• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Well, sure. Considering Carter tapped out at 46 goals and 84 points while Kessel is yet to crack 65 points.

meh.

Last yr:

Kessel (23): 82gms, 32gls, 64pts (82gms, 32gls, 64pts)
Carter (26): 80gms, 36gls, 66pts (82gms, 37gls, 68pts)

Last 2yrs:

Kessel (23): 152gms, 62gls, 119pts (82gms, 34gls, 64pts)
Carter (26): 154gms, 69gls, 127pts (82gms, 37gls, 68pts)

Last 3yrs:

Kessel (23): 222gms, 98gls, 179pts (82gms, 36gls, 66pts)
Carter (26): 236gms, 115gls, 211pts (82gms, 40gls, 73pts)

Best Year:

Kessel (21): 70gms, 36gls, 60pts (82gms, 42gls, 70pts)
Carter (24): 82gms, 46gls, 84pts (82gms, 46gls, 84pts)

Playoffs:

Kessel (20-21): 15gms, 9gls, 15pts (82gms, 49gls, 82pts)
Carter (21-26): 47gms, 13gls, 21pts (82gms, 23gls, 37pts)

I'd say they've both been pretty similarly productive, especially considering that Carter has generally played with better linemates. But with Kessel being 3yrs younger, IMO there's more upside left to tap.

And Carter's playoff numbers are abysmal, and I have a hard time ignoring that.
 
I dunno, I think that kind of price is way too high for a 60ish point guy who's got an 11 year NTC contract.

If Philly can find other teams that are willing to take on that contract (without sending any money back in return) while paying top dollar, then I'd be happy to see them do it. But I don't really want us to be the guys giving a premium price AND taking on that contract.

i think you're overrating colborne
 
i think you're overrating colborne
No, I'm no huge fan of Colborne or anything. I was pretty underwhelmed that he was the prospect that we got in return for Kaberle, though he did pick things up with the Marlies after his abysmal start with the Providence Bruins. It's more that I'm not really a huge fan of Carter, the player, and I absolutely hate his contract (which to a smart GM, greatly reduces his trade value IMO, especially if you're not sending any cap dollars back in return). So naturally, I wouldn't be eager to give up a whole lot in return for him.
 
Richards fits this club's needs way better, IMO.

I have to admit, I'll be pretty disappointed if we can't land him. I know only one team can but this is a big test for Burke.
 
Yes, but Carter is a 30G 65Pts top 6 forward who is only 26. As much as you may think of Colborne, Colborne + 1st is a very reasonable price to pay for Carter ... and that's only because of his contract. If not for his 11 years contract it'll definitely cost more. In fact, I don't even think Philly will let Carter go for Coloborne + 1st alone.

Do keep in mind this is only a rumor. I don't see any desperate need for Philly to unload Carter or create cap space. Many said they need a goalie but hey, Philly ALWAYS need a goalie and they didn't feel a need to address that last season, I don't think they feel there's a need today. They might as well stay the course and hope Borbovsky mature and develope to become a true #1 next season.
 
Richards fits this club's needs way better, IMO.

agreed completely. but if we offer a package that philly likes we are guaranteed to get carter.

i woudln't swing a deal unless there is some clarity on richards. but if it looks like the chances of getting him are less than 50% then i think you have to look at carter who wil probably be the 2nd best available.

i'm not a huge carter fan. but the leafs need to get better and he's a guy who will make them better.
 
how many 35 goal scorers make less than $5.3mn?

and it isn't like he's signed until he's 40.
No, but he is signed until he's 37. With an NTC that kicks in at the start of next season.

Now, don't get me wrong. While I don't think Carter's an ideal fit, I do absolutely agree with you that he makes us better. But taking that contract off Philly's hands without sending any money back is a huge asset in itself. So, what we give up in return should reflect that. And I personally don't believe Colborne, 1st rounder (and potentially another asset) for Carter is fair value/a smart move for us.
 
It's hard because if we miss out on Richards, we're kinda in a beggers can't be choosers situation when it comes to getting another top line guy. But then Lupul Carter Kessel seems like a poorly constructed first line.
 
No, but he is signed until he's 37. With an NTC that kicks in at the start of next season.

Now, don't get me wrong. While I don't think Carter's an ideal fit, I do absolutely agree with you that he makes us better. But taking that contract off Philly's hands without sending any money back is a huge asset in itself. So, what we give up in return should reflect that. And I personally don't believe Colborne, 1st rounder (and potentially another asset) for Carter is fair value/a smart move for us.

37 isn't bad. most players are still effective at that age. i'd be worried if carter were a banger/crasher, but he isn't. with his size and style he should still be a good player into his mid-to-late 30s.

the ntc is concerning but it is what it is. and if he can put up some 40 goal years then it's a pretty friendly cap hit.

what works against carter is that he isn't a great centre. the contract isn't an issue at all. however unlikely, if he were to prove that 08-09 wasn't a fluke then he becomes a downright bargain. and as it stands, he sin't locked up until he's in his 40s, and the cap hit is reasonable even for a 35 goal 65 point guy. the contract isn't a sticking point. if he's teh best out there then the leafs should make a play.
 
Kulemin - Richards - Kessel
Lupul - Carter - MacArthur




- sign Richards....

- Colborne, 1st, Gunnarson for Carter...

- trade Grabovski for a PM defenseman....

- enjoy home ice in the playoffs.
 
that's an interesting idea. the truth is that carter isn't earning much more than grabovski is likely to ask for on his next contract.

only thing i don't like is that lineup makes it basically impossible for kadri to earn a top six spot next year, and might be difficult to find him a spot moving forward.
 
37 isn't bad. most players are still effective at that age. i'd be worried if carter were a banger/crasher, but he isn't. with his size and style he should still be a good player into his mid-to-late 30s.

the ntc is concerning but it is what it is. and if he can put up some 40 goal years then it's a pretty friendly cap hit.

what works against carter is that he isn't a great centre. the contract isn't an issue at all. however unlikely, if he were to prove that 08-09 wasn't a fluke then he becomes a downright bargain. and as it stands, he sin't locked up until he's in his 40s, and the cap hit is reasonable even for a 35 goal 65 point guy. the contract isn't a sticking point. if he's teh best out there then the leafs should make a play.
Well, we'll have to agree to disagree there. My general point of view is that if I wouldn't be happy signing the player in question to their current contract as a UFA, then if we pick them up in a trade, we damn well better be getting a terrific bargain on them. And then I agree with you that Carter not really being your prototypical natural center is an issue with this idea too.
 
Carter is getting hip surgery. Burke would have to be insane to be pursuing a guy who is heading into hip surgery. If a player as great as Mogilny cannot come back from it, no chance a pug like Carter will.

I put up with the Kessel trade, but no way I will support getting this semi finished floater.
 
Carter's contract is great. He'll still be making just $5 million 5, 6, 7 years from now when guys like that are making a shitload more.
 
Back
Top