• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

his selection to team canada really isn't an indication of anything other than the fact that he's one of canada's top 20 forwards. nobody would dispute that.

In fairness its not even an indication of that. See Patrice Bergeron, Kris Draper, Rob Zamuner, etc.

Its not really an indication of anything, though Nash did deserve to be there.
 
If Nash was ever available, the Sens should be first in line to get him.

Heck, this might be a good draft to pick him up..

Nash is over-rated as "clutch" due to a few good showings at international style tournaments, but he is still a top 20 scorer in the league with the potential to top 50 goals if everything goes his way.
 
his selection to team canada really isn't an indication of anything other than the fact that he's one of canada's top 20 forwards. nobody would dispute that.

the fact that you think he'll magically increase his production and become more consistent on another team is proof positive that you overrate him, though.

every time one of these guys is dealt, we're told that we can expect them to take off. it never happens.

on a team with a better centre where he sees the puck less, and is no longer the team's main puck carrier on the powerplay he might even end up with a few less goals.

In fairness its not even an indication of that. See Patrice Bergeron, Kris Draper, Rob Zamuner, etc.

Its not really an indication of anything, though Nash did deserve to be there.

It would be more of an indication that he is one of the top 12 or 13 forwards who are Canadian. Second to that, he's been on 2 Olympic squads and is only 26 still, and will be on at least one more Team Canada squad. Finally, he's not a role player as those players were, so they are targeting him for his combination of skills and ability to which you could even say they are complimenting him by taking complete players since his experiences in Columbus have had him playing a defensive minded game.

And I would say there are examples of players who have played in defense-first systems that go elsewhere and see more production and vice-versa where players go from offensive systems to a more defensive system and see a drop in production.

As I said, I think Nash in the right situation is a 40/80 guy. To say that Columbus is a good spot for him to reach his maximal production is a little silly. And like I had mentioned, I don't think a lot of people here watch Rick Nash, but associate him with an annually underachieving team.

He would be our best forward from the day he walked through the door.

And I take Nash over Spezza, but that's because I think Spezza is soft and goofy. Not my type of player.
 
It would be more of an indication that he is one of the top 12 or 13 forwards who are Canadian.

no, it wouldn't. as leafman cogently pointed out, they have also elected to take guys like draper, zamuner, and bergeron to international tournaments. better players than those guys have been left off the roster.

it means absolutely nothing.

Second to that, he's been on 2 Olympic squads and is only 26 still, and will be on at least one more Team Canada squad.

he may well be. nobody has said he shouldn't be.

it's just a pointless argument. that's the only point. the fact that he has played in the olympics means nothing more than the fact that he's one of canada's better players. that doesn't really say anything other than that.

robyn regehr also played in two olympics by the time he was 26. does that make him a special player, too?

nobody is denying nash is a talented player. it's just the argument that he 'isn't overrated because he is on team canada' is an absurd argument.

since his experiences in Columbus have had him playing a defensive minded game.

what?

And I would say there are examples of players who have played in defense-first systems that go elsewhere and see more production and vice-versa where players go from offensive systems to a more defensive system and see a drop in production.

show me. prove it.

and columbus was arguably a more defensive oriented team than most for 3 years under hitchcock. despite that, he had far and away the best season of his career under hitchcock (79 points -- the only time he has broken the 70 point barrier in his career). in his first full season away from hitchcock (and with it ,a less restrictive system), his production is identical to last season (when he spent 59 seasons under hitchcock). and well below his 08-09 pace when he played the full schedule with hitchcock as his coach.

As I said, I think Nash in the right situation is a 40/80 guy. To say that Columbus is a good spot for him to reach his maximal production is a little silly. And like I had mentioned, I don't think a lot of people here watch Rick Nash, but associate him with an annually underachieving team.

to say that florida was a good spot for horton, or jokinen, or bouwmeester to reach their maximal production is silly.

to say that atlanta was a good spot for hossa and kovalchuk to reach their maximal production is silly.

statsny had no problem matching nash's career high poitn total last year on a lousy colorado team.

he is a mid-to-late 20s player. he isn't suddenly going to get better because of a change in scenery.

He would be our best forward from the day he walked through the door.

nobody would disagree right now
 
Healey was funny last night when he said that it would be interesting to see Kessel play if he actually had a center to play with.
 
are you stupid? that's exactly what you said:

'Kessel got more than that (2 1sts and a second) and Seguin is comparable.'

Actually I specifically said that he was traded for 2 firsts and a second. I then stated that Seguin (who was one of those picks, not that he was traded for him straight up) is a comparable. If you want to be obtuse and split hairs over every little comment then you are pretty gay.

We know Kessel was traded for draft picks - I never said otherwise. However, we NOW know who they turned out to be and I'm comparing them. If you don't want to, that's your perogative.
 
no, it wouldn't. as leafman cogently pointed out, they have also elected to take guys like draper, zamuner, and bergeron to international tournaments. better players than those guys have been left off the roster.

it means absolutely nothing.



he may well be. nobody has said he shouldn't be.

it's just a pointless argument. that's the only point. the fact that he has played in the olympics means nothing more than the fact that he's one of canada's better players. that doesn't really say anything other than that.

robyn regehr also played in two olympics by the time he was 26. does that make him a special player, too?

nobody is denying nash is a talented player. it's just the argument that he 'isn't overrated because he is on team canada' is an absurd argument.

But Rick Nash didn't make Team Canada as a role player. He was taken as a skill player, or more arguably as a COMPLETE PLAYER. So what qualities then make him over-rated?

show me. prove it.

Kristian Huselius from Calgary>>Columbus
Mike Ribeiro from Montreal<<Dallas
Mike Cammalleri from Calgary and/or L.A.>>Montreal
Ilya Kovalchuk from Atlanta>>New Jersey
Danius Zubrus from Washington>>New Jersey
Sergei Federov from Anaheim>>Columbus<<Washington
Andrew Brunette from Minnesota<<Colorado>>Minnesota

and columbus was arguably a more defensive oriented team than most for 3 years under hitchcock. despite that, he had far and away the best season of his career under hitchcock (79 points -- the only time he has broken the 70 point barrier in his career). in his first full season away from hitchcock (and with it ,a less restrictive system), his production is identical to last season (when he spent 59 seasons under hitchcock). and well below his 08-09 pace when he played the full schedule with hitchcock as his coach.



to say that florida was a good spot for horton, or jokinen, or bouwmeester to reach their maximal production is silly.

to say that atlanta was a good spot for hossa and kovalchuk to reach their maximal production is silly.

statsny had no problem matching nash's career high poitn total last year on a lousy colorado team.

he is a mid-to-late 20s player. he isn't suddenly going to get better because of a change in scenery.

Who you play with has a lot to do with your production. So when has Nash ever had quality linemates? Hossa and Kovalchuk played together first of all, then they had Savard for some time. Even more importantly to that is centres often make their linemates better, while wingers have less chances to get those ticky-tack second assists since not all of the playmaking goes through them

My curiosity in the end is, how exactly is Rick Nash overrated? What part of his game is lacking??
 
Actually I specifically said that he was traded for 2 firsts and a second. I then stated that Seguin (who was one of those picks, not that he was traded for him straight up) is a comparable. If you want to be obtuse and split hairs over every little comment then you are pretty gay.

We know Kessel was traded for draft picks - I never said otherwise. However, we NOW know who they turned out to be and I'm comparing them. If you don't want to, that's your perogative.

you can't have it both ways. if kessel was simply traded for picks then whatever those picks turn out to be isn't what kessel was traded for.

i asked you to cite an example of a comparable prospect to kadri being traded for a comparable talent to nash. you said kessel was traded for picks, and seguin is a comparable prospect.

how else is one to take that comment? that isn't splitting hairs

and if you are now arguing that you weren't suggesting that kessel was traded for a comparable (perhaps better) prospect than kadri then you are admitting that i am right.
 
Rick Nash is overrated because everyone seems to think he is an 80-90+ point superstar, and he is paid like one, when in reality he has been a 70 point player, if not worse than that.

Saying he is overrated doesn't mean he isn't a good player. He is a very good player.

But he is held in high regard with some other players, that he just isn't as good as. He's not a franchise player.
 
But Rick Nash didn't make Team Canada as a role player. He was taken as a skill player, or more arguably as a COMPLETE PLAYER. So what qualities then make him over-rated?

because people make arguments like 'if only he was on a better team he'd be an 80 point player' when we're talking about a player who has only hit the 70 point mark once in an 8 year career.

Kristian Huselius from Calgary>>Columbus
Mike Ribeiro from Montreal<<Dallas
Mike Cammalleri from Calgary and/or L.A.>>Montreal
Ilya Kovalchuk from Atlanta>>New Jersey
Danius Zubrus from Washington>>New Jersey
Sergei Federov from Anaheim>>Columbus<<Washington
Andrew Brunette from Minnesota<<Colorado>>Minnesota

the fedorov example is ridiculous. so is the kovalchuk example.

the other guys are like a lot of players, and have seen peaks and valleys in their production. ti's like saying quebec sundin > toronto sundin, which is a ridiculous argument. or, it's like saying 08-09 nash > 09-10 nash. in fact, it's exactly like that.

it's silly to talk about a 30 year old fedorov vs. a 35 year old fedorov. and kovalchuk will rebound, there's no question about that.

the other guys might have seen spikes in their production for other teams, but on the whole their production was basically identical outside of one or two peak seasons. for instance, ribeiro had 65 points in 03-04 for the habs, and has 66 points (77 games) this for dallas.

brunette had 59 points in his final season with colorado and 61 points last year with minnesota. huselius had 66 points in his last season with clagary and 63 points last year with columbus.

these players might have had a better season here or there. but having a spike in their production, and actually being a better player are totally different things. they weren't substantively different players when they had their peak season. they just posted more points than average.

just like nash in 08-09. nobody is denying that nash can score 40 goals or approach 80 points. he has already done it. but there is a world of difference between doing it consistently, and doing it once every 5-10 years.
 
because people make arguments like 'if only he was on a better team he'd be an 80 point player' when we're talking about a player who has only hit the 70 point mark once in an 8 year career.



the fedorov example is ridiculous. so is the kovalchuk example.

the other guys are like a lot of players, and have seen peaks and valleys in their production. ti's like saying quebec sundin > toronto sundin, which is a ridiculous argument. or, it's like saying 08-09 nash > 09-10 nash. in fact, it's exactly like that.

it's silly to talk about a 30 year old fedorov vs. a 35 year old fedorov. and kovalchuk will rebound, there's no question about that.

the other guys might have seen spikes in their production for other teams, but on the whole their production was basically identical outside of one or two peak seasons. for instance, ribeiro had 65 points in 03-04 for the habs, and has 66 points (77 games) this for dallas.

brunette had 59 points in his final season with colorado and 61 points last year with minnesota. huselius had 66 points in his last season with clagary and 63 points last year with columbus.

these players might have had a better season here or there. but having a spike in their production, and actually being a better player are totally different things. they weren't substantively different players when they had their peak season. they just posted more points than average.

just like nash in 08-09. nobody is denying that nash can score 40 goals or approach 80 points. he has already done it. but there is a world of difference between doing it consistently, and doing it once every 5-10 years.

Haha.

I could see all these arguments coming from a mile away.

Fedorov was a stretch. But you can't argue that he produced slightly better after being traded from Columbus to Washington.

Kovalchuk produced at OVER a PPG and is maybe producing AT a PPG in the second half of the season.

Ribeiro had 82 and 78 point seasons on Dallas, never close to that on Montreal.
Cammalleri went over 80 points twice before Montreal.
Brunette in 3 years in Colorado went (83,63,59) then in Minnesota went (61,50,43)
Huselius had years of (77,66) in Calgary then (63,56) in Columbus

You purposely looked for the numbers that made your arguments work. I said there are examples.

The most important thing to look at for Nash is that he doesn't play with players who can support 80-90 point seasons at the moment. The only other top winger who has oddly low levels of PP production is Bobby Ryan for the Ducks and that is because Selanne takes his spot on the PP, and coincidentally is why Selanne has so many assists.

EV Production from Wingers
63 - Corey Perry
60 - Daniel Sedin
59 - Alex Ovechkin
58 - Bobby Ryan
54 - Martin St. Louis
54 - Claude Giroux
53 - Jarome Iginla
52 - Rick Nash (8th overall)

Other Notables:
46 - Alex Tanguay
45 - Patrick Kane
44 - Teemu Selanne
43 - Loui Ericksson
40 - Thomas Vanek
39 - Phil Kessel
33 - Dany Heatley
 
Furthermore Rick Nash since the lockout is a +10, on a team that has a goal differential of (-197) over that time frame.

Rick Nash is a top-10 winger in the league, hands down.
 
If we can acquire him for someone like Kadri, while balancing out the salary and not losing any key people from our current squad, I would be all for it.

If we could get him and not lose Kadri, even better.

With that said, it would never happen, but if it did, WOW.
 
Nash IS a franchise player, he's a leader, a top scorer and an extremely marketable player. Trouble is, he's paid like a superstar and plays for a team that hasn't been able to trade or draft a complementary player.
 
Haha.

I could see all these arguments coming from a mile away.

Fedorov was a stretch. But you can't argue that he produced slightly better after being traded from Columbus to Washington.

fedorov had 28 points in 50 games in his final season with columbus. fedorov had 33 points in 52 games in his first full season in washington.

Kovalchuk produced at OVER a PPG and is maybe producing AT a PPG in the second half of the season.

and yet he is playing on a better team, with better players.

it's silly to use a limited sample, though. kovalchuk is having by far the worst statistical season of his career. we're talking about a multiple time 50 goal scorer who might not hit 30 this year... who hasn't scored less than 38 since his second season in the league in 02-03.

Ribeiro had 82 and 78 point seasons on Dallas, never close to that on Montreal.

some guys click on a particular line for a particular period of time. it doesn't mean they got any better when they produced at those levels, or any worse when they stopped doing it.

some guys improve as they get mature. ribeiro could also be a guy who had one or two years where things just worked. kind of like nash scoring 79 points in 08-09 and not doing in the two seasons since.

i don't think anybody's saying ribeiro is a 'worse' hockey player now because he probably won't hit 70 points this year.

Cammalleri went over 80 points twice before Montreal.

and had a 60 point season right in between them, just like he's had in both of his season with montreal.

Brunette in 3 years in Colorado went (83,63,59) then in Minnesota went (61,50,43)

brunette's also in his late 30s. he had one big outlier with colorado. other than that, from the late 90s until this season he's floated anywehre between 46 and 69 points. he did that in 2 of his 3 years with colorado.

if your argument is that nash might go to a team and click with linemates and post a one or two outlier years like bertuzzi then nobody will disagree with you. the question is whether he'll do it consistently. you are still yet to show me a guy who actually stepped up his production simply on account of going to a better team. a lot of guys spike for a year two. hell, nash has already done that.

Huselius had years of (77,66) in Calgary then (63,56) in Columbus

huselius followed up a 66 point season on a better calgary team with a 63 point season on a worse columbus team.

he was the same player.

You purposely looked for the numbers that made your arguments work. I said there are examples.

i didn't look for anything.

i simply looked into your examples.

nash has already proven that if he clicks on a line he can have a 40 goal 80 point season. but he isn't a 40 goal 80 point player, because that connotes that he does that consistently, or expectedly. that isn't the case with a single one of the players you listed.

they all spiked for one season, or two seasons. and had other seasons on the team they spiked with, where they produced at their career norms.

the thing is, it really has very little to do with quality of team, and in a lot of cases, quality of linemates (i.e. no discernible jump in kunitz's production going from anaheim's second line to crosby's wing; no change in perry's production when getzlaf went down). sometimes it's just a matter of clicking with the right guys.

The most important thing to look at for Nash is that he doesn't play with players who can support 80-90 point seasons at the moment. The only other top winger who has oddly low levels of PP production is Bobby Ryan for the Ducks and that is because Selanne takes his spot on the PP, and coincidentally is why Selanne has so many assists.

EV Production from Wingers
63 - Corey Perry
60 - Daniel Sedin
59 - Alex Ovechkin
58 - Bobby Ryan
54 - Martin St. Louis
54 - Claude Giroux
53 - Jarome Iginla
52 - Rick Nash (8th overall)

Other Notables:
46 - Alex Tanguay
45 - Patrick Kane
44 - Teemu Selanne
43 - Loui Ericksson
40 - Thomas Vanek
39 - Phil Kessel
33 - Dany Heatley

not sure what these stats tell us. you look at a guy like kessel... and i think that nash is better than kessel (for now, at least)... who is playing on a powerplay about as inept as columbus's, and kessel has been much more productive on the pp.

why is that? it isn't like kessel has been playing with a bunch of world beaters on special teams.
 
Back
Top