• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

This, the MacArthur thing, is about MacArthur, because of two things. A) he is in that particular spot, where he could be traded for some real nice assests to some real desperate clubs. Burke MIGHT be able to get some amazing shit for him. Might being the operative...

B) He is asking for a contract that befits a guy who has been doing a fair amount for a fair amount of time. Personally I think he is worth close to it, particularly based on his really good numbers this year. But there is something about him I like, and something about him that makes me almost sure that this is him giving way more than he will give in the future, AFTER he has NINE MILLION in his pocket.

with MONEY, and BIG contracts, the key is to predict what the player will be like with all that dough. Will he enjoy it, and WANT MORE, or will he pull a Toskala and start buying purses, extremely ugly clothing that he thinks is fashionable, and STOP improving?

I do NOT know MacArthur at all. The only glimpse we have seen of him behind the scenes is the observations of Grabovski, which were very high praise re: his work ethic and level of passion.
 
MacArthur has been the driving force on that line. If you are going to trade him, may as well trade Grabo too while his value is still high.
 
Someone brought up the point, as did I, that maybe the three of them are just an anomoly in itself. The sum greater than the individuals. What are they? The second highest scoring line in hockey? Pretty amazing when you figure we were supposed to only have on guy who was a legitimate top six forward.

I would imagine that Burke probably does NOT want to split them up. Probably.
 
This, the MacArthur thing, is about MacArthur, because of two things. A) he is in that particular spot, where he could be traded for some real nice assests to some real desperate clubs. Burke MIGHT be able to get some amazing shit for him. Might being the operative...

this much is true, and why it's worth at least putting out feelers to see what is available.

at macarthur's cap hit and with his rfa status his value is definitely inflated. whether it's commensurate with other 25 year old 60 point scorers i'm not sure. but as you allude to, it might be.

B) He is asking for a contract that befits a guy who has been doing a fair amount for a fair amount of time. Personally I think he is worth close to it, particularly based on his really good numbers this year. But there is something about him I like, and something about him that makes me almost sure that this is him giving way more than he will give in the future, AFTER he has NINE MILLION in his pocket.

well, this just isn't true. ~65 point wingers have gotten considerably more than $3mn per in recent years. the exception is whitney, who signed at 38 and is under contract until he is 30 -- and even he got $3mn per. prior to that he was earning a $3.55mn cap hit. jason blake signed for $4mn. dumont signed for $4.4mn. hartnell signed for $4.2mn.

the fact of the matter is that $3mn is still very, very good value for what macarthur has brought to the table this year.

obviously, there are questions as to whether or not he can do it again. that is always the concern. but that is precisely the sort of difficult decision they hired burke to make, and pay scouts to help mitigate.
 
Someone brought up the point, as did I, that maybe the three of them are just an anomoly in itself. The sum greater than the individuals. What are they? The second highest scoring line in hockey? Pretty amazing when you figure we were supposed to only have on guy who was a legitimate top six forward.

I would imagine that Burke probably does NOT want to split them up. Probably.

yup, i've said that. it may well be another case where a line has been put together, they inexplicably click and for a period of time produce above their norms, simply because of their chemistry.

two recent examples are the bertuzzi-morrison-naslund line in calgary and heatley-spezza-alfredsson in ottawa.

in both instances the chemistry eventually wore out and they all regressed to their means.

that could definitely be the case.
 
the "second highest scoring line in hockey" is a little misleading.

they have likely taken more shifts together as a complete trio than any other line in hockey - probably many, many more than most.

that being said, they are a perfect 2nd line and it would be a shame to lose them.


with them as a 2nd line, and Bozak/Army forming the 3rd line, we're looking very good there....and then the question becomes whether our 3 top-10 picks Lupul-Kadri-Kessel can turn into the legit first line that we so badly need.
 
Well, like a lot of things in life, they have to go with their gut instincts on this one. If he cannot be traded for a premium, with seven Western Conference teams looking to either get a leg up on Detroit and Vancouver, or JUST MAKE it, I dunno. Should be interesting.

Typical of Burke, he won't say much when he has the advantage.
 
the "second highest scoring line in hockey" is a little misleading.

they have likely taken more shifts together as a complete trio than any other line in hockey - probably many, many more than most.

that being said, they are a perfect 2nd line and it would be a shame to lose them.

besides sedin-sedin-x

with them as a 2nd line, and Bozak/Army forming the 3rd line, we're looking very good there....and then the question becomes whether our 3 top-10 picks Lupul-Kadri-Kessel can turn into the legit first line that we so badly need.

the leafs have a difficult decision to make up the middle. because i think whether kadri is with the team or not, they have to bring in an established first line C.

which means either kadri starts on the third line and bozak is dealt... or kadri starts on the second line and grabovski is dealt.
 
well that's the other half the equation: (1) do you want grabovski back after 2011-2012? he is a ufa in the summer of 2012, as well. (2) even if you want grabovski back, are you willing to pay him what he will command considering his pending ufa status?
 
Grabo+Kuley+say, Lupul, still makes a very good 2nd line.

I'm not saying trade Mac now, but if there's a good offer on the table then I don't see why Mac is irreplaceable.

Grabo drives that line more than the other 2 guys IMHO.
 
MacA has been a great Leaf. What are you expecting in return? Honestly, unless we're looking at a potential 80-90pt prospect I don't see why we'd talk about trading him.

Best announce the signing after tonights game Burkie.
 
Back
Top