• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Honestly not sure how much we'd even need a high end PMD if we added both Carter + Richards.......given that Richards could QB the PP with Phaneuf.

Not necessarily a high end puck mover but you still need some help on the blueline if you're planning on a playoff spot. Phaneuf, Schenn, Aulie...? And Aulie's really green.
 
Phaneuf, Schenn, Aulie, Komisarek, Gunnarson, Lashoff, Lebda, Gardiner, Holzer, Gysbers.....might be good enough depending on how Burke feels about how ready some of the kids are.

Really, going from MacArthur to Carter only eats up 2.5 million extra or so in cap space anyway, so there could still be room for a cheap dman as well.
 
Aulie's pretty green, and potentially in line for a sophomore slump. We really don't know what we'll get from Gunn on a game by game basis. Komisarek and Lebda are...terrifying. Lashoff was a decent fill in at #6, but ideally he's either in that spot for you, or at #7. And then the rest are completely untested rookies that may need significant more time in the AHL.

Not adding another legitimate top four guy would really be playing with fire. I don't think you can underestimate the fact that we deleted half of our top-four (Kaberle & Beauch) and that they need to be adequately replaced.
 
Lupul (4.25) - Richards (8) - Kessel (5.4)
Kulemin (2.35) - Grabovski (2.9) - Carter (5.3)
Kadri (.9) - Bozak (1.5) - Armstrong (3)
Brown (1) - XXX (.75) - XXX (.750)

XXX (.750) XXX (.750)

Phaneuf (6.5) - Schenn (4?)
Komisarek (4.5) - Aulie (.525)
Gunnarson (1.3?) - UFA (???)
Lashoff (.800?)

Reimer (2?)
Gustavsson (1.35)



23 man roster at $58 million once Tucker's hit is factored in, if my math is correct and my RFA/Richards guesses are accurate, leaving us anywhere from $2.5-5.5 million for a UFA dman + wiggle room, depending on the cap (rumoured between 60.5-63.5 million correct?)

(sorry, on an iPad couldn't use CapGeek)
 
Maybe I undervalue a defensive dman. Guys like Foote, Volchenkov and Michalek are great to have, but I'd prefer the big strong scoring forward.

The thing is though, none of those guys you listed, were anywhere near as good as Schenn was at 21 yrs old....and Carter is "big", but definitely doesn't play "big" so it's a bit of a stretch to call him a "big strong scoring forward"
 
You're really comfortable with just bringing in a bottom-pairing defenseman, and having Komisarek and a sophomore defenseman rounding out our top-4?
 
Aulie's pretty green, and potentially in line for a sophomore slump. We really don't know what we'll get from Gunn on a game by game basis. Komisarek and Lebda are...terrifying. Lashoff was a decent fill in at #6, but ideally he's either in that spot for you, or at #7. And then the rest are completely untested rookies that may need significant more time in the AHL.

Being a GM means taking risks, and sometimes believing in the players you've acquired......if most of Aulie, Komi, Gunnarson, alls slump, and none of the kids can step up, then sure we're sin trouble and a move would need to me made.

Not adding another legitimate top four guy would really be playing with fire. I don't think you can underestimate the fact that we deleted half of our top-four (Kaberle & Beauch) and that they need to be adequately replaced.


We were also 12-7-5, after both were dealt away, though.....
 
Part of being a GM is also knowing when you're taking a foolish risk. Now, if you're confident that Komi can not only transform into an NHL-caliber defenseman, but also become a guy who can capably play top-four minutes, then more power to you. But I happen to think there's about as much of a chance of Rickard Wallin winning an NHL scoring title. I also think that saddling Keith Aulie with Komisarek and top-4 minutes could be pretty harmful to his development.

And then God help us if Schenn or Phaneuf are out for any significant period.
 
Part of being a GM is also knowing when you're taking a foolish risk. Now, if you're confident that Komi can not only transform into an NHL-caliber defenseman, but also become a guy who can capably play top-four minutes, then more power to you.


Last year was the first season in the last five that Komisarek didn't average 19-20+ minutes a game......
 
Last year was the first season in the last five that Komisarek didn't average 19-20+ minutes a game......
Well, if that fact would give you some level of comfort about heading into the season with him pencilled in as our #3 defenseman...then like I said, more power to you. Doesn't do much for me though and I sincerely hope that Burke and Wilson feel the same way.
 
None of us were big fans of having Grabovski as our #2 center this time last year (in fact most people wouldn't even list him in their projected lineups for 10/11, and that "gamble" by Burke worked out okay.)

If the gamble we have to make to add both Richards + Carter, is to play a guy second pairing minutes, that we felt highly enough in to pay 4.5 million a year.....thats a gamble I can live with.


....but I don't buy Komi being a bottom pairing defender the rest of his career.
 
Last edited:
Worth noting, when Carter put up 46 goals and 84 points in 08/09, Joffrey Lupul was one of his primary wingers, both at even strength and on the top PP unit.
 
Two big money players dealt for each other, and three young players on entry level contracts dealt for each other.

You really think those are comparable? That's all you can come up with?

Good players being traded for good players rather than for a bag of pucks. What do you want? Guys named Jeff Carter?

You really don't think those trades are comparable?

I'm not even sure what you think I'm arguing here. I'm not saying that it HAS TO BE LUKE SCHENN!!! I'm just saying that I personally doubt that the Flyers trade Jeff Carter for Clarke MacArthur. The trade I proposed a couple of times included no star players, just players that would be more useful... Aulie, Colborne and a 2nd.
 
Last edited:
Thornton, Heatley, Phaneuf, Boyle, Richards vs The Heatley-Hossa trade (no superstars in the Johnson-Stewart deal)



At least 5-1 by my count.....not sure that's "as many as you can name"
So Carter is a superstar now?

Let me get this straight. You're going to get Carter for MacArthur and somehow Chris Stewart and Eric Johnson aren't even on the same level as Carter. Hell maybe you could get Chris Stewart AND Eric Johnson for Clarke MacArthur.
 
Back
Top