• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

But that's exactly why they probably don't happen that often. Because they're not getting these amazing offers.

I'm not expecting an amazing deal... but MacArthur? Come on, the guy never showed signs of being a 1st liner then he had a very good year that will likely never be repeated. Scrivens? Rynnas? Long shots to ever be NHL starters. A late 1st? That's not bad... but in a weak draft not worth that much. The Flyers showed what they thought of a late 1st when they gave theirs to the Leafs for Versteeg.
 
I'm not expecting an amazing deal... but MacArthur? Come on, the guy never showed signs of being a 1st liner then he had a very good year that will likely never be repeated. Scrivens? Rynnas? Long shots to ever be NHL starters. A late 1st? That's not bad... but in a weak draft not worth that much. The Flyers showed what they thought of a late 1st when they gave theirs to the Leafs for Versteeg.

these trades do go down occasionally but not for anyone like schenn to this point.
 
seriously?

Well what am I misreading here?

well, see, that's sort of the point.. jeff carter really isn't much of a top line talent, 08-09 notwithstanding.

the leafs give up macarthur plus because mac has only had one big season. but if the 2010-11 macarthur/carter were the 'real' macarthur and carter then they really aren't that different, at least in terms of quality/quantity of play. and if we're talking about a 60 point guy as opposed to a 65 point guy, who are the same age, but the 60 point guy makes $3mn per year for 4 years, and the 65 point guy makes $6mn for 10 years... well, i'd be more inclined to take the 60 point guy on my team.

Carter is the 65 point guy right?
MacArthur is the 60 point guys right?

"i'd be more inclined to take the 60 point guy on my team"
That means that you'd rather have MacArthur right?

Seriously, if I'm misunderstanding that then let me know where. You're the one that wrote it, you'd have a better idea of what you meant.
 
You know HP, the onus in this debate is really on you. We've produced numerous examples of "star" players signed to big contracts going for the kind of packages we're suggesting. Can you come up with any examples of players comparable to Carter being dealt for young assets like Kadri or Schenn?
 
The most important part.

but if the 2010-11 macarthur/carter were the 'real' macarthur and carter then they really aren't that different

Oh... so he was talking purely hypothetically. I thought we were actually discussing the actual players.

My bad.
 
But it happens. Hossa for Heatley. Chris Stewart and Kevin Shattenkirk for Eric Johnson.

There are still hockey trades when you're talking about non UFAs.

A 28 year old Brad Richards coming off a Conn Smythe win and better seasons than Carter only got Jokinen, Halpern, Smith and a 4th.
 
You know HP, the onus in this debate is really on you. We've produced numerous examples of "star" players signed to big contracts going for the kind of packages we're suggesting. Can you come up with any examples of players comparable to Carter being dealt for young assets like Kadri or Schenn?

Hossa for Heatley. Chris Stewart and Kevin Shattenkirk for Eric Johnson.
 
Hossa for Heatley. Chris Stewart and Kevin Shattenkirk for Eric Johnson.
Two big money players dealt for each other, and three young players on entry level contracts dealt for each other.

You really think those are comparable? That's all you can come up with?
 
We do need top line talent. I guess we can't be too picky given that there's not plenty available but there's some things about Carter that make me pretty uncomfortable giving up the packages being thrown around.
 
Fair/equal value? Just the couple I just mentioned... as many as you can name that were totally lopsided... not counting goalies.

Thornton, Heatley, Phaneuf, Boyle, Richards vs The Heatley-Hossa trade (no superstars in the Johnson-Stewart deal)



At least 5-1 by my count.....not sure that's "as many as you can name"
 
Or both Carter + Richards.

To add both Carter and Richards in the same offseason would be pretty ridiculous but I don't think we really need to give up the assets for Carter if we landed Richards.

Lupul-Richards-Kessel
Kulemin-Grabs-Mac

Even if you're iffy on that second line repeating their seasons, you don't really need your 2nd line getting 80 goals with that first line anyway. Besides, it sure takes the pressure off them and they'd get favourable matchups with the other team concentrating on the Richards line.
 
Back
Top