• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

To add both Carter and Richards in the same offseason would be pretty ridiculous but I don't think we really need to give up the assets for Carter if we landed Richards.

Apparently you don't have to give up any assets, so it should work out perfect.
 
So Carter is a superstar now?

Let me get this straight. You're going to get Carter for MacArthur and somehow Chris Stewart and Eric Johnson aren't even on the same level as Carter. Hell maybe you could get Chris Stewart AND Eric Johnson for Clarke MacArthur.

Neither Stewart or Johnson are on Carter's level.....clearly.
 
Nash and Carter are two of the more overrated players league. They're treated like superstars (moreso by the media than the people here), but they don't produce superstar numbers. That being said, they're still both very good players and I'd take either depending on the price.

If Carter's brought in, he's going to play centre imo. I doubt Burke's going to give significant assets and commit to him financially for nearly a decade to play the wing. But, the fact he can play both wing and centre adds a little more value there.

First option should still be Richards, because he's better than both, and he can be had for just cash.
 
Apparently you don't have to give up any assets, so it should work out perfect.

I think we're just saying that when these players are dealt its usually not for what everyone expects and as rare as you say these players being dealt is, it's even more rare that it's a hockey deal (star for star) and not affected by cap considerations.
 
Cap space has tremendous value in a cap system. The Leafs are one of a few teams that can absorb Carter's entire contract without taking any money back.

The Flyers wouldn't just get prospects and picks for Carter, they'd be getting prospects, picks + 5 mill in cap space that they could use to sign a very good goalie or a combination of things.

A lot of people made fun of Boston for trading Thornton, but it allowed them to spend big on a guy like Chara.

The Leafs have a couple 1st rounders, Colborne, Gardiner etc that might interest the Flyers if they aren't interested in adding any NHL salary.
 
The fact Carter is paid between $6-7 million in real cash for the first 6 or 7 years of the deal, cuts down on the number of teams that would be interested as well.
 
I've talked to a few pro scouts in the London area that I know and they've also heard the rumours. The names that they've heard linked to any Carter to Toronto trade are Nikolai Kulemin, Carl Gunnarson, Joe Colborne and two first round picks

From the other board.

I don't think it makes sense to trade Kulemin for carter. we'd be giving up a 30 goal scorer who has traits that no other forward in our lineup has(ie can score and play good defence). I realize that fits Carter as well, but based on Carter's production the last two seasons wouldn't Kulemin+ for carter be somewhat of a lateral move?
 
but based on Carter's production the last two seasons wouldn't Kulemin+ for carter be somewhat of a lateral move?

No, Carter would be an improvement on Kulemin...

But....the difference between the two players on the ice isn't Colborne, Gunner, & 2 1sts. Not even close

In all seriousness, I see Carter being capable of ~35 goals and 60-70 points pretty much every year. Kulemin capable of 25-30 and 50-60 points every year. There simply isn't a huge gulf in player quality there, definitely not one that requires pouring a decent young defender, excellent centre prospect & 2 1sts into.
 
haha ... as usual, Leafs assets are vastly under-rated in this rumor.

Gunnarson may not be worth too much, but he's still a serviceable #4-#5 young defenseman who is very cheap .... but fine, he's not worth a lot.

Colbourne is 1 of the top prospects in the Leafs system, and 2x1st rounders obviously has decent trade value to them as well.

If that is all it takes to acquire Carter - a player who has serious cap commitment which most teams cannot take without sending some salary in return ... that would be fine.

But then to include Kulemin also in the rumor is insane.

Replace these pieces with equivalent from other teams and whoever comes up with this rumor will be laughed at.
 
From the other board.

I don't think it makes sense to trade Kulemin for carter. we'd be giving up a 30 goal scorer who has traits that no other forward in our lineup has(ie can score and play good defence). I realize that fits Carter as well, but based on Carter's production the last two seasons wouldn't Kulemin+ for carter be somewhat of a lateral move?

I love Carter, but that'd be a ****ing stupid trade for us to make.
 
Back
Top