• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Hey Gaborik left after the first period in the rangers game today... not injured either. Could he be on the move??? He'd be that salary dump for us, but could the Rangers make a move to LA??

New York Rangers Torts confirms that Marian Gaborik has a concussion, though not sure when/how he suffered the injury
 
Last edited:
Again, can anyone tell me why Schenn is a better prospect than Kadri? Never mind that there is such a gap in between them that the obvious (huge) gap between Kessel and Simmonds evens it out? Just why he's better at all will suffice thanks.

Kadri and Schenn are similar size (Schenn has about 10 pounds on Kadri and they're similar height, Schenn maybe having an inch advantage), but Kadri plays with a level of crazy that simply isn't in Schenn. They have very similar junior scoring track records, were drafted 2 slots apart, but due to one excellent WJHC tourney, Schenn has become wildly over rated
I hope NHL GMs don't get as hyped about WJHC performance as TSN does ... everybody understands why TSN hypes up WJHC - cos they broadcast it.

But if you need to know why WJHC performance can mean nothing ... look at Pogge, who still has that gold medal at home.
 
Now that said, it doesn't mean Kadri is definitely not going anywhere. Burke might very well trade Kadri, but only if it's a trade that makes sense to him. Burke loves B. schenn, no question about that. But Burke is also sensible. He knows B Schenn has nothing on Kadri other than 1 good WJHC, and he knows Kadri has done everything he's asked him to and is well on top of his expected development curve for a 20 year old.

And Burke is NOT trading Kessel.
 
I hope NHL GMs don't get as hyped about WJHC performance as TSN does ... everybody understands why TSN hypes up WJHC - cos they broadcast it.

But if you need to know why WJHC performance can mean nothing ... look at Pogge, who still has that gold medal at home.

Don't get me wrong...Schenn is an excellent prospect. I think he's got a very nice NHL future ahead of him. The only valid argument I see for ranking him ahead of Kadri at all is that though they're the same draft year, Schenn is ~9 months younger, and very young for his draft class. Even that though, if you don't compare them season for season and roll back Kadri's 1 year chronologically, they still come out looking really, really similar as prospects.

I can even accept someone preferring Schenn due to that and the slight size advantage, but to suggest that he should be so coveted that on top of giving up Kadri, his value with worth Kadri + a significant asset, is simply ridiculous.
 
I can see BUkre doing whatever it takes to get Schenn without Kessel...but adding too much on top of Kadri seems redundant to me as Kadri and Brayden look real similar.
 
I don't think Schenn is overrated. He is easily one of the top prospects in the NHL.

Kadri is just underrated.

Kadri is a very good prospect... but contrary to what many on this board want to believe he is just not as good of a prospect as Kadri (oops)...Schenn at this point. Perhaps Kadri will go on to be the better player, but at this point there's no way in hell that the Kings would trade Schenn for Kadri. I can't say for certain but I'd be surprised if the other 28 GMs wouldn't choose Schenn as well.
 
Last edited:
Kadri is a very good prospect... but contrary to what many on this board want to believe he is just not as good of a prospect as Kadri at this point. Perhaps Kadri will go on to be the better player, but at this point there's no way in hell that the Kings would trade Schenn for Kadri. I can't say for certain but I'd be surprised if the other 28 GMs wouldn't choose Schenn as well.

I'll skip pointing out the obvious slip up in your post and ask the same question that you've apparently missed me ask 4-5 times now.

Why? What has Brayden Schenn done, at any level of hockey, to separate himself from Naz Kadri?
 
Kadri and Schenn's careers have been identical. Everything from their draft position, to their production in junior, to their production in the AHL to their production in the NHL. Hell even their production in the WJC (when they both played on the same team and Kadri was played AHEAD of Schenn as the #1 centre).

And Kadri's playoff run last year is the exact same as what Schenn is doing in junior this year.

Like it or not, they are equivalents.
 
He looked purty in Canada jersey.

That's about what it comes down to really. If someone wanted to make the "good under pressure argument" because of that performance, cool. I'd just point to CHL career playoff scoring where Naz has put up 74 points in his last 46 playoffs games (1.61ppg) to 37 in Schenn's last 27 (1.37). That's one of the biggest things to like about Kadri, his playoff scoring rate is higher, every year, than his regular season rate.
 
Pre Draft Year

Kadri - OHL - 56 gp, 25 gls, 78 pts (82 gp, 37 gls, 114 pts)
Schenn - WHL - 70 gp, 32 gls, 88 pts (82 gp, 37 gls, 103 pts)

Post Draft Year

Kadri - OHL - 56 gp, 35 gls, 93 pts (82 gp, 51 gls, 136 pts)
Schenn - WHL - 59 gp, 34 gls, 99 pts (82 gp, 47 gls, 138 pts)

WJC
Kadri - 6 gp, 3 gls 8 pts (82 gp, 41, gls, 82 pts)
Schenn - 6 gp, 2 gls, 8 pts (82 gp, 27 gls, 82 pts)

This year

AHL
Kadri - 32 gp, 12 gls, 31 pts (82 gms, 31 gls, 79 pts)
Schenn - 7 gp, 3 gls, 7 pts (82 gms, 35 gls, 82 pts)

NHL
Kadri - 17 gp, 0 gls, 6 pts (82 gp, 0 gls, 29 pts)
Schenn - 8 gp, 0 gls, 2 pts (82 gp, 0 gls, 21 pts)

Drafted

Kadri - 7th in 2009
Schenn - 5th in 2009


Identical.
 
Last edited:
I get the feeling if Burke pulled that draft day trade with Murray and Kadri goes to the Sens this isn't even a debate. but since Kadri is a Leaf its somehow ludicrous to suggest he is a very similar prospect to Schenn. its a ****ing joke
 
I'd attribute it to the following:

1) Brayden is both a little younger and a little bigger, with a frame that will allow him to take more of a pounding from big NHL defenders. Kadri in his small sample size showed an inability to win the one-on-one battles and he shied away from contact. I can't say whether or not Brayden was like that, as I haven't seen any of his games at the NHL level.

2) Attitude and work ethic. Not to say that Naz doesn't work hard or has a bad attitude, but he does have a knock about both in hockey circles. Personally, I think Naz has a demeanor that could end up being a positive, as (over)confident individuals often take it upon themselves to live up to their own lofty goals in their minds. Brayden has the 'typical' Canadian hockey attitude and both scouts and GMs love that attribute. Just think of how composed Luke is at his young age. His brother is most likely just as humble.

3) Brayden probably doesn't huff the chach.
 
Be prepared to be very disappointed. Burke looks at Kadri as a piece of trade bait, nothing more. Look at his treatment of him. Similar to Kaberle??? If you aint big and huge, you aint budging Burke.
 
The question you should be asking is "does Burke like Brayden Schenn better than he likes Kadri".

The answer is definitely yes. Kadri was Burke's 3rd choice for that pick.
 
Back
Top