• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Nash IS a franchise player, he's a leader, a top scorer and an extremely marketable player. Trouble is, he's paid like a superstar and plays for a team that hasn't been able to trade or draft a complementary player.
Real franchise players produce like franchise players even without a "complementary player".

See Sundin, Mats.

Very good players, like Nash or Kessel, can give you great production, but will never give you elite production without a lot of help from a real franchise player.
 
fedorov had 28 points in 50 games in his final season with columbus. fedorov had 33 points in 52 games in his first full season in washington.



and yet he is playing on a better team, with better players.

it's silly to use a limited sample, though. kovalchuk is having by far the worst statistical season of his career. we're talking about a multiple time 50 goal scorer who might not hit 30 this year... who hasn't scored less than 38 since his second season in the league in 02-03.



some guys click on a particular line for a particular period of time. it doesn't mean they got any better when they produced at those levels, or any worse when they stopped doing it.

some guys improve as they get mature. ribeiro could also be a guy who had one or two years where things just worked. kind of like nash scoring 79 points in 08-09 and not doing in the two seasons since.

i don't think anybody's saying ribeiro is a 'worse' hockey player now because he probably won't hit 70 points this year.



and had a 60 point season right in between them, just like he's had in both of his season with montreal.



brunette's also in his late 30s. he had one big outlier with colorado. other than that, from the late 90s until this season he's floated anywehre between 46 and 69 points. he did that in 2 of his 3 years with colorado.

if your argument is that nash might go to a team and click with linemates and post a one or two outlier years like bertuzzi then nobody will disagree with you. the question is whether he'll do it consistently. you are still yet to show me a guy who actually stepped up his production simply on account of going to a better team. a lot of guys spike for a year two. hell, nash has already done that.



huselius followed up a 66 point season on a better calgary team with a 63 point season on a worse columbus team.

he was the same player.



i didn't look for anything.

i simply looked into your examples.

nash has already proven that if he clicks on a line he can have a 40 goal 80 point season. but he isn't a 40 goal 80 point player, because that connotes that he does that consistently, or expectedly. that isn't the case with a single one of the players you listed.

they all spiked for one season, or two seasons. and had other seasons on the team they spiked with, where they produced at their career norms.

the thing is, it really has very little to do with quality of team, and in a lot of cases, quality of linemates (i.e. no discernible jump in kunitz's production going from anaheim's second line to crosby's wing; no change in perry's production when getzlaf went down). sometimes it's just a matter of clicking with the right guys.



not sure what these stats tell us. you look at a guy like kessel... and i think that nash is better than kessel (for now, at least)... who is playing on a powerplay about as inept as columbus's, and kessel has been much more productive on the pp.

why is that? it isn't like kessel has been playing with a bunch of world beaters on special teams.

I would say that it says teams make sure to watch him on the powerplay because he has a lack of complimentary pieces out there with him. Rick Nash is puck possession player whereas Phil Kessel isn't/

Next, over the past 4 seasons, Nash is a 36/70 guy (82GP 38/75).

And to that, over the past three seasons Nash has been one of the top producing LW's at even strength.

He'd easily be a PPG player in the right situation.
 
Forget even about trading. If you were Brian Burke and Nash was a UFA this summer, would you sign him to a seven year deal at $7.8M per season?

Done and done. Not even a question.

We traded 2, count em, TWO 1st rounders and a 2nd rounder for Phil Kessel. You wouldn't trade ONE for a 26 year old star, who is better than Kessel??
 
Real franchise players produce like franchise players even without a "complementary player".

See Sundin, Mats.

Very good players, like Nash or Kessel, can give you great production, but will never give you elite production without a lot of help from a real franchise player.

It's much easier for centres to get assists due to the nature of the position.
 
I would say that it says teams make sure to watch him on the powerplay because he has a lack of complimentary pieces out there with him. Rick Nash is puck possession player whereas Phil Kessel isn't/

this is just guesswork and assumptions.

the thing is, if there's any reason to think his production might go up on another team on the PP it would be specifically because he isn't the guy you want on the puck, because he's a lot more dangerous close to the net.

Next, over the past 4 seasons, Nash is a 36/70 guy (82GP 38/75).

and yet over those four seasons he has only hit the 70 point mark once.

And to that, over the past three seasons Nash has been one of the top producing LW's at even strength.

not sure why this matters.

again, nobody is denying that he's a very good first line winger or one of the better forwards in hockey.

He'd easily be a PPG player in the right situation.

why was 08-09 different for columbus than any other year?

nobody is saying he can't score at a point per game pace. but then, he's already done that. the question is whether giong to another team and playing with better players would make him a lock to do it.

and the answer to that is almost certainly no, because scoring trends basically never work that way.

he might well do it.

but he migh twell do it on columbus, too. just like he already has.
 
Done and done. Not even a question.

We traded 2, count em, TWO 1st rounders and a 2nd rounder for Phil Kessel. You wouldn't trade ONE for a 26 year old star, who is better than Kessel??

kadri is not the same as the leafs' 2012 first round pick.

kadri has a lot more value than a draft pick one year advance.

kadri had more trade value on draft day 2009 than the leafs' first rounder in 2010, as evidenced by the fact that burke wouldn't trade the kadri pick for kessel, but would trade the 2010 pick for him.
 
kadri is not the same as the leafs' 2012 first round pick.

kadri has a lot more value than a draft pick one year advance.

kadri had more trade value on draft day 2009 than the leafs' first rounder in 2010, as evidenced by the fact that burke wouldn't trade the kadri pick for kessel, but would trade the 2010 pick for him.

I get that the kid has gotten a lot of hype from people in this area. Being passionate about our top prospect is good. But don't be fooled by his promise.

On draft day it was Kadri and Kaberle -for- Kessel which Burke balked at.

Kadri has been outshone this season by quite a few rookies. And I doubt next year that he produces at the level of whoever the top rookie scorer is.

He's good. But I doubt he'll EVER be Rick Nash good.
 
I get that the kid has gotten a lot of hype from people in this area. Being passionate about our top prospect is good. But don't be fooled by his promise.

i don't need a lecture on the matter.

i didn't say a damn thing about him until i had a chance to actually watch the kid play.

he plays with a tenacity and level of skill i have never seen before in a leafs forward prospect. this has nothing to do with 'hype,' and everything to do with the fact that he sees the ice and handles the puck as well as any player on this team right now.

and he's only 20-odd games into his career.

On draft day it was Kadri and Kaberle -for- Kessel which Burke balked at.

ok?

Kadri has been outshone this season by quite a few rookies. And I doubt next year that he produces at the level of whoever the top rookie scorer is.

so what? mike johnson tied patrick elias in points in their rookie season back in 97-98. steven stamkos struggled to crack 40 points as a rookie

tyler seguin probably won't even hit 25.

in 98-99 hossa finished 7th in rookie scoring... behind the likes of bill muckalt, jan hrdina and brendan morrison.

that same year lecavalier was 10th. briere was 13th, outscored by mike watt. jokinen was 15th.

in 2000 shane willis was 2nd in rookie scoring, outproducing havlat, the sedins, gaborik. that year denis shvidki has as many points as scott hartnell.

in 02-03 cammalleri managed just 8 points in 28 games. mike rupp was a rookie that year as well and matched his production.

that other rookies are outproducing kadri means little.

in any event, had kadri played a full spate of games at the nhl level, assuming that he would maintain the same clip he has produced at in the 26 games he has played in this season, he would be just outside of the top 10 (11th overall in rookie scoring) with 37 points.

amongst rookie forwards he'd be in 9th. and only skinner and hall are as young/younger.

He's good. But I doubt he'll EVER be Rick Nash good.

nash had 39 points in 74 games as a rookie

kadri paces out to 34 points in 74 games.

as far as kadri never reaching the same level of performance as nash.... i think that prognosticating kadri as a 70 point forward is a very reasonable, and not at all exaggerated, prediction. it also may be on the conservative side.

that is based on what he did in the ahl this year, and his track record in junior.

but of course people will cling to nash's 'all around game', and continue to assume that 'well, if only he got out of that shit hole in columbus he'd really take off.'

remember... people have said the same thing about all of florida's young players for years.
 
i don't need a lecture on the matter.

i didn't say a damn thing about him until i had a chance to actually watch the kid play.

he plays with a tenacity and level of skill i have never seen before in a leafs forward prospect. this has nothing to do with 'hype,' and everything to do with the fact that he sees the ice and handles the puck as well as any player on this team right now.

and he's only 20-odd games into his career.



ok?



so what? mike johnson tied patrick elias in points in their rookie season back in 97-98. steven stamkos struggled to crack 40 points as a rookie

tyler seguin probably won't even hit 25.

in 98-99 hossa finished 7th in rookie scoring... behind the likes of bill muckalt, jan hrdina and brendan morrison.

that same year lecavalier was 10th. briere was 13th, outscored by mike watt. jokinen was 15th.

in 2000 shane willis was 2nd in rookie scoring, outproducing havlat, the sedins, gaborik. that year denis shvidki has as many points as scott hartnell.

in 02-03 cammalleri managed just 8 points in 28 games. mike rupp was a rookie that year as well and matched his production.

that other rookies are outproducing kadri means little.

in any event, had kadri played a full spate of games at the nhl level, assuming that he would maintain the same clip he has produced at in the 26 games he has played in this season, he would be just outside of the top 10 (11th overall in rookie scoring) with 37 points.

amongst rookie forwards he'd be in 9th. and only skinner and hall are as young/younger.



nash had 39 points in 74 games as a rookie

kadri paces out to 34 points in 74 games.

as far as kadri never reaching the same level of performance as nash.... i think that prognosticating kadri as a 70 point forward is a very reasonable, and not at all exaggerated, prediction. it also may be on the conservative side.

that is based on what he did in the ahl this year, and his track record in junior.

but of course people will cling to nash's 'all around game', and continue to assume that 'well, if only he got out of that shit hole in columbus he'd really take off.'

remember... people have said the same thing about all of florida's young players for years.

So next year Kadri will pace out to 40 goals?

Nash stepped right into the show at 18 and never looked back. Kadri will play his first full season at 21.

Nash is a little overpaid I would say, but there was a reason Columbus paid that. Nash would be a god in this city.
 
Done and done. Not even a question.

We traded 2, count em, TWO 1st rounders and a 2nd rounder for Phil Kessel. You wouldn't trade ONE for a 26 year old star, who is better than Kessel??
Kadri does not = a first rounder. A first rounder is a lottery ticket. Nazem Kadri is a 20 year-old who scored at a point-a-game pace in his first professional season in the AHL, and who has already been the difference maker in mutiple wins at the NHL level. And again, they key point being that Nash is signed for four years longer than Kessel, and is getting paid $2.4M more than him per season to produce marginally more than him. Forget trading Kadri for him, if Nash was a free agent and Burke signed him to that idiotic contract, I'd be outraged.

It's much easier for centres to get assists due to the nature of the position.
That has to be the worst excuse for a player's lack of production that I've ever seen.
 
So next year Kadri will pace out to 40 goals?

i think nazem kadri will hit 60 points next year, just like nash (almost) did in his second season.

i very much doubt kadri will ever score 40 goals in a season, but that hardly matters.

Nash stepped right into the show at 18 and never looked back. Kadri will play his first full season at 21.

this is a very, very misleading statement for a number of reasons.

kadri's first season (and it now counts as a full season, he has lost his rookie eligibility) was one year later, relative in his development to nash's.

of course, nash was infinitely more suited to jumping into the nhl immediately than kadri was, given the fact that nash is much larger, and filled out much earlier.

kadri wouldn't be the first young player who, on account of size, required a little extra time in the ohl.

that aside, on plenty of ohter teams kadri very well might have spent the entire season in the nhl. that he spent as much in the ahl as he did says more of burke than of just about anything else. just look at boston -- they kept seguin on the roster all year, despite the fact that, unlike the leafs, they didn't really need his offence to be competitive, and they're a contending team burying him on the bottom line.

that kadri won't play a 'full' season until 21 is no fault of his own, and says nothing about his ability to play a year earlier. it just speaks to the fact that his general manager is more inclined to play prospects in the ahl than most other general managers.
 
12 guys are doing it right now.

a few more are just shy (carter, and tavares).

and those 12 does not include players who are over the age of 25, or 25 and under, who have done it in the past but aren't doing it this year.
 
Nash was a PPG player at 21.

in an abbreviated season and has only managed to do that again just once in the five seasons since.

the question, again, isn't whether rick nash can score 40 goals or 80 points.

the question is whether or not he can do it consistently enough to be labelled a 40 goal 80 point player.

i have a very difficult time doing that, when the player has only topped 70 points once in an 8 year career.
 
My view on Nash is that he is a 35/70 guy year-in-year out.

In his up years he's 40/80. Down years 30/65.

Every year like clock-work. And he's 26.

If Kadri puts up a 25/70 pace year ONCE by that time I'll be ecstatic. Nash has done that 5 times now, had another 30/60, and a 40/57 year.

On Columbus.
 
On Columbus

Are people not tired of making this argument yet?

Seriously? Didn't I hear the same argument about Scott Gomez, Nathan Horton, and basically every offensive under achiever (or more accurately, every player on a shit team who had only ever been able to live up to expectations 1-2 times in their careers) that has changed teams over the last 10 years?

But this time would be different.

Riiiight.
 
Back
Top