• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

pardon? im pretty sure i already addressed this but your emotional ego is not allowing yourself to see passed it !

i never agreed its a good thing ! its a moving forward thing ! 12 years he has played for this team !he did his service and now its time to close the chapter and move on

im not going to argue the pros and cons of having kaberle on this team that isnt the debate ! you merely asked why ? and i addressed it by simply saying burke wants to close a chapter !

What the hell? Of course it's the debate.

i do know that burke doesnt rest ! and giving up kaberle and the assets he gains will be far greater in the long run than keeping one player who is winding down in his career

And I disagree. I think a 50 point defenseman is more valuable to us than the pieces being suggested. There simply isn't a defenseman available who'll be able to fill the hole that losing Kaberle creates. We're sending him to a division rival and getting a return that can be had for shopping lesser players.

The only reason you're defending this is because you've got some crazy other scenario worked up in your head about what else Burke is doing.
 
What the hell? Of course it's the debate.



And I disagree. I think a 50 point defenseman is more valuable to us than the pieces being suggested. There simply isn't a defenseman available who'll be able to fill the hole that losing Kaberle creates. We're sending him to a division rival and getting a return that can be had for shopping lesser players.

The only reason you're defending this is because you've got some crazy other scenario worked up in your head about what else Burke is doing.

SUGGESTED

and youre still coming at me denouncing your argument not mixed with emotions ?

step back and realize you are

a 32 year old who was soft in his own end and truly caused as many goals as he did make them is not as significant as you play him out to be

gardiner is going to challenge huge next year burke already mentioned that ! gysbers !blacker ! all fine mobile defensemen coming up ! in fact next years camp is going to be quite exciting watching our young defensemen eyeing that vacant position ! secretly rooting for blacker
 
look at it this way !~

had it not been for berards eye injury ! kaberle would have never been given the chance and who knows ?............ maybe just maybe kaberle would never have materlized into the player he became !

life is about the moment and the opportunity !

so how do we know that a kaberle is not lurking in the wings waiting for his turn to shine ?

12 years no cup no trophies ..... nothing ! he has done us well now its time to move on
 
SUGGESTED

and youre still coming at me denouncing your argument not mixed with emotions ?

step back and realize you are

a 32 year old who was soft in his own end and truly caused as many goals as he did make them is not as significant as you play him out to be

gardiner is going to challenge huge next year burke already mentioned that ! gysbers !blacker ! all fine mobile defensemen coming up ! in fact next years camp is going to be quite exciting watching our young defensemen eyeing that vacant position ! secretly rooting for blacker

Someone here is going off of their emotions but it sure as hell isn't me.

You can't honestly suggest that the likes of Gardiner, Gysbers and Blacker will be able to make up for the offense Kaberle can bring to the table and then turn around and make cracks about Leaf fans being impatient or expecting too much immediately.
 
Wow, this thread certainly turned epic weird in a hurry.

I've got Craig Anderson in a couple of pools and he has just been awful this season. So good for 3 seasons before that, although only one as a starter. I don't know what's wrong with him, perhaps a change of scenery would help. It wouldn't surprise me if he was available. Something to consider, if he does rebound Anderson-Reimer looks pretty bleeping good on paper.

It won't surprise me if Teeds comes up with one Zuckerberg idea and hits the stratosphere.

P.S. The moon landing is totally real.
 
Wow, this thread certainly turned epic weird in a hurry.

I've got Craig Anderson in a couple of pools and he has just been awful this season. So good for 3 seasons before that, although only one as a starter. I don't know what's wrong with him, perhaps a change of scenery would help. It wouldn't surprise me if he was available. Something to consider, if he does rebound Anderson-Reimer looks pretty bleeping good on paper.

It won't surprise me if Teeds comes up with one Zuckerberg idea and hits the stratosphere.

P.S. The moon landing is totally real.

i have a suspicion he's playing through a bad knee injury. it's a contract year, and another quality season (and good playoff round) would probably double his salary.

if you recall, he missed 10 games or so earlier in the season when he hurt his knee in a warmup. it looked really, really bad at the time of the injury, but the team was pretty hush-hush about what was actually wrong with him.

he came back but he hasn't been the same goalie this year. makes you wonder if he sprained a ligament or tore cartilege either in the off season, or pre season. he also had a strange 'leave of absence' last week.
 
The half life of thorium 232 is 4.5 billion years That is mind blowing

It could seriously end all of our current energy issues...all of them. All the benefits of uranium/plutonium with no weaponization capabilities and a tiny fraction of the waste.
 
Someone here is going off of their emotions but it sure as hell isn't me.

You can't honestly suggest that the likes of Gardiner, Gysbers and Blacker will be able to make up for the offense Kaberle can bring to the table and then turn around and make cracks about Leaf fans being impatient or expecting too much immediately.

Our children would be complete beasts of logic and rational thought.

Just sayin.
 
look at it this way !~

had it not been for berards eye injury ! kaberle would have never been given the chance and who knows ?............ maybe just maybe kaberle would never have materlized into the player he became !

kaberle was on the team before they acquired berard. he also played more than berard in 99-00. a lot more.

in any event, i think it's pretty safe to assume that even if he were on the third pair, and berard on the second he still would have gotten the opportunity.

life is about the moment and the opportunity !

yes, it is. you also have to earn opportunities. kaberle forced his way on to the team in the first place. they had zero intention of giving him a roster spot when training camp starter in 1998.

so how do we know that a kaberle is not lurking in the wings waiting for his turn to shine ?

because there are only a very small handful of players in the league who do what kaberle does as well as he does. and only one, frankly, who does it better.

nevertheless, there still might, in theory, be the 'next kaberle' waiting in the wings. but we heard the same thing with ian white and carlo colaiacovo and anton stralman -- who have all become serviceable to good nhl defensemen -- and none of the guys in the system are even as impressive as those three were as prospects. more to the point, tomas kaberle was, even as a prospect, a special player. i'm not even saying this because he has turned into an nhl player and i have the benefit of hindsight. but let's keep in mind that by the time kaberle came to toronto he had already played parts of 4 pro seasons for kladno. and he was only 20.

i can't say that any of the leafs current prospect defensemen would have been ready to play professionally, as a defenseman, by 20, let alone 16...

12 years no cup no trophies ..... nothing ! he has done us well now its time to move on

not to say kaberle is as great a player, but the red wings said the same thing about steve yzerman once upon a time.

holding a player to this sort of standard is ridiculous.

it isn't kaberle's fault that he hasn't playe don a team good enough to win a cup.

and tell me: how many defensemen have won the norris since kaberle entred the league in 1998-99?

as if that's a mark against a player...
 
and tell me: how many defensemen have won the norris since kaberle entred the league in 1998-99?

MacInnis
Pronger
Lidstrom
Niedermayer
Chara
Keith

If the biggest knock on Kaberle is that he wasn't better than 4 HOF'ers, Chara, and 70 point Duncan Keith....well, yeah
 
A report from a Boston radio station said Kaberle would head to the Bruins in exchange for Blake Wheeler and a draft pick.

But the rumour mill suggested Burke was more interested in Bruins rookie forward Jordan Caron, a 20-year-old first round pick (25th) from the 2009 draft.

- Toronto Star.
 
If the Leafs trade Kaberle right now, they wont be able to replace him for a while, it is against all rational thought to trade Kaberle because you have a set amount of cap room allocated for certain positions. This isn't a position that can be argued, elite offensive defensemen in the NHL are a premium, Komi is a spare part. Why is Burke so adamant on trading him for an okay offer and that too within the division? C'mon Burke, get creative. Land a bigger piece than ****ing Blake Wheeler or Jordan Caron ffs.
 
One thing I will say is that Phaneuf might blossom without Kaberle. Might being the operative. And the moon, in the sixties. Please, they found the area in Nevada where it was shot. There are a million holes in all the film, that can be picked out now. And they have never gone back.

Plus, there wasn't a star in the sky in all the shots. Have you ever gone to somewhere quiet and rural down in the caribbean? Cuba? Nassau, Mexico? There are thousands of stars in the sky. The moon shots, films etc... DID NOT HAVE ONE. C mon. The moon, in the sixties. TOTAL FAIRY TALE> No one with a brain cell could buy that one today.
 
kaberle was on the team before they acquired berard. he also played more than berard in 99-00. a lot more.

in any event, i think it's pretty safe to assume that even if he were on the third pair, and berard on the second he still would have gotten the opportunity.



yes, it is. you also have to earn opportunities. kaberle forced his way on to the team in the first place. they had zero intention of giving him a roster spot when training camp starter in 1998.



because there are only a very small handful of players in the league who do what kaberle does as well as he does. and only one, frankly, who does it better.

nevertheless, there still might, in theory, be the 'next kaberle' waiting in the wings. but we heard the same thing with ian white and carlo colaiacovo and anton stralman -- who have all become serviceable to good nhl defensemen -- and none of the guys in the system are even as impressive as those three were as prospects. more to the point, tomas kaberle was, even as a prospect, a special player. i'm not even saying this because he has turned into an nhl player and i have the benefit of hindsight. but let's keep in mind that by the time kaberle came to toronto he had already played parts of 4 pro seasons for kladno. and he was only 20.

i can't say that any of the leafs current prospect defensemen would have been ready to play professionally, as a defenseman, by 20, let alone 16...



not to say kaberle is as great a player, but the red wings said the same thing about steve yzerman once upon a time.

holding a player to this sort of standard is ridiculous.

it isn't kaberle's fault that he hasn't playe don a team good enough to win a cup.

and tell me: how many defensemen have won the norris since kaberle entred the league in 1998-99?

as if that's a mark against a player...

I'm absolute certain that it wasn't until berards ill fated injury occured that kaberle was given full opportunity to shine !

Noone is denying his skillset but the problem is everyone is crucifying burke before you see what he does !

Obviously there is something behind closed doors in that kaberle is no longer in the picture ! To which fans can only guess ! But I trust burke to do what he needs to do ! To get this team back on track and I think with the bitterness of the jfj era people need to lose that chip and start to beleaf again
 
Back
Top