• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

We are not a playoff contender this year, why give that back and ruin our future? Let's pick Richards up in July.
 
Because if they trade him before then, the team that gets him will probably sign him.

And there really are no other options out there, with the exception of possibly Stastny.

And Stastny will cost more. Though due to his age, he's the preferable target, imo.
 
Richards is probably the only realistic target.

Stastny would be great, but I don't buy that he's moving, and he'd also cost a shit ton more in a trade.
 
Heres the thing with a lot of leaf fans (exluding myself), you all want the best of the class (guys like Richards/Statsny) yet your not willing to part with the players needed to bring in these guys. Ask yourselves this, if teams came and asked for guys like Kessel, wouldnt you want the best return possible, why should it be different for any other teams? Stastny and Richards either way would at least cost Kadri plus, and you know what, I'm fine with that deal. I'd glady give up Kadri for a proven elite player.
 
Heres the thing with a lot of leaf fans (exluding myself), you all want the best of the class (guys like Richards/Statsny) yet your not willing to part with the players needed to bring in these guys. Ask yourselves this, if teams came and asked for guys like Kessel, wouldnt you want the best return possible, why should it be different for any other teams? Stastny and Richards either way would at least cost Kadri plus, and you know what, I'm fine with that deal. I'd glady give up Kadri for a proven elite player.

Richards won't cost Kadri.

Just like Kovy didn't cost a top prospect. And every star deadline rental player before him.

Just isn't going to happen.
 
Richards won't cost Kadri.

Just like Kovy didn't cost a top prospect. And every star deadline rental player before him.

Just isn't going to happen.

Kadri may be a top prospect in the leafs system, but I'd hardly say he is a top propsect in the NHL. Richards is a proven elite centremen, which is actually far more important then a winger. So yes, it's very likely Richards would cost us Kadri.
 
Kadri is a top prospect in the NHL. And guys like him are never traded for star rental players.

The Devils didn't even have to give up a guy like Tedenby or Josefson.

Rental players NEVER cost that much. Ever.
 
Everything will depend on the amount of bidders for Richards.

Note i said i ask for Kadri or Connoly if I;m Dallas....i hardly expect to get them.

Leafman101 is right.
 
Thats about the top end that he's worth, anything more then that, and pass on him. Mccarthur so far is a one year wonder, I hope he shows he can keep this up for another 10-12 years, but we'll see, right now I would pay him anywhere from $2.5-3M/2-3 years, he needs to show he can do this for more then 3/4 of a season.

well, that's the thing. that might not be the 'top end that he's worth.' it might not even be close to it.

if they can get macarthur for $3mn or below then it's an absolute steal, because they can afford for him to regress from this season and still get fair value out of him.

60+ point forwards don't usually sign for $3mn. if grabovski's contract were expiring in 2011, does anybody think he'd be asking for $3mn right now?

absolutely not.

and he has been no better than macarthur this year.
 
I'd do that in a second. Not sure if it would be enough for Dallas though.

I know they have ownership issues, but they are dumping $8 million in Richards. I would think you'd need to give up a young roster player.
 
If Kadri was traded for Richards, he'd be the first ever top prospect traded for a rental player. And better rental players than Richards have been dealt before.
 
In response to Pronger84's offer:

Maybe in a year we are in the playoffs looking out, but this year NO WAY.

It would be ridiculous to give up anything substantial if he hasn't signed on the dotted line.
 
Back
Top