• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

It amazes me that no matter how many times these big money/big contract players get dealt, people still don't learn. If Philly decides to trade Carter, they won't get a single asset from any team as good as Schenn or Kadri. They'd get a B+ prospect/or 2nd liner, maybe a first rounder (or 2nd), and another throw-in player. The same goes for Rick Nash.

As for Carter to the Leafs, I don't see how he's a fit for us.
 
Considering:
a) how firmly Burke has held on to Schenn in the past despite (according to him) receiving some really good offers
b) his distate for long contracts
c) the fact that i'm not sure a carter-kessel combo works that well

I can't see it happening for Schenn, habspatrol. Or Kadri + Reimer + 1st like Sal suggested, heh.

That's fine... I'm not saying that it has to be Schenn, just trying to figure out what the Flyers would accept for Carter. I just don't think a solid second liner a B/C level prospect and a late 1st gets it done. Schenn was the first thing that came to mind.

I did come up with what I thought was a pretty good deal though.

Colborne, Aulie and a 2nd for Carter and Coburn or Carle

I think the Kings make better trade partners though. Bernier and Hickey for Carter.
 
Come on guys... we all know that MacArthur only scored 4 less points than Cater this year, but does anyone here think he's anywhere near as valuable? If so, I can't imagine why you'd give him up + a prospect (even a B/C level prospect)+ a pick.

MacArthur had a very good year, but he's just a solid second liner. He's not top line talent. He's not going to break out an bring it up another notch. It'll be surprising if he ever reproduces what he did this year.

Scrivens is going to be 25 years old before the next season starts and he's never played an NHL game, and only played 33 AHL games. Maybe he has some potential, but more than likely will never be an NHL starter.

Rynnas is 24 and looks like he has some some good potential but even then he's no lock to be an NHL starter.

well, see, that's sort of the point.. jeff carter really isn't much of a top line talent, 08-09 notwithstanding.

the leafs give up macarthur plus because mac has only had one big season. but if the 2010-11 macarthur/carter were the 'real' macarthur and carter then they really aren't that different, at least in terms of quality/quantity of play. and if we're talking about a 60 point guy as opposed to a 65 point guy, who are the same age, but the 60 point guy makes $3mn per year for 4 years, and the 65 point guy makes $6mn for 10 years... well, i'd be more inclined to take the 60 point guy on my team.
 
It amazes me that no matter how many times these big money/big contract players get dealt, people still don't learn. If Philly decides to trade Carter, they won't get a single asset from any team as good as Schenn or Kadri. They'd get a B+ prospect/or 2nd liner, maybe a first rounder (or 2nd), and another throw-in player. The same goes for Rick Nash.

As for Carter to the Leafs, I don't see how he's a fit for us.

You're thinking of pending UFAs at the trade deadline. We're talking about guys signed to long term deals. There's a world of difference. These guys don't get traded often.
 
well, see, that's sort of the point.. jeff carter really isn't much of a top line talent, 08-09 notwithstanding.

the leafs give up macarthur plus because mac has only had one big season. but if the 2010-11 macarthur/carter were the 'real' macarthur and carter then they really aren't that different, at least in terms of quality/quantity of play. and if we're talking about a 60 point guy as opposed to a 65 point guy, who are the same age, but the 60 point guy makes $3mn per year for 4 years, and the 65 point guy makes $6mn for 10 years... well, i'd be more inclined to take the 60 point guy on my team.

So in your mind the Leafs should get Carter+ for MacArthur?
 
...but there are probably 10-20 teams that would be willing to give up a better package than MacArthur, Scrivens and a late first for Carter that would free up space.

I could see the Kings offering up a better deal. How about Bernier and Hickey?

That wouldn't bother me, they can go right ahead. I'm not so sure Carter can be the 45+ goal 80 point guy again. Which is what we would need out of him, if that's Burke's big move for the summer.

Carter's a skilled player but he's on a really long deal and his playoff numbers stink. There are legit reasons not to want him, and if another team wants to overpay I'm fine with it.
 
You're thinking of pending UFAs at the trade deadline. We're talking about guys signed to long term deals. There's a world of difference. These guys don't get traded often.
So you actually think Carter being signed to a big money 11-year NTC contract makes him significantly more valuable? Try looking up what Dan Boyle got in a trade pretty recently after signing his big extension, and let me know how close that return comes to the package I outlined.
 
He's right though that they don't seem to happen that often. But when they do it seems to usually be for less than you'd expect.
 
That wouldn't bother me, they can go right ahead. I'm not so sure Carter can be the 45+ goal 80 point guy again. Which is what we would need out of him, if that's Burke's big move for the summer.

Carter's a skilled player but he's on a really long deal and his playoff numbers stink. There are legit reasons not to want him, and if another team wants to overpay I'm fine with it.

his regular season numbers are also more akin to a 'good 2nd liner' than a first liner, too.

at the end of the day whoever trades for him (if he is dealt) is getting a guy who in 09/10 and 10/11 was a similar caliber player to mikhail grabovski, nikolai kulemin and clarke macarthur but who is signed for another decade and earning more than double than what any of them will earn in 2011-12. people spend far too much time remembering his good first half in 2008-09, and what he did in junior.

08-09 might or might not have been an aberration. but when you look at his full body of work, including (as you pointed out) some really, really awful playoff numbers, it definitely seems that it was. buyer beware on that one.
 
He's right though that they don't seem to happen that often. But when they do it seems to usually be for less than you'd expect.

of course they don't happen often. teams don't usually deal these players.

but the thing is, other than that one season carter really isn't the same caliber player as just about anybody we're going to try and compare him to (although a big part of the reason for that is he seems to be held in particularly high esteem -- and undeservedly so).

in any event, when you look at what high impact star playres have been dealt for the packages have practically always been similar, whether they're pending ufa's or not.

thornton, heatley, phaneuf, boyle, richards, havlat

none of these guys went for an a-list youngster.
 
Yeah, that's the problem with these big contract guys. It's hard to find teams willing to pick up those contracts, and the negative value of a lengthy expensive contract combined with the limited number of teams bidding on the player is likely what helps keep the returns for these players relatively low.
 
of course they don't happen often. teams don't usually deal these players.

but the thing is, other than that one season carter really isn't the same caliber player as just about anybody we're going to try and compare him to (although a big part of the reason for that is he seems to be held in particularly high esteem -- and undeservedly so).

in any event, when you look at what high impact star playres have been dealt for the packages have practically always been similar, whether they're pending ufa's or not.

thornton, heatley, phaneuf, boyle, richards, havlat

none of these guys went for an a-list youngster.

good call on richards, i totally forgot about him and the dallas-tampa deal.
 
Back
Top