MindzEye
Wayward Ditch Pig
They are better than any player you listed, both offensively and defensively, minus Buff who plays a different position, although you wouldn't know most times where exactly that position is.
They're not better offensively though...
2 yr ppg
Dubinsky - .67ppg
Callahan - .62ppg
Raymond - .61ppg
Byfuglien - .54ppg
Bolland - .53ppg
Versteeg - .58ppg
Bourque - .71ppg
Fleischmann - .72ppg
Filpulla - .59ppg
Hudler - .61ppg
Very comparable. Defensive work is so subjective that it's a silly discussion...a year ago Bolland had the entire hockey world jerking him off for his ability as a shut down centreman...I think you'd have a hard time convincing anyone that Dubinsky or Callahan are better defensively than he is.