• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Part of the problem with relying on two stars is that if one or both get hurt, you're screwed. If one can't play up to par, the other needs to have a generational type season. Can that sustain a long playoff run? I don't think so.

They didn't get too far last year with this setup. Bumped by the 8th placed seed, no?

they went to the second round after back-to-back cup runs.

detroit, who did the same thing, fell apart in the second round last year, too.

it wasn't a surprise at all. those teams top players played a lot of hockey from 2007 through 2010 when you factor in crosby/malkin/gonchar (i think he was back for the olympics) and datsyuk/lidstrom/zetterberg all playing in back-to-back cups and then not having a break during the olympics.

pittsburgh's problem last year was fatigue. not a lack fo depth.
 
No they didn't. Malkin signed his monster contract after the Cup.

No one said it's either depth or talent. It's a mix, obviously. But it has to be more balanced that what Pittsburgh and Chicago have done.

you can't make an argument like that without looking at their roster. the 2009 cup winning penguins team was no better on the wings than this year's pens' team.
 
Show me the teams who've won by maxing out with three or four players.

1. 2009 Pittsburgh Penguins
2. 2007 Anaheim Ducks
3. 2006 Carolina Hurricanes
4. 2004 Tampa Bay Lightning
5. 2003 New Jersey Devils
6. 2001 Colorado Avalanche
7. 1999 Dallas Stars
8. 1995 New Jersey Devils

To name but just a few.
 
And something you can't forget about the Hawks cap situation, is thanks to winning the cup they have like a $5 million cap penalty this year.

That hurt them a lot. They could have kept some of that depth under normal circumstances. But thats the price you pay to win.
 
1. 2009 Pittsburgh Penguins
2. 2007 Anaheim Ducks
3. 2006 Carolina Hurricanes
4. 2004 Tampa Bay Lightning
5. 2003 New Jersey Devils
6. 2001 Colorado Avalanche
7. 1999 Dallas Stars
8. 1995 New Jersey Devils

To name but just a few.

I'll grant the Penguins of '09, but the rest? Most of them weren't even in a cap situation.
 
you can't make an argument like that without looking at their roster. the 2009 cup winning penguins team was no better on the wings than this year's pens' team.

Fair enough, I'll recant on the 09 Penguins. I'll be surprised if they repeat with Malkin and Crosby maxed out nonetheless.
 
Why would you ask that question then?

I thought it was obvious we are talking about working under the salary cap. I can rephrase it ... name me the Cup winners who won under the salary cap by maxing out two or three players.

What I'd say though is that it's possible, because, as with Anaheim, teams can develop good young talent that is still cheap. But if you allocated a large portion of your cap to a few players, you won't be able to hold the depth these other players provide. As such, teams that do this will be most unlikely to repeat.
 
you won't be able to hold the depth these other players provide. As such, teams that do this will be most unlikely to repeat.

This has more to do with the parity and lack of differentiation between talent levels on most teams in the NHL rather than any sort of team-building philosophy.
 
This has more to do with the parity and lack of differentiation between talent levels on most teams in the NHL rather than any sort of team-building philosophy.

No, it has to do with how the cap is allocated. Maybe it's fine to lock up over 60% of your cap in five players. It forced Chicago to unload some quality players that weren't all that expensive.
 
It's happened at least twice or three times since the lock-out (depending on how you evaluate individual player contributions):

1. Pittsburgh relied almost entirely on Crosby and Malkin in 2009.
2. Anaheim relied mainly on Pronger, Niedermayer, Selanne, and Getzlaf.
3. Carolina was a three man show relying on Eric Staal, Brind'Amour, Cam Ward, and got an unexpected contribution from Cory Stillman.

That's 60 percent of the time.
 
No, it has to do with how the cap is allocated. Maybe it's fine to lock up over 60% of your cap in five players. It forced Chicago to unload some quality players that weren't all that expensive.

The point is that Chicago won a Cup on the basis of their stars. They made difficult choices that will pay dividends in the long-run.
 
The point is that Chicago won a Cup on the basis of their stars.

That's just not true. Niemi and Byfuglein were key parts of that win - clutch performers. Shit, Byfuglein led the team in postseason goals. How you let a guy like that go is beyond me.
 
A guy that they called up in Bryan Bickell already has as many goals and more points as of today than Dustin did all of last season. And he's making close to league minimum to do the same job. You're falling into the trap that too many Canadian hockey fans fall prey to.

You overrate the grinders on a champion. You win with your stars, not with the lunchpail guys.
 
That's just not true. Niemi and Byfuglein were key parts of that win - clutch performers. Shit, Byfuglein led the team in postseason goals. How you let a guy like that go is beyond me.

keep in mind that byfuglien was pretty adamant about playing on the blueline... and the truth is that he kind of stinks in his own end.
 
Back
Top