• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

yes, nash is a 35 goal 70 point guy year in, year out.

that isn't 'your view' that is proven fact. i'm not going to split hairs over a 66 point season vs. a 70 point season.

still, that's the high end -- he isn't scoring 70 points in 75 games, he's scoring ~65 points in 75 games. so we're talking about a ~70 point scorer.

the thing is, i think he'd be the exact same player on any other team in the league. in good years he'll score 80 points. in most years he'll float around the 70 mark.

nobody is saying nash isn't an excellent hockey player. but there is a presumption that 'if only he weren't on columbus' then the real rick nash would shine through. i am left with no doubts whatsoever that he would probably have scored some big playoff goals and had some impressive playoff rounds on a better team.

i don't think, however, that he would have much more than 259 goals and 488 points that he currently has.

a year or two ago you could have spoken of his potential and room for growth, but the time for that has past, imo.

26 seems to be the magic year for players.

the only guys currently playing i can find who bested a point per game for the first time after the age of 26 are st louis (and i think we can agree he's an anomaly for a bunch of reasons) and ribeiro (he did it at 27).

savard, bertuzzi, the sedins and marleau all eclisped a point per game for the first time at 26.

iginla was 24.

zetterberg was 25.

edit: briere was 28, though imo fits into the same category as st. louis (given his size limitations)
 
yes, nash is a 35 goal 70 point guy year in, year out.

that isn't 'your view' that is proven fact. i'm not going to split hairs over a 66 point season vs. a 70 point season.

still, that's the high end -- he isn't scoring 70 points in 75 games, he's scoring ~65 points in 75 games. so we're talking about a ~70 point scorer.

the thing is, i think he'd be the exact same player on any other team in the league. in good years he'll score 80 points. in most years he'll float around the 70 mark.

nobody is saying nash isn't an excellent hockey player. but there is a presumption that 'if only he weren't on columbus' then the real rick nash would shine through. i am left with no doubts whatsoever that he would probably have scored some big playoff goals and had some impressive playoff rounds on a better team.

i don't think, however, that he would have much more than 259 goals and 488 points that he currently has.

a year or two ago you could have spoken of his potential and room for growth, but the time for that has past, imo.

26 seems to be the magic year for players.

the only guys currently playing i can find who bested a point per game for the first time after the age of 26 are st louis (and i think we can agree he's an anomaly for a bunch of reasons) and ribeiro (he did it at 27).

savard, bertuzzi, the sedins and marleau all eclisped a point per game for the first time at 26.

iginla was 24.

zetterberg was 25.

edit: briere was 28, though imo fits into the same category as st. louis (given his size limitations)

And every single one of those guys had elite linemates, save for maybe Iginla. Contextually it isn't even in the same ballpark.

Tell me one legit first line talent Nash plays with.
 
marleau didn't have an elite linemate when he did in 05-06, thornton was acqured around the 25 game mark, and they played on separate lin es.

iginla didn't have an elite linemate.

hell, zetterberg didn't, either. in his breakout year he and datsyuk were centering separate lines.

i'm not going to deny that it obviously helps to be playing with better players. but these guys have all put up 80+ points consistently, whether they have played with another top player or not.

staal has consistently posted ~80+ with or without top players.

same with st. louis.

same with richards.

same with kopitar

same with thornton

same with gaborik.

parise, too.
 
marleau didn't have an elite linemate when he did in 05-06, thornton was acqured around the 25 game mark, and they played on separate lin es.

iginla didn't have an elite linemate.

hell, zetterberg didn't, either. in his breakout year he and datsyuk were centering separate lines.

i'm not going to deny that it obviously helps to be playing with better players. but these guys have all put up 80+ points consistently, whether they have played with another top player or not.

staal has consistently posted ~80+ with or without top players.

same with st. louis.

same with richards.

same with kopitar

same with thornton

same with gaborik.

parise, too.

Marleau had 44 PP points that season.

Zetterberg had 35 PP points.

Quite obviously they were cashing in on playing with elite players in PP situations.

The year Staal put up his 100 points he had 40 PP points. Since then he has cracked 80 points once in 4 years.

Now lets run through this list of players of interest who these guys play with the most ES since 07-08:

Marleau - Pavelski, Setoguchi, Thornton, Heatley
Iginla - Tanguay, Jokinen, Cammalleri, Conroy, Huselius
Zetterberg - Datsyuk, Holmstrom, Franzen, Hossa
Staal - Cole, Whitney, T. Ruutu, Samsonov
St. Louis - Lecavalier, Richards, Stamkos, Malone, Prospal
Richards - Lecavalier, St. Louis, Neal, Ericksson
Kopitar - Brown, J. Williams, Smyth, Lokitionov
Thornton - Cheechoo, Michalek, Marleau, Heatley, Setoguchi
Gaborik - Dubinsky, Prospal in NY; Koivu and Brunette in Minny
Parise - Langenbrunner, Zajak

Nash - Peca, Zherdev, Malholtra, Huselius, Vermette, Brassard, Voracek

I think out of that entire list, Nash, Iginla, and possibly Staal have had the worst linemates. However, at least Staal played with someone like Whitney who could get the puck to him.
 
And just for clarification, how would you term a guy like Kessel? 30/60?

What would his top-end level be in your mind??

I mean, we all talk about "if he only had a great centreman". But yet for Nash it won't have any affect on him?
 
you're just throwing a bunch of players who have played for the same team at the same time without any context whatsoever.

thornton has posted big time numbers whether it's glen murray and mike knuble flanking him, or jonathan cheechoo and ryan clowe.

interestingly, thornton's lowest production has been on a line with heatley and marleau. go figure.

same with iginla .. whether they have him with jokinen and tanguay, or stajan, or langkow and huseilus, his numbers are always right up there.

the groups surrounding gaborik (who was producing long before koivu entered the picture, and both with and without brunette), parise (langenbrunner and zajak? seriously?), kopitar, and richards since he became a star are, at best, slightly better than the likes of huselius, umburger and voracek.
 
Last edited:
And just for clarification, how would you term a guy like Kessel? 30/60?

What would his top-end level be in your mind??

I mean, we all talk about "if he only had a great centreman". But yet for Nash it won't have any affect on him?

i would say that if kessel doesn't top 35 goals or 65 points within the next year or two then he's pretty much a 35 goal, 65 point player.

to be entirely fair, though, you'd have to go back to 03-04 to find the last time columbus saddled him with a centre as shitty as bozak has been this year.

they brought in fedorov to at least give him somebody to play with, even if fedorov was diminished.

but, yeah, the clock's ticking on kessel. it's put up or shut up time.
 
you're just throwing a bunch of players who have played for the same team at the same time without any context whatsoever.

thornton has posted big time numbers whether it's glen murray and mike knuble flanking him, or jonathan cheechoo and ryan clowe.

interestingly, thornton's lowest production has been on a line with heatley and marleau. go figure.

same with iginla .. whether they have him with jokinen and tanguay, or stajan, or langkow and huseilus, his numbers are always right up there.

the groups surrounding gaborik (who was producing long before koivu entered the picture, and both with and without brunette), parise (langenbrunner and zajak? seriously?), kopitar, and richards since he became a star are, at best, slightly better than the likes of huselius, umburger and voracek.

Throwing out random names?

http://www.dobberhockey.com

Take a look at the line combos.

Nash has never played significant minutes with Umberger btw.

Furthermore, when San Jose stacked their line, they began to see diminishing returns because it was too easy to let other team match up with them strategically. That's now why they have separated them.
 
i would say that if kessel doesn't top 35 goals or 65 points within the next year or two then he's pretty much a 35 goal, 65 point player.

to be entirely fair, though, you'd have to go back to 03-04 to find the last time columbus saddled him with a centre as shitty as bozak has been this year.

they brought in fedorov to at least give him somebody to play with, even if fedorov was diminished.

but, yeah, the clock's ticking on kessel. it's put up or shut up time.

After everything you just said, you call Kessel 35/65 now?

Kessel passed 35 ONE TIME. Passed 65 points NEVER.

Kessel is a 30-35/60 guy right now from what he's done. However, I see him as a 40/75 guy on average for 3-4 seasons with a good centreman. With a good centreman Nash can average 45/80, with his top years having him break 50/90.
 
Throwing out random names?

i didn't say that. i said you pulled out a bunch of players who played on the same team as the 'star players' listed... without any context whatsoever

Nash has never played significant minutes with Umberger btw.

by never you mean... frequently in 09-10.

Furthermore, when San Jose stacked their line, they began to see diminishing returns because it was too easy to let other team match up with them strategically. That's now why they have separated them.

that's a bunch of high winded BS

your argument is that when you put good players together they produce more.

three very good players were paired together (they have played nearly 30% of their total ice time together) and produced less.

they split them up because they weren't scoring. that's about it.

and even still, they've played close to 30% of the season together.

http://www.dobberhockey.com

Take a look at the line combos.

perhaps you should do the same.
 
After everything you just said, you call Kessel 35/65 now?

Kessel passed 35 ONE TIME. Passed 65 points NEVER.

Kessel is a 30-35/60 guy right now from what he's done. However, I see him as a 40/75 guy on average for 3-4 seasons with a good centreman. With a good centreman Nash can average 45/80, with his top years having him break 50/90.


oh, excuse me.

phil kessel is a 32 goal, 61 point player.

it doesn't make a difference.

i went with his career high in goals and paced out the points. we know phil kessel can score 35 goals and top 60 points.

he's been a shade below that the past two seasons.

if you want to attribute that to playing with savard as opposed to play with bozak all the power to you.

so, fine, rick nash will be a perennial 73 point player if he plays with a better centre.



and it amazes me that somebody can argue so virulently against the notion that rick nash is overrated... and then say that an 8 year vet with career highs of 41 goals and 79 points has 50 goal 90 point potential.

just like heatley and thornton would maximize their production by being paired together, right?

agian, if you want to argue that one day rick nash will go to a team, get to play with a couple of players who they click with, catch lightning in a bottle and have one or two fluke seasons then all the power to you. that's a very suspect argument. it has happened exactly two times in recent years.
 
Last edited:
This argument has gotten so off track. If you have to go to these lengths to try and suggest Nash is better than he actually has been, its a pretty good bet the people who are saying he is overrated are right.

If a guy is held in a higher regard than the type of player he has actually been, he is overrated. And Nash is most definitely held in a higher regard than 70 point player.

I mean think of it like this. 3 years splits:

Ribiero: 226 gms, 59 gls, 199 pts (82 gms, 21 gls, 72 pts)
Nash: 229 gms, 95 gls, 212 pts (82 gms, 34 gls, 76 pts)


2 year splits

Ribiero: 144 gms, 37 gls, 121 pts (82 gms, 21 gls, 69 pts)
Nash: 151 gms, 55 gls, 133 pts (82 gms, 30 gls, 72 pts)
 
And just to show how out to lunch the linemate idea is. This year Nash has played mostly with Brassard, Voracek, Huselius and Vermette. In his big year 2 years ago he played mostly with Huselius, Malhotra and Umberger.

His linemates are better now, and he is producing less.
 
Further,

Kessel w/ Savard: 70 gms, 30 gls, 60 pts (82 gms, 35 gls, 70 pts)
Kessel w/o Savard: 149 gms, 61 gls, 116 pts (82 gms, 34 gls, 64 pts)

The difference between playing with a 90 point, star set up man, and Tyler Bozak was a goal and 6 points. Most players don't substantially effect the production of other players. Kessel could have easily been a 40 goal 80 point player this year, if he didn't go into those ridiculously extended slumps, where he loses all confidence and starts to play like a bitch for 1/4 of the season. That was his biggest problem. Not Tyler Bozak.
 
oh, excuse me.

phil kessel is a 32 goal, 61 point player.

it doesn't make a difference.

i went with his career high in goals and paced out the points. we know phil kessel can score 35 goals and top 60 points.

he's been a shade below that the past two seasons.

How?

He hasn't done it in two seasons here. And while I think he can you're making an argument based on your beliefs and not actual numbers.


if you want to attribute that to playing with savard as opposed to play with bozak all the power to you.

so, fine, rick nash will be a perennial 73 point player if he plays with a better centre.

I said I see him as a 45/80 player with a better centre. Just like I see Kessel as a 40/75 player with a better centre.


and it amazes me that somebody can argue so virulently against the notion that rick nash is overrated... and then say that an 8 year vet with career highs of 41 goals and 79 points has 50 goal 90 point potential.

Saying he is an 8-year vet is deceiving. He's 26 and has never played with quality linemates.

Vermette? 2nd-line centre at best.
Huselius? Arguably a first-liner.
Brassard? 22 years old.
Voracek? 21 years old.
Umberger? Probably the arguably best played Nash has had. Plays about 10% of his shifts with Nash this year, about 30% last year, about 20% the year prior.


just like heatley and thornton would maximize their production by being paired together, right?

Heatley has played with good centres (Savard, Spezza, Thornton) all his life. He put up ridiculous numbers on the NHL's top line for two seasons. PPG player last year w/ 39 goals. Split them up this year to spread out the offense since they weren't producing enough to have reason to keep them together.

agian, if you want to argue that one day rick nash will go to a team, get to play with a couple of players who they click with, catch lightning in a bottle and have one or two fluke seasons then all the power to you. that's a very suspect argument. it has happened exactly two times in recent years.

I said he has the potential to have top seasons at 90pts. On average I would see him as a 40-45/80 guy, which is quite reasonable.
 
How?

He hasn't done it in two seasons here. And while I think he can you're making an argument based on your beliefs and not actual numbers.

no i'm not. like i said, and leafman has now proved, his numbers between his last year in boston and first two years in toronto are substantively the same. basically identical.

I said I see him as a 45/80 player with a better centre. Just like I see Kessel as a 40/75 player with a better centre.

see, that's an assumption, not what i said.

Saying he is an 8-year vet is deceiving. He's 26 and has never played with quality linemates.

saying he is an 8-year vet is fact, not deception.
 
This argument has gotten so off track. If you have to go to these lengths to try and suggest Nash is better than he actually has been, its a pretty good bet the people who are saying he is overrated are right.

If a guy is held in a higher regard than the type of player he has actually been, he is overrated. And Nash is most definitely held in a higher regard than 70 point player.

I mean think of it like this. 3 years splits:

Ribiero: 226 gms, 59 gls, 199 pts (82 gms, 21 gls, 72 pts)
Nash: 229 gms, 95 gls, 212 pts (82 gms, 34 gls, 76 pts)


2 year splits

Ribiero: 144 gms, 37 gls, 121 pts (82 gms, 21 gls, 69 pts)
Nash: 151 gms, 55 gls, 133 pts (82 gms, 30 gls, 72 pts)

34/76 is much more valuable than 21/72 and only provides support that due to the nature of the centre position, he has the ability to get more assists.

Let's for instance take their seasons this year and break them down a bit further:

Ribeiro: 78 GP, 18 G, 50 A, 68 PTS, -4 (82 GP, 19 G, 53 A, 71 PTS, -4)
Nash: 75 GP, 32 G, 34 A, 66 PTS, +2 (82 GP, 35 G, 37 A, 72 PTS, +2)


Ribeiro PP: 78 GP, 7 G, 15 A, 22 PTS (82 GP, 7 G, 16 A, 23 PTS)
Nash PP: 75 GP, 6 G, 8 A, 14 PTS (82 GP, 6 G, 8 A, 14 PTS)


Ribeiro ES: 78 GP, 11 G, 35 A, 46 PTS (82 GP, 12 G, 37 A, 49 PTS)
Nash ES: 75 GP, 26 G, 26 A, 52 PTS (82 GP, 28 G, 28 A, 56 PTS)


Ribeiro Linemates: 143 GP, 51 G, 53 A, 104 PTS (82 GP, 29 G, 30 A, 59 PTS)
Nash Linemates: 148 GP, 30 G, 61 A, 90 PTS (82 GP, 17 G, 34 A, 51 PTS)


So, with more scoring from his linemates and with a better PP line-up, Ribeiro produces less and has a (-) rating on a team that gives up 0.3 more goals/game.

Add to that 35/72 >> 19/71.

And Ribeiro is 30.
 
Spin away.

The bottom line is Nash has been much closer to a Ribiero type player in terms of effectiveness the last 3 years, than the superstars he is compared to.

You can try and justify all you want, why he has only been Ribeiro-esq in terms of effectiveness as a player, but it doesn't change how effective he has actually been.
 
i guess henrik sedin is a lot less valuable than daniel sedin...

the 35 goal 70 point > 25 goal 70 point argument is ridiculous.
 
Further,

Kessel w/ Savard: 70 gms, 30 gls, 60 pts (82 gms, 35 gls, 70 pts)
Kessel w/o Savard: 149 gms, 61 gls, 116 pts (82 gms, 34 gls, 64 pts)

The difference between playing with a 90 point, star set up man, and Tyler Bozak was a goal and 6 points. Most players don't substantially effect the production of other players. Kessel could have easily been a 40 goal 80 point player this year, if he didn't go into those ridiculously extended slumps, where he loses all confidence and starts to play like a bitch for 1/4 of the season. That was his biggest problem. Not Tyler Bozak.

Look at Rick Nash is his last 15 games, since Columbus has went into their slump. 3 goals in 15 games. Kessel has gone up and down all year and has had hot and cold stretches all along.

Nash played for four straight months at a 43/84 pace, from November-February.
 
Back
Top