• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Grabo is by far and away the best 2nd line center in our organization.

He doesn't even have a challenger for the role.

This team isn't going anywhere this year. Looking forward to next year and beyond, Kadri, Colborne, and Bozak are legit contenders for # 2 center, also a guy like B. Schenn if we were to trade for him. I'm becoming more convinced that Burke is going to try to fill the # 1 center spot by either a big trade now, or trade/signing in the off-season. He knows how desperately we need one.
 
Carter had the most impressive physical package, but was a good deal behind Kadri and Richards production wise.

Richards was closer to Kadri's level offensively (though still behind) and had a clear advantage in the character/leadership/2-way department, but not only did he suffer from a similar size question mark as Kadri does, his skating was also considered a bigger question mark.

Draft Year

Kadri: 56gms, 25gls, 78pts (82gms, 37gls, 114pts) - Plyffs: 14gms, 9gls, 21pts (82gms, 53gls, 123pts)
Richards: 67gms, 37gls, 87pts (82gms, 45gls, 107pts) - Plyffs: 25gms, 11gls, 32pts (82gms, 36gls, 105pts)
Carter: 61gms, 35gls, 71pts (82gms, 47gls, 95pts) - Plyffs: 4gms, 0gls, 2pts (82gms, 0gls, 41pts)

Post Draft Year

Kadri: 56gms, 35gls, 93pts (82gms, 51gls, 136pts) - Plyffs: 12gms, 9gls, 27pts (82gms, 62gls, 185pts) - WJC: 6gms, 3gls, 8pts (82gms, 41gls, 109pts)
Richards: 58gms, 36gls, 89pts (82gms, 51gls, 126pts) - Plyffs: 1gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts) - WJC: 6gms, 2gls, 5pts (82gms, 27gls, 68pts)
Carter: 57gms, 36gls, 66pts (82gms, 52gls, 95pts) - Plyffs: 0gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts) - WJC: 6gms, 5gls, 7pts (82gms, 68gls, 96pts)

2nd Post Draft Year

NHL

Kadri: 17gms, 0gls, 6pts (82gms, 0gls, 29pts)
Richards: -----
Carter: ------

AHL

Kadri: 32gms, 12gls, 31pts (82gms, 31gls, 79pts) - Plyffs: -----
Richards: 0gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts) - Plyffs: 14gms, 7gls, 15pts (82gms, 41gls, 88pts)
Carter: 3gms, 0gls, 1pts (82gms, 0gls, 27pts) - Plyffs: 21gms, 12gls, 23pts (82gms, 47gls, 90pts)

CHL

Kadri: -----
Richards: 43gms, 22gls, 58pts (82gms, 42gls, 111ps) - Plyffs: 15gms, 11gls, 28pts (82gms, 60gls, 153pts) - WJC: 6gms, 1gls, 5pts (82gms, 14gls, 68pts)
Carter: 55gms, 34gls, 74pts (82gms, 51gls, 110pts) - Plyffs: 7gms, 5gls, 10pts (82gms, 59gls, 117pts) - WJC: 6gms, 7gls, 10pts (82gms, 96pts, 137pts)


3rd Post Draft Year

NHL

Kadri: ?
Richards: 79gms, 11gls, 34pts (82gms, 12gls, 35pts) - Plyffs: 6gms, 0gls, 1pts (82gms, 0gls, 14pts)
Carter: 81gms, 23gls, 42pts (82gms, 23gls, 43pts) - Plyffs: 6gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts)
 
Very well, done. Now compare by age. Kadri's first OHL season .v. Richards' and Carter's, his second, his third. Please. His birthday's the only thing screwing this up.

Compare 17 y/o Kadri (the 07-08 Rangers) with 17 y/o Richards (the 02-03 Rangers). Perfect scientific experiment. Both were second line centres on Kitchener teams that went to the Memorial Cup Final.

You're doing it relative to their draft year because it's the only way your argument works. Do it honestly, by their age. Go ahead, I'll wait.
 
Mike Richards
Born: Feb, 11, 1985
First full NHL Season: October 2005
Age: 20 years, 8 months

Nazem Kadri
Born: Oct, 6, 1990
First full NHL Season: ????
Current Age: 20 years, 5 months

Wanna have another go there, sport?


I think your decision to ignore that comparing them via their draft eligibility cutoff compares them within a 3-4 month age difference instead of an 8-9 month age difference exposes the weakness of your position, to be honest.
 
I think your decision to ignore that comparing them via their draft eligibility cutoff compares them within a 3-4 month age difference instead of an 8-9 month age difference exposes the weakness of your position, to be honest.

Same competition level, same ages, same size. There are plenty of kids younger and smaller than Nazem who played in the League. You're factoring in his birthday and draft status because it helps your argument. Compare them as rookie, sophomores, 3rd year and 4th year OHLers, do it. Come on.
 
Grabo is IN MAJOR PLAY. As is Kulemin.


is this your thing sit at home get drunk and make up a bunch of BS and then try and pass it off as inside rumours? i cant recal a single instance where you have ever gotten anything right. that guy inside mlse of yours is pretty good eh? you flip flop more then a fish out of water and might be the craziest person on the planet
 
its funny to accuse one of cherry picking an argument to suites ones needs in making a point when thats exactly what you are doing irish...

We're both doing it. My argument is that zeke's overlooks something more significant than mine does. I'm overlooking eight months of time. That's it. Nazem didn't play with the 1991s growing up, he played with the 1990s, he was drafted into the OHL with the 1990s.

zeke is treating his stats like he's a 1991 born player in order to aid his argument. By doing that, you ignore a full year of OHL experience which is way more valuable than the eight months of nothing. You're comparing a fourth year Kadri to a third year Richards. Does that seem accurate to you?
 
Same competition level, same ages, same size. There are plenty of kids younger and smaller than Nazem who played in the League. You're factoring in his birthday and draft status because it helps your argument. Compare them as rookie, sophomores, 3rd year and 4th year OHLers, do it. Come on.

If I decide to use your comparison which uses an 8-9 month age gap instead of the more sensible draft year comparison which uses a 3-4 month age gap, tthen yes, they start to look like similar level prospects.


Up to you which one you think is more accurate, I guess.


18yrs

Kadri: 56gms, 25gls, 78pts (82gms, 37gls, 114pts) - Plyffs: 14gms, 9gls, 21pts (82gms, 53gls, 123pts)
Richards: 58gms, 36gls, 89pts (82gms, 51gls, 126pts) - Plyffs: 1gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts) - WJC: 6gms, 2gls, 5pts (82gms, 27gls, 68pts)
Carter: 57gms, 36gls, 66pts (82gms, 52gls, 95pts) - Plyffs: 0gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts) - WJC: 6gms, 5gls, 7pts (82gms, 68gls, 96pts)


19yrs

AHL

Kadri: -----
Richards: 0gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts) - Plyffs: 14gms, 7gls, 15pts (82gms, 41gls, 88pts)
Carter: 3gms, 0gls, 1pts (82gms, 0gls, 27pts) - Plyffs: 21gms, 12gls, 23pts (82gms, 47gls, 90pts)

CHL

Kadri: 56gms, 35gls, 93pts (82gms, 51gls, 136pts) - Plyffs: 12gms, 9gls, 27pts (82gms, 62gls, 185pts) - WJC: 6gms, 3gls, 8pts (82gms, 41gls, 109pts)
Richards: 43gms, 22gls, 58pts (82gms, 42gls, 111pts) - Plyffs: 15gms, 11gls, 28pts (82gms, 60gls, 153pts) - WJC: 6gms, 1gls, 5pts (82gms, 14gls, 68pts)
Carter: 55gms, 34gls, 74pts (82gms, 51gls, 110pts) - Plyffs: 7gms, 5gls, 10pts (82gms, 59gls, 117pts) - WJC: 6gms, 7gls, 10pts (82gms, 96pts, 137pts)


20yrs

NHL

Kadri: 17gms, 0gls, 6pts (82gms, 0gls, 29pts)
Richards: 79gms, 11gls, 34pts (82gms, 12gls, 35pts) - Plyffs: 6gms, 0gls, 1pts (82gms, 0gls, 14pts)
Carter: 81gms, 23gls, 42pts (82gms, 23gls, 43pts) - Plyffs: 6gms, 0gls, 0pts (82gms, 0gls, 0pts)

AHL

Kadri: 32gms, 12gls, 31pts (82gms, 31gls, 79pts) - Plyffs: -----
Richards: -----
Carter: ------
 
If you go by age, and coincidentally this also means going by comparative high level (OHL, WJC, AHL, NHL) hockey experience, Nazem compares favourably, he's right in the mix. But that wasn't zeke's original contention. zeke's original contention was that Kadri was much better.
 
If you go by age, and coincidentally this also means going by comparative high level (OHL, WJC, AHL, NHL) hockey experience, Nazem compares favourably, he's right in the mix. But that wasn't zeke's original contention. zeke's original contention was that Kadri was much better.

****ing wow
 
Kadri, I think - I hope - will do what a lot of other highly-rated prospects have done.

Be kinda overwhelmed at his first taste of NHL action, go down to the AHL, and then come back ready and able to be an impact player.

We just saw Aulie do it this year. Hopefully Kadri is next.
 
is this your thing sit at home get drunk and make up a bunch of BS and then try and pass it off as inside rumours? i cant recal a single instance where you have ever gotten anything right. that guy inside mlse of yours is pretty good eh? you flip flop more then a fish out of water and might be the craziest person on the planet

I don't drink at all. And I have been closer and am closer to the MLSE gang than probably anyone here EVER will be. And its boring there. So don't envy me at all.

And Green Hornet, if this was my website, idiots who NEVER, EVER contribute anything but vitriol like yourself would be banned right off the bat. Habsy must be asleep at the wheel letting a pube like you troll this place.
 
And ONCE AGAIN. Very slowly. Do you think Wilson and Burke are so dumb as to play Lebda, Komisarek, Giguere and other schmucks, because they think they are in a playoff race? Seriously?

This team is in full on TANK. Get it through your blue and white lobotomy hats.
 
By tanking I mean trading all the second line guys for guys three years younger AND draft picks and then turning around and signing free agents to replace the second liners. Great way to quickly stock the cupboard.

Nobody on this team outside of Aulie and Schenn are Burke types. Grabo is too small. Kulmenin is Russian, MacArthur is going to ask too much and might be fit, but he is average to small as well. None of em classic Burke types.

Keep watching.
 
Back
Top