• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

rental or not I'd much rather spend more to get Stastny anyway because of age. Unless the price difference we'd have to give is really crazy where we have no choice but to go for Richards, but i'd do my best to get stastny first.

Richards will be 31 in 2 months and I don't see the leafs competing for a cup in the next 2 years in his last prime years left. He'll be declining then you have a higher chance of injury to worry about and who needs to deal with that.

Stastny just turned 25 in late december and we'll get to enjoy a half decade of his play before he's 30 when the leafs are primed for a run (or two)

I know beggars can't be choosers and we haven't sniffed the playoffs in a long time but I go for Stastny unless the cost is totally outrageous.
 
Yeah, I take back what I said about offering Kadri. Momentary lapse.

If Dallas was willing to give us Richards for a 1st, Blacker and a 2nd, I would jump on that, and fast.

I like McKegg too much though. Not trading that kid, just exploded too much to part with.
 
Its still unclear that Stastny will ever be as good as Richards. He probably won't be. And Richards is only 5 years older.
 
Richards before this and last year was the poster boy for over paid after the conn smythe award.. This is why Tampa let him go...

He is only 5 years older but did you see the knock that has given him "concussion like" symptoms?? It wasn't much at all... maybe his melon aint so good.
 
Stastny was a PPG player a year ago, wasn't he?

At his age, that's pretty much as good as or better than Richards, in my book.

Definitely would take him first, but seriously, if Richards could be had for a relative song (1st, Blacker, 2nd), we gotta get him.
 
Richards is a top 10 offensive player.

Stastny has scored at a 60 point pace 2 of the last 3 years.

He's not as good. He may never be.
 
Richards is a top 10 offensive player.

Stastny has scored at a 60 point pace 2 of the last 3 years.

He's not as good. He may never be.

not sure if that's a totally fair characterization -- richards has had a few down years recently as well.

in 08-09 richards had 48 points in 56 games; stastny currently has 48 in 58.

in 07-08 richards had 62 points in 74 games; in 08-09 (stastny's other down year he played at a 59 points pace over 74 games.

the only difference is that richards has had a few big (90 point years), whereas stastny has maxed in the point per game territory.

if we're judging the two players right now then richards has the edge, but imo it's less pronounced than you think.
 
Burke's got some solid assets to offer for Richards (or Stastny for that matter). Since that's basically it in terms of available elite 1st line players that I can see, we might as well go for it.
 
When Stastny came into the league in his first year he had 78 pts. In his 2nd year he had 71 pts in just 66 games.

You don't see that kind of production from such a young player entering the league unless he has a very high level of talent.

In his 3rd year he only played half a season so it's unfair to judge that season with ppg as he didn't play the whole year. The following season, last year, he was at ppg playing a full season.

Brad Richards was under a ppg in 4 of his last 6 seasons, or 3 of the last 6 when you discount the 12 gamer. And 3 of those seasons were shortened when he played in only 12, 62, and 56 games. Then you have the concussion problems to worry about along with his play likely declining in the next few yrs because he's almost 6 years older than the 25 and 2 month Stastny.
 
Well Richards has hit his prime, and is in his back to back top notch production year.

Its possible that Statsny gets there too, but he just hasn't yet. Not saying he won't. Not saying he isn't a great young player. But he hasn't got there yet, and Richards has.
 
Stastny's age, and (likely) cheaper contract probably nullifies any advantage Richards has in production at this point in his career, imo.

Not to mention any concerns Richards recent concussion carries, going forward.
 
Don't get me wrong, I'm not knocking Stastny. A few pages back I said I just might deal Kessel for him.

Just saying, I'd gladly take either one. I'm not picky. I'm not going to push Richards aside just because Stastny is younger.
 
not sure if that's a totally fair characterization -- richards has had a few down years recently as well.

in 08-09 richards had 48 points in 56 games; stastny currently has 48 in 58.

in 07-08 richards had 62 points in 74 games; in 08-09 (stastny's other down year he played at a 59 points pace over 74 games.

the only difference is that richards has had a few big (90 point years), whereas stastny has maxed in the point per game territory.

if we're judging the two players right now then richards has the edge, but imo it's less pronounced than you think.

Richards got his first 90 point season in his 6th year. Stastny had 71 pts in 66 games in his 2nd year and was on that 90 point clip.

In their first two years, Stastny was the better player. Richards topped out at 62 pts while Stastny hit 78 in his first season and on his way to a 90 point campaign in his 2nd season.

I really like Stastny and think he can hit that 90 point mark with all the years he has left. He just turned 25.

After Richards' first 90 pt season when he had 91 points in his 6th year, he followed it up by being under a ppg in each of the following 4 seasons.
 
Last edited:
I know cost is an issue, but if you could guarantee Richards name on a contract for three years (not happening) at 6.6 million, then his cost would be more than Statsny.. but that won't happen.

Richards with an extension will cost you more in terms of picks and prospects, and salary and term. Therefore age, term, salary, and cost favor Statsny in every possible way.

Again a signed Richards will cost you Kadri and the two firsts this year to start. Kadri and the two firsts COULD get you a guy whose younger, less injury riddled, on a proper contract for a number one centre, and for a term you can live with to let Colborne develop into hopefully something.
 
Back
Top