to other high-draft picks such as his eldest brother (who DID produce significantly in junior).
 
Rumour out of Florida is that David Booth might be on the block.

Big physical skilled winger. 26 years old. $4.25m for 4 more years after this one.

Big time concussion worries.

Burkie has to be tempted.

There's a guy I'd like on my team. Hopefully his melon isn't too soft.
 
At the moment I am thinking more about zeke and LeafGM arguing that Versteeg is better than Jordan Staal.

I clearly remember all the arguments about how good Kessel is and would be because he scored at a 40 goal pace at the age of 21. Yet somehow when you have a kid that scored 29 goals (including 8 SHG) as an 18 year old and then put up a couple 49 point seasons before the age of 22... he's pretty much peaked. He's done this while being used on the 3rd line in a defensive role. Even the most skeptical of this assertion would certainly agree that he has been used in somewhat of a defensive role rather than a top 6 offensive role.
...wait, zeke sure, but where exactly did I say that I think Kris Versteeg is a better player than Staal?
 
Wouldn't be shocked if the Versteeg offer was for Booth.

I'd take Booth if he's coming cheap. But I get the feeling his price tag would be higher than he's worth.
 
Well no, it has to do more with the fact that Jordan Staal's junior statistics (one of the best measures of prediction available to us and remarkably consistent across leagues and players) are completely underwhelming and likely point to a lesser offensive ceiling when compared to other high-draft picks such as his eldest brother (who DID produce significantly in junior).
Heh, good point. Let's put their draft years in junior side-to-side:

Brother A: GP 68, G 28, A 40, Pts 68
Brother B: GP 66, G 39, A 59, Pts 98

So which one is the one who's turned into a #1 center at the NHL, and which one is a 2nd/3rd line center on most teams?

And as for David Booth, I'd take a chance on him. When was the last time he had a concussion?
 
...wait, zeke sure, but where exactly did I say that I think Kris Versteeg is a better player than Staal?

Well you jumped into the discussion that zeke and I were having about Staal and Versteeg and argued how overrated Staal was. It only made sense that you were taking the same stance as zeke. Guess I misread that.

I find it hard to believe that you've watched so many Staal games and haven't come away extremely impressed. I have watched virtually Pens hockey game every year for the past 4 years or so. The fiance and I usually tape one of the Habs or Pens game and watch the other and then watch the taped game.

My opinion on Staal is that he's the best defensive forward in the game. I realize that he hasn't put up great point totals bu 20+ goals and 50 points (49 to be exact) is pretty damn impressive for a young kid that plays primarily a defensive role. I know just watching the games doesn't mean that anyone has to take my word for it that he's that good. I'm just surprised that anyone that has watched him play a significant amount of games could come away not being extremely impressed by him.

I actually figured that the Pens would miss him more than any player other than Sid when I heard that Staal would miss time. Hard to say how it would have turned out If not for Sid carrying the team this year like he has.

Only one forward in the league played more short handed minutes than the 21 year old Staal last year. He get's his icetime but not prime offensive minutes that's for sure. Last year he was 10th on the team in power play minutes per game, slightly ahead of Luca Caputi. Staal's role is on the PK and facing the opposition's top players at even strength. Obviously he has permission to try to score. It's not like he's handcuffed, but does have a role to play.
 
The truth of the matters is that if Staal was so great offensively guys like Guerin, Kunitz and Poni wouldn't have played on the PP over him.

Bylsma isn't ridiculous.
 
Heh, good point. Let's put their draft years in junior side-to-side:

Brother A: GP 68, G 28, A 40, Pts 68
Brother B: GP 66, G 39, A 59, Pts 98

So which one is the one who's turned into a #1 center at the NHL, and which one is a 2nd/3rd line center on most teams?

And as for David Booth, I'd take a chance on him. When was the last time he had a concussion?

Yeah I doubt Staal will ever be a 100 point guy. Anyone who claims that he will is a fool. I do however think he's got 40ish goal and 70+ point potential. Add that to the fact that he's a beast on the PK and all around defensively impressive it makes him an extremely valuable player.

Of course this is all speculation but I think if Staal went to a team where he was relied on as a top 3 forward he'd probably consistently put up years of 35 or so goals and like 65-70ish points. If he stays in Pittsburgh playing the role he currently does I can see maybe 25g and 55-60ish points in the near future.... like I said though, it's all just speculation until he actually does it. For now I suppose the best I can fairly call him is a guy that's shown that he can score almost 30 goals and almost 50 points at a young age.
 
I do however think he's got 40ish goal and 70+ point potential.

Totals he never approached in junior in the first instance and barely scraped by in the second instance will be attained at the professional level? Staal would be one of the first instances of that ever happening. Simply put, you're dreaming in technicolour.
 
The truth of the matters is that if Staal was so great offensively guys like Guerin, Kunitz and Poni wouldn't have played on the PP over him.

Bylsma isn't ridiculous.

Again... not GREAT offensively but he has good offensive potential. Bylsma is no idiot at all. He recognizes his players strengths and plays them in that role. He plays Staal a lot on defensive situations and not as much in the offensive situations.

The fact that Staal scored more goals and more points than every guy that you listed while playing less PP time shows that he's better than them offensively, but Bylsma used those guys ahead of him on the power play so that he could play his role as the #1 pk guy and #1 checker.
 
Another thing you can't overlook when talking about Staal's great stats early in his career, is the only time he has come remotely close to potting 30 he scored 7 goals short handed. And that is definitely something that won't be repeated.
 
The fact that Staal scored more goals and more points than every guy that you listed while playing less PP time shows that he's better than them offensively, but Bylsma used those guys ahead of him on the power play so that he could play his role as the #1 pk guy and #1 checker.

Its not a one or the other choice. Lots of guys play in all situations. Staal doesn't play on the PP because he isn't good on the PP.
 
Totals he never approached in junior in the first instance and barely scraped by in the second instance will be attained at the professional level? Staal would be one of the first instances of that ever happening. Simply put, you're dreaming in technicolour.

Perhaps I am.

Would you have predicted him scoring 29 goals as an 18 year rookie looking at his junior totals? Would you have predicted two 49 point campaigns by the age of 21?

I never said he WOULD score 40 or WOULD score 70 points... I just think he had the potential to do so. Could I be wrong? Definitely.
 
Its not a one or the other choice. Lots of guys play in all situations. Staal doesn't play on the PP because he isn't good on the PP.

You can't play forwards 25 minutes a game... or at least it's not really advisable.


Last year Staal played the 10 most PP minutes per game and scored the 5th most PP points on the Pens.

Again, he's not an offensive juggernaut, he's just an elite defensive forward with some very good offensive potential.
 
Staal is one of the least effective Pens on the PP.

Last year only Mark Eaton had a worse points/60 minutes on the PP rating. In 2008-09 only Eaton, Fedotenko, Kennedy and Boucher were less efficient than Staal.

Last year when Staal was on the ice on the PP, the Pens PP GF/60 was 3.98, while it was 6.88 with him off the ice.
 
Another thing you can't overlook when talking about Staal's great stats early in his career, is the only time he has come remotely close to potting 30 he scored 7 goals short handed. And that is definitely something that won't be repeated.

Sure, he may not score 7 SHGs... but you don't take those goals away. He still scored 29 and has at least 29 goal potential. Maybe next time he only scores 2 SHGs and 27 even strength and PPGs.
 
Back
Top