• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Highly doubt it would cost Schenn......in fact damn near guarantee it wouldn't.

Really?!?! Wow... if he goes cheaper than that then I'd imagine every team in the league would want in.

It's not going to be cheap to get a 26 year old forward who's 6'3" 200 lbs who scored 46 goals at 24 and has three 30+ goals and a 29 goal season under his belt.

What do you figure it'll cost?
 
Burke has a nice history of fleecing Columbus. I really don't think Schenn is in play... but Kadri for sure. Kadri one of the first this year and our second is the starting point for a big deal.

Nash is the sexier name, but he has the much higher price tag. Could you imagine if Burke could do..... Kadri, Bozak, Komi (salary purposes) Boston's first and our second for Nash and Filatov... Then sign Richards.

Nash Richards Kessel would be a ridiculous first line.
 
Am I missing something? Is Schenn that good or did Carter get hurt?

I get that Schenn is a very good physical defensive dman, but those guys just flat out aren't as valuable as 35-40/70-80 forwards.
 
Really?!?! Wow... if he goes cheaper than that then I'd imagine every team in the league would want in.

It's not going to be cheap to get a 26 year old forward who's 6'3" 200 lbs who scored 46 goals at 24 and has three 30+ goals and a 29 goal season under his belt.

What do you figure it'll cost?

I would like to have Carter. But he really doesn't solve the whole "get Kessel a decent center" dilemma, he plays the same position as him, and is a goal scorer who demands the puck a lot.

So while I have no idea what it would cost (Kadri's been suggested by some here when we talked about this earlier), I doubt Burke would give up Schenn for him.
 
Burke isn't moving Schenn. I doubt the Flyers would want him anyway. They have a ton of money locked up on the blueline, and with Schenn due for an extension, he carries a pretty big cap number, that wouldn't give the Flyers the cap space they need, which is the only reason they would move Carter in the first place.

Doesn't really make sense for either team. Would be prospects like Colborne and picks.
 
out of the two players... I would actually lean more in the Nash direction. Carter is still too up and down. He doesn't play his size, and doesn't really scream power centre or set up man.

If it is a similar package I go with Nash, and then call up Richards and say... hey... check out these two wingers. What do you think about playing with these guys,
 
I can't imagine that Philly would be trading Carter just to bring in a forward prospect.

They'd have no reason to trade an excellent young forward for a young potentially excellent forward, so I doubt Kadri would be involved.
 
Burke isn't moving Schenn. I doubt the Flyers would want him anyway. They have a ton of money locked up on the blueline, and with Schenn due for an extension, he carries a pretty big cap number, that wouldn't give the Flyers the cap space they need, which is the only reason they would move Carter in the first place.

Doesn't really make sense for either team. Would be prospects like Colborne and picks.

Yeah, Carter's only at 5.3... if Schenn gets anywhere close to Marc Staal you're not saving a whole lot.
 
Am I missing something? Is Schenn that good or did Carter get hurt?

I get that Schenn is a very good physical defensive dman, but those guys just flat out aren't as valuable as 35-40/70-80 forwards.

pretty tough to call a guy who has scored 61 and 66 points in the past 2 years a 70-80 point player.

and on that note, that's exactly why you don't trade schenn for him. he isn't a big time impact forward, he's a pretty one dimensional goal scorer.

frankly, i wouldn't trade schenn for kessel at this point, who i see as a similar player to carter and with more skill (and therefore more potential) to boot.
 
I can't imagine that Philly would be trading Carter just to bring in a forward prospect. They'd only be trading him in hopes of improving on their defense and or goaltending.
.

Yeah exactly. They would trade him to create cap space to go after a goalie. Thats the only reason to move him. They aren't trading him for a $3+ million dman with Pronger, Timmonen, Carle, Coburn and Meszaros in the fold. Just doesn't make any sense for them.
 
Maybe I undervalue a defensive dman. Guys like Foote, Volchenkov and Michalek are great to have, but I'd prefer the big strong scoring forward.
 
If Burke is really going for Nash, then he must think he can get Richards.

I wonder if these names and big deals being bantered about will open up talks with teams like Colorado, who could look at some of the names being offered and say we could do that for Statsny. But again, I think Burke wants some size on the wing. A true power forward to open up some space for Kessel and give a centre two bonafide options on the wings.
 
Yeah exactly. They would trade him to create cap space to go after a goalie. Thats the only reason to move him. They aren't trading him for a $3+ million dman with Pronger, Timmonen, Carle, Coburn and Meszaros in the fold. Just doesn't make any sense for them.

I was thinking it would be something like Schenn++ for Carter and Carle or Coburn.
 
Maybe I undervalue a defensive dman. Guys like Foote, Volchenkov and Michalek are great to have, but I'd prefer the big strong scoring forward.

I agree with msun that Carter's a pretty similar player to Kessel though. It's nice to have one on your team but do you need both? And should you take from your D to get it?
 
I just can't see CLB trading Nash... he's signed forever and he's their franchise player. You just don't trade your one potential superstar while you are still trying to build and keep a fanbase.

There's almost no chance Nash gets traded.
 
I just can't see CLB trading Nash... he's signed forever and he's their franchise player. You just don't trade your one potential superstar while you are still trying to build and keep a fanbase.

There's almost no chance Nash gets traded.

Unless if they can get another franchise player, or solid potential franchise player in return. Or enough prospects that it may cost them in the short term, but that they make out like bandits 3 years down the road.
 
If Philly moves Carter it'll be to free up cap space, and because he has a full no-trade clause that kicks in from 2012-2015....

Not sure how many teams would be banging down the door for a 30g/60-70 point forward, that's locked up for 11 years. I'm sure there would be suitors, but not the amount you're thinking of HP....


McArthur, Scrivens/Rynnas, Boston's 1st round pick........could see them accepting something like that, although I guess that'd only free up 2-3 million for them.
 
Back
Top