• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

26 points in 55 games is pretty weak.

And a 6'6 who plays like a 5'10??

I also have some concern Colborne is a RICH kid coming from a very rich family. You sometimes wonder about the drive if your daddy's got you covered no matter what.

This is such a weak argument with prospects. Crosby came from a pretty affluent family. So do most of the American USNTDP players and they routinely get drafted in the first round.
 
he lost me there when he said he'd take Colborne over Kadri.

Kadri is a MUCH, MUCH better prospect than Colborne.

I'd be very happy if we get Kadri + late 1st for Kaberle.

I dont know about much much, even if at all.

Kadri has a lot of maturing to do on his own.

They are both ranked at 8.0C on Hockeys Future, but I don't see Kadri as a #1 Center. A #2 C, sure, maybe a winger on the top line, but he has a lot of work to do before even being considered a first line center.

Colborne has the size to take on that role. A knock on a lot of young players [even those with some crazy size] is that they dont use their size enough. Wasn't that a knock on Aulie, however now he seems to really enjoy that aspect of the game.

Kabs is a rental, getting a top prospect and a first round pick, is a good deal. I think you guys are just expected way, way to much of a return
 
coreypronman (writer for Hockey Prospectus)

Colborne is a potential #1 center, you jump on this opportunity if possible for Tor. He's one of the better center prospects in hockey.

Between Joe Colborne and Nazem Kadri, I take Colborne. If he's in the deal, even if nothing else comes with him, it's a huge win for Tor.

Colborne is an extreme, extreme longshot to be a #1 centre.

I'd peg his upside as a #2 centre - and even then, he could easily be a complete bust. He has not been good in the AHL this year at all. He doesn't even look as good as Mueller.
 
Jays, what are your thoughts on Spooner?

Incredibly strong despite a somewhat underwhelming physical package. He's one of those guys at the gym that is three or four inches shorter than you and then he takes off his shirt and he's sculpted like a Greek god. Spooner did something like 17 or 18 reps with the bench press at last year's Combine, exceptional numbers for any player let alone one who came into the day a shade over 5'10 and barely 172 pounds soaking wet. He's primarily a pass-first centre with good vision and hockey sense, a pretty decent skater, likes to look for the seams in traffic (Colborne plays a similar style but is 8 inches taller).

NHL Central Scouting’s Chris Edwards
“He's a solid guy, he battles and competes and gets involved. He's grittier than some other guys. He plays with good energy, he's up and down. He skates very well and has a good skill set."

Peterborough Petes head coach Ken McRae
“Ryan has been a very dynamic player for us over the past two seasons. He is very strong on the puck and is very elusive down low in the offensive zone avoiding and escaping his check. His ability to play all 200 feet of the ice has improved each season. He is our go to guy when a big goal or play is needed.”

People are going to think this is an outlandish comparison but he always struck me as stylistically similar to Ryan Kesler.
 
I'd like to see him with the Marlies.. he's a playmaking center and his team has HUGE problems scoring goals. Put him with Kadri and see how he does
 
If Colburne ever decides to use his frame then i can see the number 1 center talk...but thats a big if.

I do like him alot as a prospect though.....but calling him> Kadri is loony
 
Colborne (Age 20) @ AHL: 55GP 12G 26Pts (.47PPG)
Kadri (Age 20) @ AHL: 30GP 11G 29Pts (.96PPG)

Kadri doubles Colborne's production and we're told Colborne is a better prospect than Kadri? PLEEEAAASE.

Kadri appears to be more ready, that doesn't mean that he'll be the better player. Big guys tend to take longer to develop.

Colborne just needs to learn how to protect the puck with his size (ala Antropov), if he can do that he's a true Thornton-Lite.
 
Incredibly strong despite a somewhat underwhelming physical package. He's one of those guys at the gym that is three or four inches shorter than you and then he takes off his shirt and he's sculpted like a Greek god. Spooner did something like 17 or 18 reps with the bench press at last year's Combine, exceptional numbers for any player let alone one who came into the day a shade over 5'10 and barely 172 pounds soaking wet. He's primarily a pass-first centre with good vision and hockey sense, a pretty decent skater, likes to look for the seams in traffic (Colborne plays a similar style but is 8 inches taller).

People are going to think this is an outlandish comparison but he always struck me as stylistically similar to Ryan Kesler.

Thanks Jays.... If you're Burke, do you target Spooner instead of the late 1st?
 
I dont know about much much, even if at all.

Kadri has a lot of maturing to do on his own.

They are both ranked at 8.0C on Hockeys Future, but I don't see Kadri as a #1 Center. A #2 C, sure, maybe a winger on the top line, but he has a lot of work to do before even being considered a first line center.

Colborne has the size to take on that role. A knock on a lot of young players [even those with some crazy size] is that they dont use their size enough. Wasn't that a knock on Aulie, however now he seems to really enjoy that aspect of the game.

Kabs is a rental, getting a top prospect and a first round pick, is a good deal. I think you guys are just expected way, way to much of a return

Each individual team page on HF is written and maintained by a different hockey writer. There is no uniformity to the rankings on individual players as a result. The write-ups are a reasonable guage on system strength and the site is a good means of quickly looking for scouting reports and second opinions on players but it is not a definitively authoritative site by any stretch of the imagination. There can be a page for a team with a bottom-third system that has more 8.0 or 7.5 ranked prospects than a team listed in the top ten in system strength.

What qualifies as a 7.0B player to one writer on the site could be entirely divergent from the belief of another writer. So be sure to keep that in mind when you browse.
 
If Colburne ever decides to use his frame then i can see the number 1 center talk...but thats a big if.

It's what coaching and development is for.

Its a common knock on a lot of big guys.

I think growing up, being much, much bigger then most of all of their opponents, they dont have to worry about that aspect of their games as much.

Now that hes in the A playing against men, being 6'5 210 is not as overpowering as it was, and he needs to work on bulking up [and filling out as all people do] and use that frame to his advantage.

Time, coaching a development, just like all young players.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Jays.... If you're Burke, do you target Spooner instead of the late 1st?

Without hesitation. He's been a large component of Kingston's resurgence over the past few months despite a slow start, putting up well over a point per game. He also has the type of skillset that traditionally translates well to the big leagues.

With his strength and willingness to get involved he should forego the adjustment period that a lot of the perimeter-type kids go through in their first taste of the professional game. And given his skating ability and strength on the defensive end he could at least forge a decent career as a PK specialist if need be.
 
Kabs is a rental, getting a top prospect and a first round pick, is a good deal. I think you guys are just expected way, way to much of a return

If we're losing Kaberle for good, it makes no difference if its a rental or not. It not being a rental would just be the cherry on top of, IMO, a shit sundae.

We should be keeping Kaberle.
 
Each individual team page on HF is written and maintained by a different hockey writer. There is no uniformity to the rankings on individual players as a result. The write-ups are a reasonable guage on system strength and the site is a good means of quickly looking for scouting reports and second opinions on players but it is not a definitively authoritative site by any stretch of the imagination. There can be a page for a team with a bottom-third system that has more 8.0 or 7.5 ranked prospects than a team listed in the top ten in system strength.

What qualifies as a 7.0B player to one writer on the site could be entirely divergent from the belief of another writer. So be sure to keep that in mind when you browse.

Oh, absolutely. However as that source [hockeyfutures] is used a lot to gauge our players and other teams prospects as well, it is a page I like to reference.

But I agree, its not the authoritative figure on all young players and prospects, and must be used more for a guide or an outline.
 
It is what coaching and development is for.

Its a common knock on a lot of big guys.

I think growing up, being much, much bigger then most of all of their opponents, they dont have to worry about that aspect of their games as much.

Now that hes in the A playing against men, being 6'5 210 is not as overpowering as it was, and he needs to work on bulking up [and filling out as all people do] and use that frame to his advantage.

Time, coaching a development, just like all young players.

Definatly...Colburne is a guy i would target too...love the upside...and size.

And if he takes one of his 2 1sts and gets help now...this might not look as terrible as it seems.
 
As for Colborne, there is a chance that he develops into a number one guy, but it remains to be seen. I think the questions about his lean body and lack of nastyness are definitely apt, but keep in mind that it took Brian Boyle seven years to become an impact player with the Rangers and he was a comparable prospect.
 
Oh, absolutely. However as that source [hockeyfutures] is used a lot to gauge our players and other teams prospects as well, it is a page I like to reference.

But I agree, its not the authoritative figure on all young players and prospects, and must be used more for a guide or an outline.

Yup, just warning against going solely by the 8.0C factor.

:thumbsup(22):
 
Big guys take longer to develop, I get that. Still, under .500 PPG at AHL at 20 is not impressive at all. FYI, Antropov posted PPG at 21 in the AHL. (no 20 yrs old stat, as he was with the Leafs at 20)

I don't know if 6'6 make Colborne a favorite to be the #1 center over Kadri at 6'0. You look at the top teams in the league, there are plenty of examples of ~ 6'0 #1 centers in the league ... Savard (before the injury), Richards .. Duchene, whom Kadri's been often comapred to, is 5'11 himself. Does that stop him from becoming the #1 center for the Aves?

Size can be an advantage but there are plenty of examples of successful 6'0 #1 centers. It shouldn't give Colborne any advantage over Kadri in becoming the #1 center for this team, especially when Kadri is outproducing Colborne at 2:1 ratio at 20 in the same league.
 
Back
Top