• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

No thanks on giving up either Kadri or Colborne in a package for Carter.

I wouldn't be heartbroken if Carter ended up a Leaf, but I'm also not chomping at the bit to acquire a guy with an 11-year contract who averages out at 60-65 points a season.
 
I have always thought of Carter more as a scorer and not as much of a playmaker.

so how would this help Kessel who "needs" a playmaking center
 
I have always thought of Carter more as a scorer and not as much of a playmaker.

so how would this help Kessel who "needs" a playmaking center
He's scored more goals than assists in five of his six NHL seasons, so that's an accurate assessment.

I'm not even really sure if Carter even regularly plays center anymore, with Mike Richards and Daniel Briere on the roster.
 
Again, worth noting that Carter's best season came with Joffrey Lupul playing on his wing.....so they've already got some built in chemistry.
 
He has 181 goals and 162 assists so far. not really all that different.

Carter's not putting up Brett Hull or Peter Bondra "Cy Young Award" type differences in his goals to assist ratio but there has been a significant enough discrepency for him to average 32 goals and 29 assists over the course of his career.

Again, not significant, but he has demonstrated a propensity to be more of a goal-scorer than a playmaker in his first six seasons with the Flyers.
 
Given there are 1.5-2X as many assists league-wide as goals, I think it's pretty safe to say that anybody who averages more goals than assists over a few years can be labelled as a "goal scorer" instead of a "playmaker".

It's a whole different matter whether that's actually important. I know classically it makes sense to put a goal scorer with a playmaker, but I think the bigger issue is who likes to control the puck, bring it out of the D zone, and who is just more of a guy who wants to take a pass. I don't know which is which - are either Kessel or Carter the types to bring the puck up the ice, or do they prefer to just go for the one-timers in the offensive zone?
 
Carter is not a pure-sniper (then again, neither is Kessel) but if you compare his G:A ratio to say, Savard, who has 207G and 500A ... it's clear Carter is not your prototypical 'play-maker'.

Richards, OTOH, has 220G and 500A.
 
Carter has 3 straight years of 300+ shots, and was right with Kessel in the top five for shots on goal last year. Really don't think they would work well together.
 
Carter is pretty similar to Kessel, especially since his size is largely an illusion.

But Kessel has some untapped upside left IMO, while Carter is tapped out.
 
Carter is pretty similar to Kessel, especially since his size is largely an illusion.

But Kessel has some untapped upside left IMO, while Carter is tapped out.
 
I guess the bottomline is, the Leafs can afford to add 1 top 6 player but not 2 ... not from a cap space perspective, and not from an trade asset perspective.

If I have to choose between signing Richards for nothing but $$ (cap space), and giving up major asset to trade for Carter, I'd take Richards in a heartbeat.
 
Carter is pretty similar to Kessel, especially since his size is largely an illusion.

But Kessel has some untapped upside left IMO, while Carter is tapped out.
Well, sure. Considering Carter tapped out at 46 goals and 84 points while Kessel is yet to crack 65 points.
 
i'd give up colborne in a heartbeat to get carter. don't love carter, but what he's done over the past two seasons is about the best we can expect of colborne, and even that is probably a stretch.

i wouldn't deal kadri for him, though, because kadri has legitimate 70-80 point potential and can be a difference maker.
 
i'd give up colborne in a heartbeat to get carter. don't love carter, but what he's done over the past two seasons is about the best we can expect of colborne, and even that is probably a stretch.

i wouldn't deal kadri for him, though, because kadri has legitimate 70-80 point potential and can be a difference maker.
Would you give up Colborne, along with a 1st round draft pick and Carl Gunnarsson?
 
i'd gauge the market to see if anybody more suitable (i.e. stastny, or test the waters on richards) first, but yeah. don't love carter, but this team needs to get better, and he's a lot better than colborn or gunnarsson ever will be, and very likely better than what, say, boston's first round pick will become.
 
I don't love Carter but he is a top 6 on any team. I don't like his contract either but hey, these days young (or youngish) top 6 forwards aren't that easy to find.

I'd say Kadri is a non-starter, but if it's Colboune + I'd definitely be interested.

If it's Colborne + 1st I'd do it in a heartbeat.
 
I dunno, I think that kind of price is way too high for a 60ish point guy who's got an 11 year NTC contract.

If Philly can find other teams that are willing to take on that contract (without sending any money back in return) while paying top dollar, then I'd be happy to see them do it. But I don't really want us to be the guys giving a premium price AND taking on that contract.
 
Back
Top