• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

It makes no sense to trade Kulemin in a package for Carter. How much exactly are the Leafs improving by trading a 30 goal scorer for a 35-40 goal scorer? Especially when Kulemin has a lot of the qualities both Carter and the Leafs lack. Kulemin is good defensively, he uses his size well, he goes to the net, he forechecks -- all things the Leafs need more of, not less. He's one guy I wouldn't move in package deal unless you're talking about acquiring a superstar talent -- and Carter isn't a superstar talent.
 
Neither Stewart or Johnson are on Carter's level.....clearly.

They are not far off.
EJ is a former 1st overall first pair/potential superstar dman.
Stewart is a 23 year old winger who has scored 56 goals and 117 points in 139 games over past two seasons. That's a 33 goal and 69 point pace. Not bad for a 23 year old kid. He's also 6'2 230 lbs. That's a pretty valuable player.

Tell you what. I'd take Johnson or Stewart way before I take a package of MacArthur, Scrivens and Boston's 1st round pick.
 
They are not far off.
EJ is a former 1st overall first pair/potential superstar dman.
Stewart is a 23 year old winger who has scored 56 goals and 117 points in 139 games over past two seasons. That's a 33 goal and 69 point pace. Not bad for a 23 year old kid. He's also 6'2 230 lbs. That's a pretty valuable player.

Tell you what. I'd take Johnson or Stewart way before I take a package of MacArthur, Scrivens and Boston's 1st round pick.

That was a true hockey trade. Since there's been a cap in place, they've way more rare than you're suggesting the Thornton, Richards, Phaneuf, Heatley, etc trades have been.
 
Burke is not going to go near Carter's new 11 year extension starting next season. He hates anything over 5 years.

13 goals, 21 points and a -13 in 47 playoff games. this year he scored once and was a -3 for the Flyers in 6 games.

I can't see Burke being too hot to trot about that either.
 
Then no Carter for Schenn talks please..

To be fair, I mentioned Schenn initially then changed that to Aulie shortly after.

Would you trade Kessel for MacArthur if MacArthur wasn't already a Leaf? Then no MacArthur for Carter talks please.
 
That was a true hockey trade. Since there's been a cap in place, they've way more rare than you're suggesting the Thornton, Richards, Phaneuf, Heatley, etc trades have been.

Don't forget, every single one of those deals were to the opposite conference. That's no coincidence.
Johnson is a 2.6 cap hit and Stewart is a 2.8 cap hit. That's a lot different than a guy who is a 5+ cap hit with 11 years left on his deal.

I'm not saying that every trade is a true hockey trade... but they do happen.

Again, I haven't once said that the Leafs would have to sell the farm to get Carter, just that one particular proposal was particularly bad IMO.

I also think that LA makes more sense as a trade partner for the Flyers.
 
yeah. I mean his comments on those kind of deals are a) that he doesn't do them and b) if he did it would have to be a superstar player.

Carter is no superstar.
 
The deal isn't MacArthur for Carter straight up though. It also includes prospects and picks.

Scrivens and Rynnas are hardly prospects. They are 24 and 25 years old with a total of 0 NHL and 63 AHL games between them. Can one or both of them potentially be NHL starters? Sure, do they have trade value? Very little.

A late 1st in a weak draft? It definitely has some value but not a lot. Hell, the Flyers didn't think much of a late 1st when they traded theirs for Versteeg.
 
I think you will see Carter traded for a young 2nd liner (or 2nd pairing dman), a B prospect and a 1st.

That's what a 60-70 point player with a 10+ year contract will fetch imo.
 
Scrivens and Rynnas are hardly prospects. They are 24 and 25 years old with a total of 0 NHL and 63 AHL games between them. Can one or both of them potentially be NHL starters? Sure, do they have trade value? Very little.

I agree that goalies don't have much trade value in the first place. I do really like Scrivens though and get the feeling non-Leaf fans underrate this guy. It doesn't matter though - we have other prospects that can be offered. Wonder if the Flyers would go for a truculent Ross.
 
Not a rumor, but something I know some of you will be happy to hear.... bumped into a trainer from my old gym at my current gym tonight. Gary Roberts bought a portion of the old gym I went to and put in a high performance area where a lot of NHL guys are training. I asked if any Leafs were working out there and he was unsure but said that Kessel was going to be training with Roberts this summer.
 
Not a rumor, but something I know some of you will be happy to hear.... bumped into a trainer from my old gym at my current gym tonight. Gary Roberts bought a portion of the old gym I went to and put in a high performance area where a lot of NHL guys are training. I asked if any Leafs were working out there and he was unsure but said that Kessel was going to be training with Roberts this summer.

Very nice. Thanks for the info.
 
Back
Top