• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Meh, it's a totally meaningful statement.

You guys are just excusing a bad move by claiming that another bad move would have been made if that one hadn't. That's a meaningless statement.

zeke, stop thinking about this based on your opinions... we know that you thought highly of reimer before this season started. we know you wanted the team to let the four youngsters fight for ice time.

but how many teams are doing that right now? and of teams that have created goaltending competitions, how many has this worked out for?

i think it is a little naive to think that burke wouldn't have brought in another goalie if he had toskala coming off the books and giguere wasn't in the picture. to me it is pretty obvious that burke would have made a move to address the lack of a veteran goalie.

and i reiterate, that player might have been quite a bit better than giguere. but that wouldn't do anything to help reimer.

and i think we both agree that it is within this team's best long-term interest to find out what reimer has in him, and if he can carry the reins.
 
Nah, I reserve the right to point out that we'd be better off if the Giguere traded never happened, every time someone mentions the trade as a good thing for our team.

as for other teams that have sucessfuly gone pretty much full bore with leaning on young unproven kids - LA, PHI, WAS, MTL, CHI, CAR, to start. The league is full of examples.
 
Nah, I reserve the right to point out that we'd be better off if the Giguere traded never happened, every time someone mentions the trade as a good thing for our team.

as for other teams that have sucessfuly gone pretty much full bore with leaning on young unproven kids - LA, PHI, WAS, MTL, CHI, CAR, to start. The league is full of examples.

Except if this was you team we would be looking at a top line centred by Kyle Wellwood, John Mitchell getting significant ice time and now Jason Blake being on the team still??

Just to clarify, let's see as a recap what your roster would have looked like to start the season.

With zeke being the coach and GM here.
 
Nah, I reserve the right to point out that we'd be better off if the Giguere traded never happened, every time someone mentions the trade as a good thing for our team.

as for other teams that have sucessfuly gone pretty much full bore with leaning on young unproven kids - LA, PHI, WAS, MTL, CHI, CAR, to start. The league is full of examples.
See, that's the problem though. Your main point is that we'd be better off if we'd just had the kids battling for playing time in goal, and ended up with Reimer/Scrivens starting the season.

The Giguere trade not happening definitely does not lead to that. And you know it.
 
Nah, I reserve the right to point out that we'd be better off if the Giguere traded never happened, every time someone mentions the trade as a good thing for our team.

as for other teams that have sucessfuly gone pretty much full bore with leaning on young unproven kids - LA, PHI, WAS, MTL, CHI, CAR, to start. The league is full of examples.

well that's quite a different question. the question isn't whether a young goalie can shoulder the load. plenty of young goalies are doing just that, and have in the past.

the question is whether teams giftwrapped starting jobs to unknowns, or have a group of youngsters fight it out for the starting job.

that just hasn't happened. again, you were an early believer in reimer, but a lot of people... including our gm, and plenty of hockey poeople... weren't. so any argument you make has to be tempered by the reality that practically nobody in hockey would have the balls to head into 2010-2011 with some combination of jonas gustavsson, a 22 year old recent 3rd rounder with 25 games of ahl experience under his belt, a 23 year old longshot latebloomer from finland, and an ncaa pickup with 0 games of professional experience in net.

it just wouldn't have happened.

of the teams you listed the only team that giftwrapped a starting job to an unknown or (arguably) undeserving youngster is LA.

chicago only turned to crawford because turco stunk

bobovrski won the job over boucher (who they only view as a backup) and leighton, who only backstopped philadelphia to the cup last year.

ward had to steal the job from irbe, and had the fortune of winning a cup rather early in his career.

montreal went with price, the recent 5th overall pick with a few solid seasons in the nhl, when the choice was between price or paying up for a restricted free agent in halak.

the situations aren't comparable to toronto's at all.
 
Cam Ward actually stole the starter's job from Martin Gerber in the playoffs, not Irbe (who backstopped them to their earlier 2001 SC finals appearance, and then played his last NHL games in 03/04). Your point remains though.
 
See, that's the problem though. Your main point is that we'd be better off if we'd just had the kids battling for playing time in goal, and ended up with Reimer/Scrivens starting the season.

The Giguere trade not happening definitely does not lead to that. And you know it.

you seem to be missing the point. the criticism of the Giguere trade is a criticism of Burke's decision making with goaltending.

saying that Burke would have gone on to make a different bad decision doesn't mean anything.
 
well that's quite a different question. the question isn't whether a young goalie can shoulder the load. plenty of young goalies are doing just that, and have in the past.

the question is whether teams giftwrapped starting jobs to unknowns, or have a group of youngsters fight it out for the starting job.

that just hasn't happened. again, you were an early believer in reimer, but a lot of people... including our gm, and plenty of hockey poeople... weren't. so any argument you make has to be tempered by the reality that practically nobody in hockey would have the balls to head into 2010-2011 with some combination of jonas gustavsson, a 22 year old recent 3rd rounder with 25 games of ahl experience under his belt, a 23 year old longshot latebloomer from finland, and an ncaa pickup with 0 games of professional experience in net.

it just wouldn't have happened.

of the teams you listed the only team that giftwrapped a starting job to an unknown or (arguably) undeserving youngster is LA.

chicago only turned to crawford because turco stunk

bobovrski won the job over boucher (who they only view as a backup) and leighton, who only backstopped philadelphia to the cup last year.

ward had to steal the job from irbe, and had the fortune of winning a cup rather early in his career.

montreal went with price, the recent 5th overall pick with a few solid seasons in the nhl, when the choice was between price or paying up for a restricted free agent in halak.

the situations aren't comparable to toronto's at all.

Two seasons in a row now Chicago has quickly gone to a totally unproven youngster as the fulltime starter.

Price went quickly to a totally unproven Price/Halak combo.

Carolina won a cup by going wiht an unproven 20 year old.

Philly didn't hesitate one instant to dump last year's hero Leighton for a totally unproven youngster.


And the salient point there is that none of those teams had four quality youngsters like the Leafs had.

The only one that was comparable there was Washington with their 3 young aces - and they didn't hesitate to go with them. Neither did LA.



So many teams have had the balls to go with youngsters flat out with no safety net, and even more have had zero problem dumping a vet immediately upon the arrival of a quality kid.

This isn't about Reimer - Reimer was no guarantee. But we had 4 very talented young goalies with plenty of top notch top level experience under their belts to fight over the starts. The chances IMO were always high that one or more of them would provide better than the expected .900 level goaltending Giguere would give us.
 
Two seasons in a row now Chicago has quickly gone to a totally unproven youngster as the fulltime starter.

but they didn't start the season with the youngster/unproven guy starting.

Price went quickly to a totally unproven Price/Halak combo.

after halak posted two and a half years of ~.930 save percentages in the ahl and echl... and price was a former 5th overall pick with some legitimate nhl success under his belt (a .920 sv% over his first 40 games in the league).

not at all comparable to the leafs going with gustavsson, with a ~40 game season at .902, reimer with 25 games of ahl experience, scrivens without a single game outside of ncaa, and rynnas, fresh off the boat from finland.

Carolina won a cup by going wiht an unproven 20 year old.

ward was the starter out of the gate that year? gerber started 60 games. he fell apart in the playoffs and ward seized the opportunity.

still, not comparable at all.

and again, ward had a much, much higher pedigree than reimer, or any fo hte leafs other young goaltenders (just look at what he did in the ahl as a 20 year old in 04-05).

Philly didn't hesitate one instant to dump last year's hero Leighton for a totally unproven youngster.

yup

still not a comparable situation

And the salient point there is that none of those teams had four quality youngsters like the Leafs had.

most of those teams had young goaltenders with significantly better reputations than any fo the leafs' youngsters... if not a youngster with a better pedigree. the other instances were teams where a veteran struggled.

these situations just cannot be compared to what the leafs' situation would have been, had they headed into the season with just the four youngstesr.

nobody is denying the fact that it probalby would have worked.

but that's not the salient point here. the question is whether any nhl general manager would head into a season with four goalies like gustavsson, reimer, rynnas and scrivens, considering their careers to this point, pedigrees and perceived potential.

i know YOU would have. and i think that this has proven you right in a sense. but the odds of burke doing that are slim to none, and you know. the odds of ANY general manager doing it is pretty darn unlikely.

The only one that was comparable there was Washington with their 3 young aces - and they didn't hesitate to go with them. Neither did LA.

LA is comparable.

washington... not so much

varlamov and neurvith were both considerably more seasoned/experience than scrivens, rynnas and reimer. and both were considerably better in nhl action than gustavsson was last year.

So many teams have had the balls to go with youngsters flat out with no safety net, and even more have had zero problem dumping a vet immediately upon the arrival of a quality kid.

now you're just attributing a blanket term inre: 'youngsters.'

sure, the leafs have some good young goaltenders. but a general manager is just flat out more likely to hand the starting job to a 23 year old former 5th overall pick, entering his fourth professional season, than a 22 year old with 25 ahl games under his belt, or a 24 year old with 0 major or minor league games under his belt, or gustavsson who was mediocre last year (in fact awful until february), or a guy making his north american debut.

no team that you listed did anything remotely comparable to that, other than maybe the kings.

This isn't about Reimer - Reimer was no guarantee. But we had 4 very talented young goalies with plenty of top notch top level experience under their belts to fight over the starts. The chances IMO were always high that one or more of them would provide better than the expected .900 level goaltending Giguere would give us.

operative term: 'imo.'

we know what your opinion is. but yoru opinion doesn't make the likelihood of burke sharing that opinion any likelier.
 
Last edited:
Zekie, if Blake is your first line winger and Trashecan is your stud #1 dman, I shudder to think of who would fill out the rest of your fantasy roster.
 
I still don't see this harping about Giguere. The bad move was relying on Gustavsson after he clearly demonstrated that he wasn't ready for even a backup role this year.

Assume, if you will, that Reimer got proper recognition and a shot coming out of the preseason. Let's say, he comes out as the backup to Giguere. Giguere has a 11-10-4 record. Over, say, 50 games that projects to 52 points. Throw in Reimer's record 10-4-3 and project it over the other 32 games ... 43 points.

95 points, bitch.
 
Msun is right in regards to the Hawks...the year of Niemi was supposed to be the year of Huet, and the year of Crawford was supposed to be Turco.

Myabe Stan is just better at cutting bait with veteren crap than most
 
but they didn't start the season with the youngster/unproven guy starting.



after halak posted two and a half years of ~.930 save percentages in the ahl and echl... and price was a former 5th overall pick with some legitimate nhl success under his belt (a .920 sv% over his first 40 games in the league).

not at all comparable to the leafs going with gustavsson, with a ~40 game season at .902, reimer with 25 games of ahl experience, scrivens without a single game outside of ncaa, and rynnas, fresh off the boat from finland.



ward was the starter out of the gate that year? gerber started 60 games. he fell apart in the playoffs and ward seized the opportunity.

still, not comparable at all.

and again, ward had a much, much higher pedigree than reimer, or any fo hte leafs other young goaltenders (just look at what he did in the ahl as a 20 year old in 04-05).



yup

still not a comparable situation



most of those teams had young goaltenders with significantly better reputations than any fo the leafs' youngsters... if not a youngster with a better pedigree. the other instances were teams where a veteran struggled.

these situations just cannot be compared to what the leafs' situation would have been, had they headed into the season with just the four youngstesr.

nobody is denying the fact that it probalby would have worked.

but that's not the salient point here. the question is whether any nhl general manager would head into a season with four goalies like gustavsson, reimer, rynnas and scrivens, considering their careers to this point, pedigrees and perceived potential.

i know YOU would have. and i think that this has proven you right in a sense. but the odds of burke doing that are slim to none, and you know. the odds of ANY general manager doing it is pretty darn unlikely.



LA is comparable.

washington... not so much

varlamov and neurvith were both considerably more seasoned/experience than scrivens, rynnas and reimer. and both were considerably better in nhl action than gustavsson was last year.



now you're just attributing a blanket term inre: 'youngsters.'

sure, the leafs have some good young goaltenders. but a general manager is just flat out more likely to hand the starting job to a 23 year old former 5th overall pick, entering his fourth professional season, than a 22 year old with 25 ahl games under his belt, or a 24 year old with 0 major or minor league games under his belt, or gustavsson who was mediocre last year (in fact awful until february), or a guy making his north american debut.

no team that you listed did anything remotely comparable to that, other than maybe the kings.



operative term: 'imo.'

we know what your opinion is. but yoru opinion doesn't make the likelihood of burke sharing that opinion any likelier.

yeah, I'm not sure how you don't get out of all of this that I realize that burke doesn't share my opinion - and that I'm criticizing him for it.

as for all your rationalizations for all the teams that didn't hesitate to go to well performing youngsters over struggling vets, that's all they are - rationalizations.
 
Absolutely, Burke has been terrible in reacting quickly, especially in net. Thats been a criticism on him his whole career in the NHL.

But to think there would have been a different result had they not traded for Giggy is silly. Burke would still be Burke.

Thankfully it looks like we don't have to worry about the goalie position anymore, so it won't be an issue going forward.
 
That's EXACTLY it. Burke will always be Burke.

When he won the cup, remember, Giguere was on his team when he got to Anaheim, and that's the 1 decision he DID NOT have to make rebuilding the team. He did a lot of great work bringing in Pronger, Nieds, Selanne etc. Full marks to Burke for building a championship team. But I bet you if Giguere wasn't there, and he had Vesa as his #1 when he got there, he would not have won the cup.

So let's hope Reimer is the real deal, and that it is obvious enough for the rest of this season that even Burke can see it. I am ok with Burke's decision in other areas, though I don't agree with all of them. I can see what he's building, and looking at the team now it's quite impressive he's managed to fill up the cupboard with quite a few promising prospects who are gonna be NHL ready very soon, and at the same time acquire a bunch of young players with potential. Let's just hope Reimer is the real deal so that Burke doesn't have to make that decision.

But it's wishful thinking to think if Burke didn't make the giguere trade he would actually bring in a good goalie ... he would probably have got Ellis or Mason, and then we'd have a crappy Mason + Gus to start this season ... worse, if Mason / Ellis weren't as injury prone as Giguere, Reimer would NEVER have got the call and we wouldn't even know what we got in him. It would have been a WORSE season.
 
Argh. This has nothing to do with wishful thinking.

You guys are making a silly argument.

I can also argue that if JFJ had never traded Rask for Raycroft, we'd be in the playoffs right now.

You guys then arguing "well JFJ would have just traded Rask for some other crappy goalie" is not a meaningful response to that.
 
Burke didn't just trade for Giggy because. He did it to fill a need. He was going to fill that perceived need one way or the other.
 
It is absolutely, 100% wishful thinking to think that Burke would have come into the season giving all of Reimer/Rynnass and Scrivens a fair shot to be the starter.

Would some GM's around the league do that? Sure.

Burke showed he didn't have any interest in doing that though.
 
Back
Top