• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Less of a track record though. Personally I'd prefer Penner... maybe I'll be proven wrong, but for now I like Penner.
 
more teams would be in on Mac as opposed to Penner....affordability is so key....adds teams like Chicago, Nashville, Phoenix, Detroit, Vancouver into the mix whereas they couldnt be for Penner.
 
I can see teams out of the playoff picture going after Mac since he is RFA.... which just makes me more confused on his actual value.

IMO everything equal he is worth slightly less than Penner and slightly more than Steeg.

With contract and controlability taken into account then who knows.... at most he costs what versteeg costs to sign, and is a better player.
 
with names liek Beach, Ellis, Josi, Hodgson, Bodeker, Turris and 1sts being mentioned i think Mac gets more than Steeg.....factor int he contract, the panic of deadline day, and seemingly lack of other top F available and i think he gets a nice return
 
more teams would be in on Mac as opposed to Penner....affordability is so key....adds teams like Chicago, Nashville, Phoenix, Detroit, Vancouver into the mix whereas they couldnt be for Penner.

Sure... but that could be said for an even lesser player... but the question was who was more valuable.
 
Does anyone have an idea of what a decent return for MacA would be?

Ellis and Dumont seams high to me, does he have more value than a player like Penner?

Darren Dreger suggested a few days ago that Burkie was looking to exceed the value that he received for Kris Versteeg if he was even to consider trading Mac. That would mean something the value of a 1st and 2nd.
 
The NHL's 3 p.m. trade deadline is expected to come and go, leaving Clarke MacArthur in a Maple Leafs uniform for at least the rest of this season, and probably next, as well.

The Leafs are apparently comfortable going to restricted free agency and quite possibly arbitration with MacArthur, the club's leading scorer, and have backed off their previous stance that he would be traded if a new contract could not be arranged by the trade deadline. It was almost exactly that scenario that drove Dominic Moore out of town two years ago, but the Leafs appear to have softened their stance on MacArthur.

Meanwhile, MacArthur's agent, Don Meehan of Newport Sports. told The Star from New York late Sunday that he does not believe the Leafs intend to trade his client on Monday unless they get a boffo offer out of the blue.

"My impression is they want to make a deal with Clarke," said Meehan. "They'll watch him for the balance of the year, see how he does, see how the team does, and then reflect on that. It's not something they have to do right now."

http://thestar.blogs.com/thespin/2011/02/let-the-final-day-begin.html
 
yeah, i figured that the trade threat was mostly a negotiation ploy. burke was trying to get something done quickly and on his terms.

that isn't to say that burke wouldn't deal him if a suitable offer was made -- but it's unlikely. there is just no urgency to make a move. they have all summer to negotiate. even if nothing comes of negotiations and goes to arbitration, they will have next season to negotiate and can deal him at next year's trade deadline if a deal can't be worked out.

there is no urgency.

hell, if macarthur is signed to a one year contract and repeats in 2011-2012 then his trade value might be even higher next year, even with pending ufa status and a considerably higher cap hit.
 
I don't want to see Mac dealt.

But I'm worried that we're going to see some GMs lose their minds tomorrow and it wouldn't surprise me to see a big time offer come in for Mac tomorrow afternoon.
 
Good news. Trading MacArthur for another Versteeg/Beauchemin style package would have been disappointing. And since he is an RFA, I never really understood the rush to get a contract extension done right now before the deadline.

Exactly. I never understood Burke's obsession with that as well.

We have him for another year regardless. I say roll the dice, offer him arbitration and see if he is a one hit wonder or not.
 
I'd be extremely, extremely dissappointed if we gave up any major assets for Weiss.

Don't worry, Weiss is in tight with ownership. I seriously don't see him getting moved. They prance him around like a showdog at events down here.
 
I think Burke is the type who, in his mind, believes MacA should sign now...or never. And I think some of the late offers are gonna be so so good.

I won't believe MacA isn't dealt until a half hour after the deadline. I know most of you like him a ton, and I like him quite a bit myself, but this is a rare chance to hit a mini lotto on a guy.

If they can trade MacA for some elite prospect, then they will. And then they'll send their 1st over to Edmonton for Penner, or someone like that to replace MacA.

I think it's 80% that MacA is dealt.
 
Back
Top