• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

You're really going to keep up an argument which says "You can't criticize a GM's move because he would have made another bad move anyways"?
 
this whole argument is meaningless. It's what we do now until the end of the season that matters, let's stop living in the past.
 
No. You can criticize whatever you want.

All I'm saying is it is in fact wishful thinking to think Burke wouldn't have gone after a veteran goalie, and stuck with the youngsters, when in fact he DID NOT do that, and history shows he had no intention to do that.

Its fair to say you don't like the deal, and you think the Leafs would have been better off not having made that deal and Burke is stupid when it comes to goaltenders. But the fact is Burke is stupid when it comes to goaltenders and they did make that move.

With Burke as GM Reimer wasn't getting a fair shot to start the year.
 
No, you can criticize Burke for his poor goalie decisions all you want, and I'm with you on every word you say about Burke.

But don't think if he hadn't made this decision to trade for Giggy, he would have made a good goalie decision and our season would have been a success. That would not have happened. He would simply have made another bad decision.

The only times when Burke makes a good call on goalies is when that decision has been made for him. In Anaheim, Giguere was the #1 when he got there. He didn't have to do anything.

For us this season, the turning point was Giguere's injury and Gustavsson's struggle. It left him with no choice but to start Reimer. Had Gus not sucked so bad, or had Giguere been healthy, we'd be looking at the 2nd lottery pick to send to Boston today.
 
And either way I don't see how you could not like the deal.

This offseason they now have $4 million of additional cap space, and Jiggy would have been a fine backup/platoon to Reimer this year, if Reimer was given a fair shot to compete with our other young, unproven goalie in Gus, like he should have been.

That was the real problem here.

Reimer has been better than Gus since game one of preseason this year, and there was no reason for him not to be in a competition with Gus for the backup job.
 
(and everybody but zeke can see this ... )

Anyways, I think it's a noble idea to give all 5 goalies (Gus, Giggy, Scrivens, Reimer, and Rynnas) an equal shot for the 2 jobs with the big club at training camp. Fact is, NO GM would do that. Experience counts for something, and veterans like Giggy don't perform up to 100% at training camp.

A more open minded GM though, would have put more weight on how the young guys perform at camp even though it may not be an equal shot. Not Burke. He pretty much had the 2 guys circled in before the camp even started.

That wasn't the biggest problem. The biggest problem was, on a young team with so many holes, you can't afford to have subpar goaltending. But when it was clear Giggy + Gus was not even average, Burke did nothing. And he would continue to do nothing about it had it not been Giguere's injury, very much like how he did nothing about Vesa+Gus until end of January.

Most GM's would have given Reimer / Scrivens / Rynnas a shot with the big club in November this season, just like most GM's would have stopped Vesa from dragging his young team down by Nov of last season. But Burke didn't do anything until the season's officially over.

I would even bet you, if it's up to Burke and not Wilson, as soon as Giguere's ready again he'd have made him #1, Reimer #2.

THAT is the biggest problem with Burke.
 
I mean hell, if only they gave Reimer a shot the first time he was called up when Giggy went down in November, and Gus was sucking dirty monkey balls, instead of sitting him on the bench, the Leafs would be well in the playoffs right now.

That was the problem here. For some reason overvaluing Gus in comparison to the 3 other young, unproven kids.
 
That stretch by Gus in November, when Reimer was WITH the team, and sitting on the bench, is what put the team in the huge hole they were in.
 
Between Giggy's two injuries in November and December, Gus went 3-8-1 and Reimer was riding the pine watching the whole thing.
 
Yes that is true.

I remember at the time, Rynnas was red hot, and I suspected the reason they called up Reimer instead of Rynnas was they had NO INTENTION to give the call-up a start anyways.

However, to say that 3-8-1 stretch was what put the Leafs in a deep hole wouldn't be accurate. After winning the first 4 starts, the Leafs won 2 of the next 12 or something like that. That killed our season.
 
Yeah and those games made up the part of that stretch that went beyond offsetting the hot start.

Give Reimer a fair shot when Giggy is out and Gus is struggling and we're in the playoffs right now.
 
The NHL like a lot of big institutions is slow to give the up and comer a break. Particularly in goal. Some rare cases can be made, but we had to fumble our way into Reimer. I wanted this guy showcased for at least a game or two last year.

Burke is finally doing what I would do if I ran this team. Building, and acquiring and accumulating. But his work with goalies is right and wrong. He is right to be acquiring a whack of them. That is good. But he stuck with some real shit performers. For too long.

And it is going to cost us a playoff spot. Ryan Miller was off the dial last night. The Leafs are going to have to win almost all of their games, to make the playoffs. And THAT is not happening.
 
Interesting breakdown of goalie stats.

http://www.pensionplanpuppets.com/2011/3/1/2023504/comparing-goalies-since-the-lockout-save-percentage-relative-to

Quick snippet.

1. The best goaltending the Leafs have gotten since the lockout was Vesa Toskala in 2007-2008 with a 0.9041 save %. This was 6.7352 percentage points below average and good for 29th in the league!
This has been said many times but bares repeating each time an analysis shows it: Vesa Toskala's goaltending last year was the worst season of goaltending of any goaltender since the lockout. His save % of 0.8797 was 32.7056 percentage points below league average. The second worse was Marc Denis in 2006-2007 who was 26.0169 percentage points below league average. That means Toskala was more than 5 percentage points worse than the second worse season since the lockout!
2. Gustavsson (who is technically 1 GP short of the cut off) is the worst goaltender this year (slightly worst than Ellis at second worse).
3. Reimer (if he were to have played enough games to count) is second best this year. Further he has the 11th best save percentage relative to average since the lockout and would have been the BEST in 200-2008.
 
Recent Mirtle tweet from Wilson that touches on what you guys were discussing:

mirtle James Mirtle
Ron Wilson: "I didn't have any expectations for Reimer (this season) other than to have a good year in the American League."
 
I mean hell, if only they gave Reimer a shot the first time he was called up when Giggy went down in November, and Gus was sucking dirty monkey balls, instead of sitting him on the bench, the Leafs would be well in the playoffs right now.

That was the problem here. For some reason overvaluing Gus in comparison to the 3 other young, unproven kids.

Giggy clogged up the pipeline. When he went down, even mbow was arguing that Gus deserved a run while he was out. Because he did - Gus is a talented young goalie who any smart team should have given a chance to, and no team would have waived.

Giggy is the $6.5m .900sv% for 3yrs running vet best buds with the GM that was clogging up the pipeline.

And if you're arguing that there's no way we could have started this season with no backup with NHL experience - then that stretches back to last year. Instead of trading for Giguere, they should have just waived Toskala and called up Reimer and let him and Gus start the last half of the year last year. Then we would have better known what we had heading into the offseason. The Giguere trade screwed up that possibility as well.
 
Absolutely, Burke has been terrible in reacting quickly, especially in net. Thats been a criticism on him his whole career in the NHL.

But to think there would have been a different result had they not traded for Giggy is silly. Burke would still be Burke.

Thankfully it looks like we don't have to worry about the goalie position anymore, so it won't be an issue going forward.

Talk about contradicting yourself, on one hand your admitting Burke lacks goaltending knoweldge, and in the next breath your saying the goalie position is secure/won't be an issue, which is it?. Right now yes it's "secure", but its tenative, Gus and Giggy are both on the team chomping at the bit to get in on the action. Reimer as great as he's been, his job isn't secure, a string of three-four bad games, and we'll likely see Burke go back to the other two clowns.
 
Wilson makes the final call on who starts in goal, who backs up, and who sits in the pressbox, not Burke.

True, but Burke gets to decide who is called up and who is sent down. Burke if he wanted to could send Riemer down today (knock on wood that doesnt happen) and Wilson couldnt do anything about it.
 
Giggy clogged up the pipeline. When he went down, even mbow was arguing that Gus deserved a run while he was out. Because he did - Gus is a talented young goalie who any smart team should have given a chance to, and no team would have waived.

Giggy is the $6.5m .900sv% for 3yrs running vet best buds with the GM that was clogging up the pipeline.

And if you're arguing that there's no way we could have started this season with no backup with NHL experience - then that stretches back to last year. Instead of trading for Giguere, they should have just waived Toskala and called up Reimer and let him and Gus start the last half of the year last year. Then we would have better known what we had heading into the offseason. The Giguere trade screwed up that possibility as well.

Why does anyone deserve a "run." If a guy is playing well he should play. If a guy is playing like crap he shouldn't.

Gus didn' deserve, or earn anymore than that.

And I'm not disagreeing that they should have gone with the youth "or anyone over Toskala," just that clearly wasn't Burke's plan, and it most certainly is wishful thinking to hope that he would have done that.

That said the Giggy trade is still a great one. Little is more important than cap management in this era. Giggy has been a fine back up this year. Their problem was favouring any one of their unproven, young goaltenders over another one. That was the real problem here.

Gus didn't really earn, or deserve any special treatment.
 
Back
Top