• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

With the way Gustavsson is playing in the AHL, what would you think his trade value may be?

I'm pretty ambivalent about this - risking exposing him to NHL shooters again and tanking his trade value or him benefiting from the AHL seasoning and rebounding to get himself on track to be a solid NHLer.
 
Depends on how high on Kadri the Avs are. Awful tough to give up a young bonafide #1 center for a prospect and a late 1st. Cause I'm assuming that basically MacArthur and Gunner go towards the Liles part of the deal give or take a bit.

As good as everyone thinks Kadri is, there are plenty of prospects his level that never become stars.

The supposed asking price for Liles is a 2nd. That's all. If so, Gunnar would be better than a 2nd and that excess would apply to the Stastny portion. And I really do think that MacA, Kadri and a 1st for Stastny (plus some value attributable to Gunnar) is a fair deal for Stastny.

As for their cap floor problem, they can easily fix that by taking on an expiring contract or two from cellar dwellers just to get through the season.
 
You don't see how it's less of a surprise that a guy with 48 points hits 60 than a guy with 30 or 35?

i don't think it's a surprise that any of them have become 50-60 point scorers

that aside, my point still stands. if it's just a 'fluke' that macarthur is scoring 60 instead of his usual 35 points then it's equally a fluke that kulemin is scoring 60 instead of his usual 35, and grabo is scoring 60 instead of his usual 45.

i mean, grabovski has already set his career high in goals. he had just 10 in 59 games last year. nobody is saying his 24 goal outburst through 60 games is just a fluike.
 
I hate arguing with 'FANS". They get emotionally attached. I am a businessman, following the pieces and chips playing in the corporation called the National Hockey League.

My favourite brand in this corporation is the Toronto Maple Leafs CORPORATION. Period.

From having watched the piece or chip, or corporation sole, called MacArthur, I have come to the realization that he is a good little player, nifty, shifty etc... but there is something missing with this guy. Something that isn't missing with Kulemin Grabovski. I dunno, what it is, maybe just a little undersized, maybe he is putting an effort that normally isn't there with him and an effort that YOU KNOW FOR SURE, won't be there, once he gets that retirement contract.

But I just feel that he is FOR TRADING purposes. End of story. Like him, but if he wants 3, trade him. He is a tradeable piece.

I agree completely. He's good, we recognize the value in him as a player, but the trade value in this one case is more attractive for some reason.

To me, when I watch him play, he is very nifty and shifty, he knows how to hold on to the puck a little longer than it looks like he'll be able to and then make a nice little pass or rush. But he isn't very strong, he tends to be dealt with with just a little aggressiveness and physicality that takes away his time and space. Grabo and Kuly just seem stronger - Grabo stronger in the sense of his skating and aggressiveness, total A level; Kuly in his physical strength and shot, and aggressiveness, A level. And both just seem to WANT it more than MacA. So, I agree, there is something missing, even though he's a good player.

And if he is only tradeable for a Versteeg package of 1st and 3rd, not interested. I'm sure you'd agree. But if he can get something like Beach and a 1st out of Chicago, I have to take that deal, personally.
 
i don't think it's a surprise that any of them have become 50-60 point scorers

that aside, my point still stands. if it's just a 'fluke' that macarthur is scoring 60 instead of his usual 35 points then it's equally a fluke that kulemin is scoring 60 instead of his usual 35, and grabo is scoring 60 instead of his usual 45.

i mean, grabovski has already set his career high in goals. he had just 10 in 59 games last year. nobody is saying his 24 goal outburst through 60 games is just a fluike.

I simply dont' agree with that. Grabo already had almost 50 points in a season. Being a 30-35 point player and then suddenly scoring 60 is a situation more easily describable as flukish. But whatever...it's not like I consider Grabo a proven scorer or anything either. In fact, maybe the reason for the Weiss rumours is that Burke has decided to sell high on Grabs.

Another question might be "how likely is it that ALL 3 of those guys really are what they have been this season"?
 
Grabo >>> Weiss.

I'll be pissed off in a big way if we get Weiss period. I don't want to give up any decent asset for that guy. No thanks.

As for:

Another question might be "how likely is it that ALL 3 of those guys really are what they have been this season"?

Grabo and Kuly are the real deal and still improving. Both of these guys are legit 30/60 NHL scorers in their primes, minimum. 1b center and 1b winger.

MacA, I consider a true 2a winger. But he's playing like a 1a winger and looks like maybe he really is one, but I'm not completely sold. So I sell high on him right now IF there is a great offer available.
 
I simply dont' agree with that. Grabo already had almost 50 points in a season. Being a 30-35 point player and then suddenly scoring 60 is a situation more easily describable as flukish. But whatever...it's not like I consider Grabo a proven scorer or anything either. In fact, maybe the reason for the Weiss rumours is that Burke has decided to sell high on Grabs.

Another question might be "how likely is it that ALL 3 of those guys really are what they have been this season"?

you don't agree with it because you're giving arbitrary weight to a 48 point season vs. a 36 point season.

how about this: as a 25-26 year old, grabovski had 10 goals and 35 points in 59 games (14 G, 48 pt pace). as a 25-26 year old macarthur has 19 goals and 47 points through 62 games (25 G, 62 pt pace).

see? we can engage in this sort of arbitrary x = y debates, but the fact of the matter is that none of the three were remotely close to 60 point caliber players last year, or in 08-09, and this year all three are. if one is a fluke then so are the others, at least at this point in time.

and based on their histories, again, it really isn't a surprise to see any of them contributing ~60 points. they all demonstrated that sort of potential in either junior, russia, or the ahl.


and leafoffaith, it's ridiculous to label the 26-27 year old grabovski and 24-25 year old kulemin 'young and improving,' but not the 25-26 year old macarthur.

that makes no sense whatsoever. it's a determination founded on nothing but your notoriously petty biases.
 
The supposed asking price for Liles is a 2nd. That's all. If so, Gunnar would be better than a 2nd and that excess would apply to the Stastny portion. And I really do think that MacA, Kadri and a 1st for Stastny (plus some value attributable to Gunnar) is a fair deal for Stastny.

As for their cap floor problem, they can easily fix that by taking on an expiring contract or two from cellar dwellers just to get through the season.

Supposed asking price and actual asking price can be much different. I think the hockey world would be thoroughly shocked if the Avs traded Liles for Gunnarson straight up. I'm surprised that you think that Gunnarson for Liles would leave excess value to go towards the Stastny portion of the trade.

That late 1st in a weak draft doesn't have a lot of value... it has some, but not a lot. MacArthur? Has a hell of a lot more value to a contender. For a rebuilding team? He's a 26 year old former 3rd round that was barely NHL caliber until this year where he's been excellent. Chances of him continuing to be a 60ish point player is quite slim... but there is the potential. Even then he's just a 2nd liner... but the type of guy that can be picked up as a UFA relatively easily. Basically the main value in this offer is Kadri... and he is a potential star... just not sure if he's blue chip enough to pry Stastny away from the Avs.
 
Perhaps he mistyped.

"48 is much closer to 60 than 35."

Guess that could be taken either way. Like I said, I didn't read the argument.

:cheers2:
 
Yeah Grabo scored 48 points at 24 when he got his first shot to play a significant role, and Mac is scoring at a 60 point pace at 25 when he got his first chance to play a significant role.

None of them is more flukey than the others.
 
Back
Top