• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

It boggles my mind that the national media would consider a roster in which Ryan Callahan and Brian Boyle of all people are leading scorers to be a legitimate contender, but the Leafs with a former Norris Trophy candidate on defence, three thirty goal scorers up front, an elite young shutdown defenceman, promising young centre with flash, and arguably the most impressive rookie goaltender in the entire league this season, are supposedly "rebuilding," or "far from the post-season." It's ridiculous how they can spout this trash.
 
I agree. I think the Leafs are brimming with interesting prospects and talent NOW.
 
Craig Custance of the Sporting News:

"The NHL draft isn't until June, but don't be surprised if the Blue Jackets trade their first-round pick this year. After missing the playoffs again, Columbus needs talent that can help it win immediately. 'Yeah, we would look at trading the pick if it was something that could make an immediate impact on the team,' GM Scott Howson told Sporting News. 'The (team) evaluation is just beginning now ..."



Possible trade up for the Leafs? Pick + Player maybe. Whose going to go in the 7-10 range?
 
Craig Custance of the Sporting News:





Possible trade up for the Leafs? Pick + Player maybe. Whose going to go in the 7-10 range?

what's the point.. if columbus trades the pick it won't be for futures, they're looking for help now. given that this is a weak draft you'd have to be a real dupe to trade a front line player for a pick in the 7-10 range. assuming that no general manager is dumb enough to do that, the question is: what do the leafs have to offer that would make the jackets interested?

and given that the leafs are also a 'rebuilding' team, the answer is almost undoubtedly not much.

kessel and phaneuf are not tradeable. kadri is easily more impressive a prospect than anybody that will be available other than than maybe ryan murphy -- but then, would you trade kadri for a 5'9 18 year old defenseman? no offence to murphy, who i think has it in him to be a very good nhl defenseman. but it would be pure folly to trade an nhl-ready and capable high impact young forward like kadri for an 18 year old defenseman with a huge size limitation.

that leaves the second line. macarthur, who i like quite a bit, is not going to net a high first round pick because of one good season. he's a risk, there's no question about that. you could sign him for 3 years and get a bargain, but what if 2010 was an aberration? meanwhile, he could just as easily seek a one year deal then walk next year.

grabovski is in a similar boat, though i think he could secure a package for that sort of pick (rightly or wrongly). but then, would i trade grabovski for a 7-10 pick? right now, mikhail grabovski is the leafs' best centre by a long shot (or at least until they shift kadri to centre, or bozak wakes the **** up). the leafs are too close to a playoff spot to justify dealing him for futures. if grabovski is dealt it has to be for a comparable talent with a shift in emphasis on skill (say, big, and strong rather than fast and toolsy). to deal him for a pick sets this team back, and with 7 years of missing the playoffs, and how close they look right now, i see little value in making a move that sets this team back.

i guess you could try and tempt them with kulemin but he's in a similar boat to macarthur and might not have the trade value. and even if he does, why would you trade him for futures? given that he's one of two top six forwards that brings any size to the table, dealing him blows a pretty big hole in the team's top six (seeing as that they're already deficient in size). for a pick in a weak draft, i just dont' think that's worth it.
 
MacArthur might not be enough on his own, but if the Leafs packaged one of their 1sts with him, that might interest them.

But I sort of like the idea of having multiple picks -- unless Burke has a certain guy he wants in that 7-10 range.
 
MacArthur might not be enough on his own, but if the Leafs packaged one of their 1sts with him, that might interest them.

But I sort of like the idea of having multiple picks -- unless Burke has a certain guy he wants in that 7-10 range.

no chance in hell that clarke macarthur is used to anchor a trade for a top ten pick, sorry.

i'm one of his biggest boosters here. but nobody is going to give that up for a guy with one good year under his belt, and pending ufa status.
 
Realistically, I'd assume the only guy we have that might legitimately interest them in that kind of deal would be Grabo.

Thats probably not worth it. But I'd definitely look to move up if you could get one of those guys.
 
no chance in hell that clarke macarthur is used to anchor a trade for a top ten pick, sorry.

i'm one of his biggest boosters here. but nobody is going to give that up for a guy with one good year under his belt, and pending ufa status.


I don't know, top 10 picks have been traded for worse than a young player coming off a 60 point season + a late 1st rounder.

Not saying Columbus would do it, but they're in desperation mode at this point. And it's not exactly a killer draft.
 
I don't know, top 10 picks have been traded for worse than a young player coming off a 60 point season + a late 1st rounder.

Not saying Columbus would do it, but they're in desperation mode at this point. And it's not exactly a killer draft.

have they?

i'm having a hard time thinking of any top 10 picks being dealt in recent years, to be honest, short of draft day trades to move up a couple of slots (like the schenn trade)

and every year it seems there's a gm who declares they're looking to trade a top 5 or top 10 pick for 'immediate help', and these trades never materialize
 
MacA would easily get that top 10 pick all by his lonesome. No question.

And let's please stop even mentioning trading Grabs or Kuly.
 
no chance in hell that clarke macarthur is used to anchor a trade for a top ten pick, sorry.

i'm one of his biggest boosters here. but nobody is going to give that up for a guy with one good year under his belt, and pending ufa status.

Actually he's an RFA, I believe. But yeah.
 
Back
Top