• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

He had other choices, don't be silly.

With all due respect if you werent related to him i doubt you'd feel the same way.

Ben was a warrior for us in the playoffs, but he made too much for a 4th liner.

I wouldve loved to have kept Sopel too but it wasn't in the cards.

He wasnt going to deal a guy liek Brouwer in order to keep Eager.
 
He got rid of the supporting, easily replaceable components while retaining all of the important core guys and promoting the promising youngsters from Rockford who have had decent seasons for the Hawks so far.
That's the line you used in the fall. They are now a bubble team.
 
With all due respect if you werent related to him i doubt you'd feel the same way.

Ben was a warrior for us in the playoffs, but he made too much for a 4th liner.

I wouldve loved to have kept Sopel too but it wasn't in the cards.

He wasnt going to deal a guy liek Brouwer in order to keep Eager.

I think Ben was easily replaceable. That's not who I'm talking about. Mostly Byfuglien, Ladd and Niemi.
 
In retrospect they should have traded Bolland and kept Buff, and let Hjalmer go in favour of Neimi, but he had the right idea.

Sure losing the depth hurts, but losing the front line players would have hurt more. And in the long run they would be a lot harder to replace.

Just turns out the lost a couple of front line players, they didn't think were front line players.
 
No, that idea is wrong. Pittsburgh is proving it and now Chicago is proving it. You need quality depth to be a winner in the NHL.
 
You definitely need quality depth players to win. But you also need the star players to win. And the stars are a lot harder to find. You just need to draft well to get the depth.

But under a cap its pretty hard to be legit contenders every year. Ideally you have a 2-3 year window before you have to lose some guys and restock.

And when you do that its much easier to replace the depth guys.
 
No, that idea is wrong. Pittsburgh is proving it and now Chicago is proving it. You need quality depth to be a winner in the NHL.

how is pittsburgh proving it?

there isn't a team in the league that can lose its two best players and still be as good as they are with them in the lineup.

pittsburgh is just fine. crosby and malkin out obviously really hurts them. but with those two and a pile of crap surrounding them up front they're probably the best team in the league.
 
In retrospect they should have traded Bolland and kept Buff, and let Hjalmer go in favour of Neimi, but he had the right idea.

Sure losing the depth hurts, but losing the front line players would have hurt more. And in the long run they would be a lot harder to replace.

Just turns out the lost a couple of front line players, they didn't think were front line players.

Bolland as opposed to Buff i can buy

but Crawford is as igood if not better that Niemi.
 
This is going to take time to be shown, but stacking your cap into a few top paid players is a potion for disaster.
 
as for chicago.. they have sustained the losses of eager, byfuglien and ladd just fine.

their problem is (or was) in net. they definitely underrated niemi. but the only reason they have spent a portion of the season on the outside looking in inre: a playoff spot is because turco shat the bed. he was awful. since turning to crawford they've looked just fine.
 
You can't win without the stars. You just can't. You need both the stars and the depth. And one is easy to get, and the other is hard to get.
 
as for chicago.. they have sustained the losses of eager, byfuglien and ladd just fine.

their problem is (or was) in net. they definitely underrated niemi. but the only reason they have spent a portion of the season on the outside looking in inre: a playoff spot is because turco shat the bed. he was awful. since turning to crawford they've looked just fine.

Yes.
 
This is going to take time to be shown, but stacking your cap into a few top paid players is a potion for disaster.

minus the fact that pittsburgh won a cup by doing that.

high end talent trumps depth.

the question in chicago is whether or not hossa can hold up as age sets in, and whether toews and kane are of a high enough caliber to do that with.

crosby and malkin don't need depth to make your team elite. they just don't. and those are the guys who teams live and die by... not overpaid 2nd liners.

case in point: the toronto maple leafs.
 
The alternative to giving up a guy like BUff would've been Sharp....if they wanted the same return.

As Jays said we got Morin back in the deal and he could be a dandy
 
how is pittsburgh proving it?

there isn't a team in the league that can lose its two best players and still be as good as they are with them in the lineup.

pittsburgh is just fine. crosby and malkin out obviously really hurts them. but with those two and a pile of crap surrounding them up front they're probably the best team in the league.
Part of the problem with relying on two stars is that if one or both get hurt, you're screwed. If one can't play up to par, the other needs to have a generational type season. Can that sustain a long playoff run? I don't think so.

They didn't get too far last year with this setup. Bumped by the 8th placed seed, no?
 
After they made the cup finals two years in a row, and got a ring.

I think they've had more than enough success with that format.
 
minus the fact that pittsburgh won a cup by doing that.

No they didn't. Malkin signed his monster contract after the Cup.

No one said it's either depth or talent. It's a mix, obviously. But it has to be more balanced that what Pittsburgh and Chicago have done.
 
Back
Top