• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

But he is a defensive liability. He's on for more goals against than just about any other forward on the team. Again:

2009-10: Gaon/60 - 3.15 (2nd last among Jackets forwards who played 50+ games)
2010-11: 2.73 (4th last)

Scoring goals has nothing to do with defense.
 
He's not overrated because he produces at a top 25 level on one of the annually worst teams in the league. While being responsible in all zones. Rick Nash is a two-way player who has NEVER had an elite teammate.

He's a complete player.
He's obviously a good player. No one's debating that. But he's overrated because for no reason whatsoever, many people like yourself think he's actually a 45/80 player, and the BJ's are paying him as such.
 
Because it doesn't?

2002-03: -27 (18th - worst on Columbus)
2003-04: -35 (18th - worst on Columbus)
2005-06: +5 (3rd)
2006-07: -8 (T-10th)
2007-08: +2 (5th)
2008-09: +11 (T-3rd)
2009-10: -2 (T-6th)
2010-11: +2 (6th)

And the only reason his totals are as respectable as they are are due to even strength scoring. He's still a defensive nightmare though.

So disregarding him as an 18 and 19 year old guy, he is always in the top half of his team, only twice coming in at a negative.

A defensive liability he is not. He plays a good two-way game as he doesn't put his team at risk to produce.

How is that a nightmare?
 
Players in markets no one pays attention to get overrated terribly. Just look at all the players on Florida that were supposedly big stars. Boumeester got exposed the minute he played in a bigger hockey market.

Nash is the same. Very nice player. But "Franchise Player"? Good lord no. No one would be calling him a franchise player if he was on the Leafs.

Another overrated player on a team no one cares about? Shea Weber.
 
sometimes. perhaps with guys in the 50-60 point range.

but i have a hard time justifying arguments like cheechoo was more or as valuable as thornton, or daniel sedin is more valuable than henrik, or perry is more valuable than getzlaf, or stamkos is more valuable than st. louis, or carter is more valuable than giroux, (and so on).

if you're looking at a 40 goal 60 point player vs a 20 goal 60 point player i would agree with you (say, jeff carter vs clarke macarthur. carter is obviously the better player)

but when we're talking about 75, 80, 90, 100 point scorers i'm not so sure.

Same team production though from similar players is a tough one. Cheechoo was a beneficiary of Thornton. The Sedins play off one another. Perry and Getzlaf usually play together and produce as a result of one another.

And why do those wingers hit those high scoring levels? Skilled centreman.

Cheechoo winger to Thornton
Sedin winger to Sedin
Perry winger to Getzlaf

Arguably the only winger who does it without a great passing centre is Iginla. And he's a beast.
 
Or was on a great producing line with a team that was great defensively (highest goal differential in the league by far that year).

He also ranked 7th on his team.

That argument is a joke.

Oh so +/- is only a good argument when you pick and choose it to be. Gotch'ya.

Of course its a joke. Any +/- argument is.
 
i've already addressed.

objectively speaking, breaking out after the age of 26 is very unlikely.

ribeiro has done it, and two guys who are amongst the smallest forwards in the league have done it... i think you can add whitney to that list. maybe stillman?

regardless, it's a very limited list.

And I wouldn't call going from 35/70 --> 40/80 breaking out.

Rick Nash broke out at age 19 with a 41 goal season. Or would you prefer me say at age 21 averaging a PPG
 
Oh so +/- is only a good argument when you pick and choose it to be. Gotch'ya.

Of course its a joke. Any +/- argument is.

If you solely look at it by itself it is. In the overall scheme it isn't though.

Kessel and Nash on similar teams. One is horrendous in terms of +/- and the other holds his own.
 
Again:

Nash:

2009-10: Gaon/60 - 3.15 (2nd last among Jackets forwards who played 50+ games)
2010-11: 2.73 (4th last)

Kessel:
2010-11: 3.31
2009-10: 3.09

Both Nash and Kessel are bad defensively.

+/- is absolutely worthless.
 
Again:

2009-10: Gaon/60 - 3.15 (2nd last among Jackets forwards who played 50+ games)
2010-11: 2.73 (4th last)

Both Nash and Kessel are bad defensively.

+/- is absolutely worthless.

That's false. Kessel in his best stretches is an even player on the Leafs.

Nash at his best stretch (Nov.-Feb.) was a +14. Nash doesn't become a liability when trying to score, Kessel OTOH does at times.

Defense is played in all three zones.
 
And I wouldn't call going from 35/70 --> 40/80 breaking out.

Rick Nash broke out at age 19 with a 41 goal season. Or would you prefer me say at age 21 averaging a PPG

you're just going in circles.

for rick nash to become a consistent 40/80 player he would need to improve on his play.

a 50 goal, 90 point season, which would be entirely unprecedented, most certainly would be a breakout year for him.

as for his ppg as a 21 year old.. he has demonstrated the ability to go hot for long stretches, and for his production to drop during other stretches. he may well have finished the season with 80 points, or he might not have.

the salient point is that he has hit (or been close to) that ppg pace just one other time in the 6 seasons since his abbreviated point per game season. evidence suggests he might have kept up that pace had he played those extra 30 games. but not only is the evidence not conclusive, it suggests that he probably wouldn't have.
 
Same team production though from similar players is a tough one. Cheechoo was a beneficiary of Thornton. The Sedins play off one another. Perry and Getzlaf usually play together and produce as a result of one another.

And why do those wingers hit those high scoring levels? Skilled centreman.

Cheechoo winger to Thornton
Sedin winger to Sedin
Perry winger to Getzlaf

Arguably the only winger who does it without a great passing centre is Iginla. And he's a beast.

so now you're saying that daniel only scores as much as he does because of henrik?

henrik looked just fine without daniel last year. don't know why daniel would be any different.

meanwhile, perry actually upped his level of performance above his career norms while getzlaf was out earlier this year.
 
The argument that these guys will score more playing with better players is the exact same argument that Phil Kessel wouldn't be able to score without Marc Savard.
 
so now you're saying that daniel only scores as much as he does because of henrik?

henrik looked just fine without daniel last year. don't know why daniel would be any different.

meanwhile, perry actually upped his level of performance above his career norms while getzlaf was out earlier this year.

Wrong.

Corey Perry without Getzlaf in the month of January.

11 GP, 5 G, 3 A, 8 PTS, -5

Good try though.
 
The argument that these guys will score more playing with better players is the exact same argument that Phil Kessel wouldn't be able to score without Marc Savard.

You would expect a 21 year old coming off of a 36 goal year to increase slightly, not go down.

Especially when seeing an increase in ice time.
 
You would expect a 21 year old coming off of a 36 goal year to increase slightly, not go down.

Especially when seeing an increase in ice time.

Maybe you would. But lots of people thought he wouldn't be able to score without Savard. And that was dumb, and shown to be wrong. Just like thinking Kessel or a guy like Nash would suddenly start to score more now just because they start to play with a guy like Savard again is dumb.
 
Back
Top