• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I'm not fan of Jason Blake, but he would be better than approximately half of the forwards we are currently icing, and Toskala's contract would've come off the books to boot.

Another year of him on the payroll would suck, but Burke has to actually use the extra cap space for something, otherwise it's a moot point.
 
you know Toskala's contract was up, right?

So? Why did they make the Giggy trade? because they had to get rid of Toskala(and to a lesser degree, Rat Fetus). If they don't make that trade, one can only assume Toskala was playing well enough not to get dumped.

Ultimately, it comes down to your assumption that had the trade not been done Reimer would be the starter instead of a vet, whether it's Giggy or whoever. I think it's quite obvious that our GM and coach do not operate that way.
 
So? Why did they make the Giggy trade? because they had to get rid of Toskala(and to a lesser degree, Rat Fetus). If they don't make that trade, one can only assume Toskala was playing well enough not to get dumped.
.

what? no.

I don't have to assume anything like that at all.

I can assume that Toskala was crap, that he'd be let go for sure, and that Burke could choose to pay $4m for a 3rd line winger instead of $6m for a goalie who he'd feel obligated to start, when he already had four extremely talented young goalies in the system.

No assumptions are necessary at all, though.

If we don't make that trade, we're in the playoffs right now.
 
No, you can't assume that. That's exactly what you've been complaining about for 2 years now -- burke/wilson have shown great reluctance to rely on young goalies. They didn't want to do it last year. They were forced to do it this year.
 
i think what volc is saying is that if they didn't have giguere, they almost certainly would have brought in somebody else.

the truth is, giguere might turn out to be a godsend for reimer in terms of getting his chance. another guy might have been a bit better, or might not have gotten hurt.
 
in any event, blake has been really bad this year... and if richards hits the open market (or the avs decide to deal stastny) then this might be the perfect summer to have that $6mn coming off the books.
 
So let me get this straight...

Blake in YOUR opinion would have started the season playing on the wing of Versteeg or Kessel? And that would have made us better??

Regardless of the fact that Blake is completely useless as a player, as he shoots way more the he deserves to, he would have been the elder statesman in our dressing room. And you think this would have been the guy to provide hockey knowledge and leadership in our dressing room? I think he is useful on a team like Anaheim because they have strong leadership in the dressing room, with A) older guys like Selanne and Koivu in there and B) indisputably better players are there like Getzlaf, Perry, and Ryan.

Just because you look at his stats and IMAGINE a roster that could be better, having him on our team hurts us a lot more than it helps us.

I love the way you argue and try to back things up, but I doubt your vision in terms of building a strong team top to bottom.

Besides that, Giguere while having a bad season changed our dressing room culture in terms of how the goalies interact and work together as opposed to competing. Ultimately, in the standings whether we make that trade or not probably changes little. In the dressing room it factors in immensely.
 
Blake >>> Sjostrom

And Giggy's "mentorship" didn't seem to help Gusto much.

I'll stand by what I said - you take away that trade (and change no other moves), and we're in the playoffs right now.
 
Blake always came across as a selfish little shit that was never really thrilled about being here. Combine that with the piss-poor season he's having in Anaheim, and that he's under contract for next year too, and I'm much happier with him being out of the dressing room, and off the books for next year.

As for Giguere, I agree with mbow, having him on the team this year has worked out for the best. Firstly, if any goaltender has cost us the season, it's Gustavsson, not Giguere. Giguere's numbers for the season are at least passable, as has been his performance until recently as his struggles with his groin issues are becoming an increasingly losing battle. Secondly, he's also done us a favour by being injury prone, as if we didn't have a #1 goalie who's been out of action as much as he's been, Reimer would still be in the AHL splitting starts with Jyussi Rynnas. And of course, the biggest bonus: $6M in cap space opening up for the summer.
 
Blake >>> Sjostrom

And Giggy's "mentorship" didn't seem to help Gusto much.

I'll stand by what I said - you take away that trade (and change no other moves), and we're in the playoffs right now.

with martin biron starting?

like leafgm said... the bigger problem has been gustavsson. that wouldn't change. and they only gave reimer a chance because giguere got hurt.

if giguere wasn't here and didn't get hurt then we probably wouldn't have seen reimer this year.
 
Blake >>> Sjostrom

And Giggy's "mentorship" didn't seem to help Gusto much.

I'll stand by what I said - you take away that trade (and change no other moves), and we're in the playoffs right now.

Meh, you've made a lot of both astute and foolish statements before. We'll throw this one in the foolish pile.
 
Blake >>> Sjostrom

And Giggy's "mentorship" didn't seem to help Gusto much.

I'll stand by what I said - you take away that trade (and change no other moves), and we're in the playoffs right now.
Yeah, but that's sort of a meaningless statement. Things don't operate in a vacuum like that. If we didn't have Giguere, we still wouldn't have been starting the season with Reimer as our #1, or even necessarily on the team. Burke had so little faith in the kid that he wasn't used until they were absolutely forced to by Giguere's injury, Gus's shitty performance and the fan/media outcry. And even then, they still sent him down after a dominant road trip, and only brought him back when forced to again by Giguere and Gus's total ineptitude.
 
Meh, it's a totally meaningful statement.

You guys are just excusing a bad move by claiming that another bad move would have been made if that one hadn't. That's a meaningless statement.
 
Your statement is the equivalent of: "If ifs and buts were candies and nuts, then we'd all have a merry Christmas."

Yeah, if we'd started the season with Reimer, we'd probably be in a playoff spot. But Giguere being here was not the thing stopping that from happening. Burke was.

So, bearing that in mind, Giguere off the payroll after this season > Blake still on the payroll for next season.
 
Back
Top