• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Spin away.

The bottom line is Nash has been much closer to a Ribiero type player in terms of effectiveness the last 3 years, than the superstars he is compared to.

You can try and justify all you want, why he has only been Ribeiro-esq in terms of effectiveness as a player, but it doesn't change how effective he has actually been.

You truly believe that?
 
Believe it?

The facts are the facts. Its what the numbers show.

The fact that you, and many other people, think Nash is better than what he has actually accomplished, is exactly why he is overrated.

Thats the whole point.
 
I will say though that a player who scores a greater number of goals and a comparable amount of points to a player more reliant on assists is almost invariably the more valuable player.
 
I will say though that a player who scores a greater number of goals and a comparable amount of points to a player more reliant on assists is almost invariably the more valuable player.

No doubt. My point wasn't that Ribero is better than Nash. I was just contextualizing Nash's production.

Here, using hockey-reference's goals created stat, the last two years:

Nash: 151 gms 52 gc (82 gms, 28 gc)
Kessel: 149 gms, 49 gc (82 gms, 27 gc)
Sharp: 153 gm, 51 gc (82 gms, 27 gc)
Vanek: 149 gms, 46 gc (82 gms, 25 gc)
Ribeiro:144 gms, 42 gc (82 gms, 24 gc)

Thats the kind of player he has been.
 
And I agree with you. Just felt that it needed to be said again, that's all.

Interestingly enough, this is the Leafs Goals Created list from this season:

1. Phil Kessel - 25
2. Mikhail Grabovski - 24
3. Nikolai Kulemin - 23
4. Clarke MacArthur - 22

Talk about a balanced offensive attack this season...
 
no i'm not. like i said, and leafman has now proved, his numbers between his last year in boston and first two years in toronto are substantively the same. basically identical.

see, that's an assumption, not what i said.



saying he is an 8-year vet is fact, not deception.

You're terming it to try and say he isn't going to improve at all, when that isn't the case. He's 26, don't downplay that.
 
"But...but....but....but...he COULD be better! That's why he's not overrated!"

He's not overrated because he produces at a top 25 level on one of the annually worst teams in the league. While being responsible in all zones. Rick Nash is a two-way player who has NEVER had an elite teammate.

He's a complete player.
 
Nash isn't a good two way player.

2009-10: Gaon/60 - 3.15 (2nd last among Jackets forwards who played 50+ games)
2010-11: 2.73 (4th last)
 
Yeah, Nash has been pretty bad from a defensive standpoint ever since he was in the OHL.

I think that he only gets attributed the two-way moniker because he's pretty physical. But a guy like Todd Bertuzzi has been a defensive liability for years despite at one point being the game's most dominant power forward.
 
sounds like gilmour has been listening to Doug McLean too much.

Nash is very good... but he's right up there with Bouwmeester as the league's most overrated player.
 
So then how exactly does his plus/minus consistently rank as at the top on his team yearly?

Especially when his team consistently has a negative ratio of GF vs. GA. How is that explained?
 
You're terming it to try and say he isn't going to improve at all, when that isn't the case. He's 26, don't downplay that.

i've already addressed.

objectively speaking, breaking out after the age of 26 is very unlikely.

ribeiro has done it, and two guys who are amongst the smallest forwards in the league have done it... i think you can add whitney to that list. maybe stillman?

regardless, it's a very limited list.
 
So then how exactly does his plus/minus consistently rank as at the top on his team yearly?

Especially when his team consistently has a negative ratio of GF vs. GA. How is that explained?

Because it doesn't?

2002-03: -27 (18th - worst on Columbus)
2003-04: -35 (18th - worst on Columbus)
2005-06: +5 (3rd)
2006-07: -8 (T-10th)
2007-08: +2 (5th)
2008-09: +11 (T-3rd)
2009-10: -2 (T-6th)
2010-11: +2 (6th)

And the only reason his totals are as respectable as they are are due to even strength scoring. He's still a defensive nightmare though.
 
He produces offensively while not being a defensive liability to his team.

Kessel is a -29 over the past two seasons. Meaning in order to produce he puts his team at risk defensively.
 
I will say though that a player who scores a greater number of goals and a comparable amount of points to a player more reliant on assists is almost invariably the more valuable player.

sometimes. perhaps with guys in the 50-60 point range.

but i have a hard time justifying arguments like cheechoo was more or as valuable as thornton, or daniel sedin is more valuable than henrik, or perry is more valuable than getzlaf, or stamkos is more valuable than st. louis, or carter is more valuable than giroux, (and so on).

if you're looking at a 40 goal 60 point player vs a 20 goal 60 point player i would agree with you (say, jeff carter vs clarke macarthur. carter is obviously the better player)

but when we're talking about 75, 80, 90, 100 point scorers i'm not so sure.
 
Back
Top