• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Sure Burke would love to get B Schenn, but it's not happening. Our only chance of getting Schenn was Kaberle, and we used him to get Colborne+. (Not suggesting kaberle alone would get us Schenn ... it would have to be Kaberle plus).

There was zero chance of that because the Kings are not looking for a PMD with who they already have, they have no need for Kaberle and would not have traded for him.

LA is looking for a good top line winger.

http://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-elliott-nhl-20110222,0,7155922.column

The Kings, who were interested in Neal but not at the cost of a top defenseman, have looked at Florida's David Booth and Edmonton's Ales Hemsky but have made it known they won't trade prospect Brayden Schenn. It would be surprising if Lombardi does anything bigger than his usual and tedious mid-range deals

A general manager identifies a need for a productive left winger. He decides to trade a valuable asset to fill that need but gives his team a better chance to go deep in the playoffs this season and in the future.

Congratulations, Ray Shero of the Pittsburgh Penguins.

What, you thought it might be Kings GM Dean Lombardi shaking off his paralysis by analysis?
 
I definitely think we should sell high, big time, on MacArthur.

I don't care if this will be his normal production level for the next three years. This is a time we can get a MAJOR premium for him, and it really would be a major opportunity lost if we don't.

He's not that amazing that we need to hang on to him. He may well be the chip that helps us land Brayden Schenn or Del Zotto.

if that is all the case, then they would be much smarter to trade grabovski, since if he repeats in 2011-12 he will undoubtedly be asking for a healthy raise from the $3mn he is making (which, coincidentally, is what macarthur is asking for)... and keep macarthur.
 
and with Colborne and Kadri coming up in the next year or two, and with the strong feeling that Burke will be acquiring a top2 line center from somewhere anyway just for the fact that Bozak's place is 3rd C. Grabovski is the better choice to trade.
 
Grabovski is a considerably better and more important player than MacArthur, imo, with greater upside. He's also a center.

I wouldn't deal him.

As for what MacArthur might bring, I dunno. I believe he'd net more than Versteeg one for one. And while alone he wouldn't get as much as Kabby would, he's a lot younger and cheaper, and an impending RFA not UFA. I don't think his value is THAT much lower than Kabby's to be honest, for a team looking for a scoring winger.

But you don't trade just him. You build a package around him and add a couple of other assets. Maybe you can pry loose someone like Schenn with a package of a few good pieces, and maybe some futures too (throw in a 1st). If you can't get a Schenn for that package, then add in a Kadri and go after someone else, like Stastny and Liles.

Either way, as much as I like MacA, I really hope Burke exploits this rare opportunity to really cash in on him and get something potentially a lot better than MacA, who may quite frankly never duplicate this season in the future.

Because last thing I want to happen is signing MacA to a nice 3/$9M deal and have him revert to a 45 point forward in the coming seasons. I would much much much rather take a risk and try to hit a home run using him as a central chip.
 
I would much much much rather take a risk and try to hit a home run using him as a central chip.

In this seller's market, I don't think you're going to get a home run return with Mac as your central chip.

to sell him off for a low first, yes. But not as a central piece for a big upgrade.
 
Grabovski is better, whether he has two less points right now in this one season. He also has 6 more goals, which I value more right now.

He is a more important player if they're more or less even this season and you admit he has greater upside. And yes, as a center, and a darn effective one, he is more valuable.

And Kadri in the pipeline is whatever until Kadri shows that he's going to emerge from the pipeline as a star.
 
JaysCyYoung, no problem. I DO change my opinion on players perhaps too much for most peoples taste, but I know and remember one thing, that most guys here don't. THIS IS A BUSINESS, not a sport. And I look at the Leafs like a businessman now, not as a fan. Being a fan is fun, but its for when you are 10-23years of age. I am older than that.

I don't drink koolaid any more, and I don't want anyone here to expect me to drink from that cup any longer. Players are assets, bargaining chips, investments as it were. And they always were.

I don't attach myself to them the way I once did. I am very attached to the BRAND, And although a franchise would be smart primarily developing players from within, IN A CAP SYSTEM, you have to be fluid, flexible and FAST THINKING at times.

The Stanley Cup can be bought in my opinion, this year, if a team, or teams, make the right moves. Nothings for sure, but if a team were to get Grabovski AND MacArthur from the Leafs, they would be injecting some serious enthusiasm and talent. If we took their future, we would be getting something back that is pretty promising as well albeit a year or two out.

I don't know the organizations as well as you and IrishWolfman and hockeylover. But I know one thing very well, how to trade UP. With the Cap, you can trade guys like MacArthur, that cost you NOTHING, and get a rival teams future.

Meanwhile, MacArthur could very well sink back into NOTHINGNESS in the future. Lets face it, Grabovski and MacArthur are playing on a line with maybe the strongest powerforward in the game, Kulemin. His only problem is that he does things so under the radar, so no one notices except LeafofFaith.

So I have learned the CAP system, and while it makes the game even more impersonal than ever, it can be a hoot if you like to develop and TRADE UP.

I continue to enjoy my best trade so far this year in the futures markets. Long OIL which is exploding UP, and SHORT the S and P(stock market, which is melting like a candle at this point in time).

Its a complex world, with a lot of layers, balance is important as BeLeafer keeps stressing, mostly to me, but so is being fluid and flexible. And not getting overly attached.

I think trading Luke Schenn, with guys like Jake Garndiner, Carl Gunnarson, Gysbers, Holzer and my favourite, Keith Aulie, would be OUTSTANDING for this team.

Do it Burke, before everyone realizes what I know. You have four other guys coming along,. that may not be as loyal and true blue as Luke, but they are BETTER.
 
Last edited:
Don't trade Grabovski, please.

We're all assuming Kadri, Colborne and Bozak will be 1-2-3 down the middle (not necessarily in that order) someday, but God knows when that's gonna happen. I don't think Colborne will be NHL ready beginning of next season, maybe not even end of next season ... big guys need longer to mature, and you DO NOT rush a big guy into the limelight of Leafs nation. Just look at Nik.

Kadri should definitely be in the NHL beginning of next season, but there's no guarantee he can play 2nd C role. Bozak is anybody's guess ... is he gonna repeat what he did in 2nd half of his rookie season, or are we looking at the REAL Bozak this season?

Imagine this season without production from the Grabs line ... chilling, isn't it?

That's why you don't trade Grabs NOW.
 
Like i said earlier in this thread, when you have the 2nd most productive line in the game and they are still young(and cheap) you do not break them up.

If we end up with a glut of good young centers then we decide then what to do.... it is never a bad thing to have to many good young Centers
 
Don't trade Grabovski, please.

We're all assuming Kadri, Colborne and Bozak will be 1-2-3 down the middle (not necessarily in that order) someday, but God knows when that's gonna happen. I don't think Colborne will be NHL ready beginning of next season, maybe not even end of next season ... big guys need longer to mature, and you DO NOT rush a big guy into the limelight of Leafs nation. Just look at Nik.

Kadri should definitely be in the NHL beginning of next season, but there's no guarantee he can play 2nd C role. Bozak is anybody's guess ... is he gonna repeat what he did in 2nd half of his rookie season, or are we looking at the REAL Bozak this season?

Imagine this season without production from the Grabs line ... chilling, isn't it?

That's why you don't trade Grabs NOW.

see, that's maybe the worst reason of all to keep him. successful teams have to make difficult decisions to cut ties with players. the leafs have this decision to make with grabovski within the next year, because he will be eligible for unrestricted free agency.

teams that have kept players 'just because,' are the teams that have ended up in cap trouble (calgary, boston and chicago come to mind). you have to commit to your top guys, and make decisions as to how the rest of your cap money should best be distributed. grabovski will be due for a hefty raise in 2012. even if he improves on this season's totals, his trade value might decline (if he prices himself too high for toronto's liking once they can negotiate an extension) because of his pending ufa status.

centre is, as has been noted, also the position where the leafs have the most young depth. they should also, whether grabovski is in the picture or not, be looking to upgrade at centre.

i am not saying that they should deal grabovski. but they have to decide if he's a long term piece of the puzzle or not.

yes, that means vesting a lot in kadri, colborne and/or mckegg, but again -- those sorts of difficult decisions have to be made.
 
Like i said earlier in this thread, when you have the 2nd most productive line in the game and they are still young(and cheap) you do not break them up.

If we end up with a glut of good young centers then we decide then what to do.... it is never a bad thing to have to many good young Centers

well, you do break them up if one of them is headed for unrestricted free agency and asking for more money then you can afford to pay them.

you can't just ignore the fact that grabovski will be an unrestricted free agent after next year and is likely to demand a contract in the $4.5mn-$5mn range
 
I think what some of us are thinking is these guys are 'overachieving' and thus we should 'sell high'.

I don't think they are over-achieving. They are sure finding the chemistry and benefit from playing together on the same intact line for the entire season, pretty much from training camp on.

But if you look at Grabovski, who's a bit of an overage rookie when he first joined the Leafs, but played on 50 Pts pace in his rookie season, still played on 48 Pts pace in his 'down year' during his sophomore season, and this year he's been playing on 60 points pace. Is that really overachievement? I think that's pretty realistic progression for a 26 years old playing in his 3rd NHL season.

Kulemin played on 35-40Pts pace in his first 2 seasons, but in the 2nd half of his sophomore season he showed great progress, playing on ~ 50 pts pace in his 2nd half. This season he's playing on 57 points pace. Again, I think that's natural progression for a 25 yrs old youngster playing in his 3rd NHL season.

MacArthur is the ONLY one who's leaps and bounces from his previous NHL seasons. It should be mentioned, however, that this is also the first season when he's played with the same linemates all season, and depended upon for an offensive role all season. When playing in Atlanta and Buffalo, he was used in a more checking role and didn't have players of Grabs or Kulemin's calibre to play with. Obviously, there is a chance the 25 years old is indeed overachieving in his 63 points pace season. And that's why Burke must be careful in contract negotiation. Assuming he can be re-signed at a reasonable price, I don't see why not take the chance with Mac and see what kindda season he can put together next year. Even if he 'regresses' to a 50-55 points season, his all-round plays and his personality will make him a worthwhile investment for this young team.

I think it'd be stupid to break up this line. Young teams benefit from stability and the most consistent thing about the 10/11 season has been the plays of the Grabs line. Let's keep them together to at least start next season.
 
if he puts up a 70pt season next year, I will gladly pay him 4.5 per for 4 years. that would still mean that the line would be making 4.5(grabovski) 3(MacA) and say 3 for Kuly. 10.5 for a line that produces like they do is not an overpayment or bad cap management.

All 3 contracts would still be movable as well.
 
I don't think Burke has any interest in trading any of the three members of a line which has flat out been one of the best lines in hockey this year. Unless he gets some primo first-line return - but as of now, I don't think any of the 3 have built up that kind of trade value quite yet.

We'd be much better off keeping all three, and trading them a year or two down the road if we still need a major upgrade.
 
yes, that means vesting a lot in kadri, colborne and/or mckegg, but again -- those sorts of difficult decisions have to be made.
But you don't have to make that right now.

Grabs is signed through next season. If his contract request is too much, you trade him next season.

Which is what we're doing for Mac right now. If he's asking too much $$, you trade him now.

But otherwise you keep these 3 guys to start your 11/12 season. If Kadri, Colborne, McKegg (we're ALREADY talking about McKegg??? I don't think he'll be ready next season at all!) can push these guys, good for them. We can then look at trading these guys. They will be 26, 27 years old by then, and I don't see a huge drop-off from at least 50 points pace. They should be easily tradeable.

But you can't count on Kadri and Colborne making major contributions next season and trade Grabs and MacA on those assumptions ... this team has finished in the bottom for long enough to a point the young guys need to get a taste of success (and playoff!) to further develop.
 
Kulemin played on 35-40Pts pace in his first 2 seasons, but in the 2nd half of his sophomore season he showed great progress, playing on ~ 50 pts pace in his 2nd half. This season he's playing on 57 points pace. Again, I think that's natural progression for a 25 yrs old youngster playing in his 3rd NHL season.

MacArthur is the ONLY one who's leaps and bounces from his previous NHL seasons. .

paces:

2011

Mac: 25gls/63pts
Kuly: 29gls/57pts

2010

Mac: 16gls/36pts
Kuly: 17gls/38pts

2009

Mac: 20gls/36pts
Kuly: 17gls/35pts
 
Back
Top