• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Carter is signed until the year 3000, and has only produced like the player we'd need him to be once. doubt Burke takes that contract on, let alone giving up Luke Schenn to get him.

As for Rick Nash...well, that's an interesting one. Maybe the Jackets have decided it's time to move him while his value's still high. He turns 27 next month, and has 2 40 goal seasons and a 38 goal season under his belt. If Burke can land a guy of that calibre, that's a pretty good wing complement to tempt Richards with on July 1st. Even Carter and Kessel would be....they'd each score 35 easy playing with Brad Richards.
 
If Philly moves Carter it'll be to free up cap space, and because he has a full no-trade clause that kicks in from 2012-2015....

Not sure how many teams would be banging down the door for a 30g/60-70 point forward, that's locked up for 11 years. I'm sure there would be suitors, but not the amount you're thinking of HP....


McArthur, Scrivens/Rynnas, Boston's 1st round pick........could see them accepting something like that, although I guess that'd only free up 2-3 million for them.

You make sense up until the offer.

That's a horrible deal.
 
You make sense up until the offer.

That's a horrible deal.


Carter out produced MacArthur last year by 4 points.....and will cost 2-3 million less, won't come with a NTC, and will be open to signing a deal likely 7-8 years shorter than Carter's. (while making 3-4 million less in real money)


Clearly they're far different players, and Carter is worth significantly more.....but I think Philly would be happy to add similar production, with all the benefits mentioned above, while also adding a high level goalie prospect to their pool, and a first round pick.


Mind you I really have no clue what Philly would be looking for in return.
 
yeah, when you put their totals in context that offer is pretty reasonable. especially since philly will want to maintain its depth up front while opening up some $ on the blueline. a guy like macarthur would be a great fit for them.

it astounds me how overrated jeff carter is.
 
yeah, when you put their totals in context that offer is pretty reasonable. especially since philly will want to maintain its depth up front while opening up some $ on the blueline. a guy like macarthur would be a great fit for them.

it astounds me how overrated jeff carter is.

The lustre of his 46 goal season hasn't faded yet.
 
Come on guys... we all know that MacArthur only scored 4 less points than Cater this year, but does anyone here think he's anywhere near as valuable? If so, I can't imagine why you'd give him up + a prospect (even a B/C level prospect)+ a pick.

MacArthur had a very good year, but he's just a solid second liner. He's not top line talent. He's not going to break out an bring it up another notch. It'll be surprising if he ever reproduces what he did this year.

Scrivens is going to be 25 years old before the next season starts and he's never played an NHL game, and only played 33 AHL games. Maybe he has some potential, but more than likely will never be an NHL starter.

Rynnas is 24 and looks like he has some some good potential but even then he's no lock to be an NHL starter.
 
yeah, when you put their totals in context that offer is pretty reasonable. especially since philly will want to maintain its depth up front while opening up some $ on the blueline. a guy like macarthur would be a great fit for them.

it astounds me how overrated jeff carter is.

Just wait to see how overrated he becomes if the Leafs get him.

:couch
 
well of course Carter is more valuable talent wise. but you're forgetting that philly would be doing this to get cap space in the first place, which has its own value.
 
Carter can play center. If Burke pays the price tag its going to cost to get Carter, it'll be to fill the #1C spot

Summer of 2012 can be a mission to find someone to pass the puck to both Carter and Kessel.
 
well of course Carter is more valuable talent wise. but you're forgetting that philly would be doing this to get cap space in the first place, which has its own value.

...but there are probably 10-20 teams that would be willing to give up a better package than MacArthur, Scrivens and a late first for Carter that would free up space.

I could see the Kings offering up a better deal. How about Bernier and Hickey?
 
Summer of 2012 can be a mission to find someone to pass the puck to both Carter and Kessel.

I think thats overstated. Talent playing together is more important than finding guy to fit specific jobs IMO. Kessel can score by himself. He doesn't need a Joe Thornton. He just needs some good players to play with.
 
And that said Richards is a better player than Carter. I'd rather get him for just money, then give up a big package for Carter.
 
Considering:
a) how firmly Burke has held on to Schenn in the past despite (according to him) receiving some really good offers
b) his distate for long contracts
c) the fact that i'm not sure a carter-kessel combo works that well

I can't see it happening for Schenn, habspatrol. Or Kadri + Reimer + 1st like Sal suggested, heh.
 
I think thats overstated. Talent playing together is more important than finding guy to fit specific jobs IMO. Kessel can score by himself. He doesn't need a Joe Thornton. He just needs some good players to play with.

It was mostly a joke. I'm not sure they would fit together that well though.
 
Back
Top