• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

don't sell schenn short, teeds.

he, frankly, skates the puck better than gunnarsson and has way better offensive acumen than aulie.
 
Schenn has been carefully crafted and built by Burke for this ocassion. He is obviously very mentally tough, and loves to bang, but he is NOT as physically gifted as Phaneuf, Gunnarson, Aulie or Gardiner. You hate to lose his amazing attitude and mental toughness, but you have to GIVE to GET.

Gardiner? really? Or do you just make this stuff up in your spare time?
 
Gardiner? really? Or do you just make this stuff up in your spare time?


Do we ALL have to put, IN MY OPINION, in every post? Its my opinion that Gardiner is a more gifted hockey player than Schenn.

But as the Boston Bruins just showed, with a top goalie and a lot of muscle, you can win, the Stanley Cup. So Schenn definitely fits into the muscle territory.

And Schenn is built for the playoffs also. But guys like Gardiner, the Sedins etc... can get you INTO the playoffs, via, offensive prowess.

Depends on what you want, but if you want a number one center, you have to give up a great prize. Schenn is one, if not, our greatest young prize.
 
I think Aulie is going to surprise a lot of you. He is NOT going to have a sophomore jinx year imo.
 
I think Aulie is going to surprise a lot of you. He is NOT going to have a sophomore jinx year imo.

i think you need to temper your expectations a little bit.

aulie is going to be a very useful and solid defensive defenseman. i like some of his instincts in pursuit of the puck. he does a decent job of getting point shots through.

but he played well over 20 minutes a game for the final 25 games, and he played in 40 games on the season... despite that he finished with.. 2 goals and 0 assists.

he has very little offensive upside. and that's fine. but it's always going to be a limitation for him.
 
I don't know how old this is butttt

incarceratedbob incarcerated bob

**LEAFS UPDATE**Source: With Laich & most likely Richards off the market Burke focusing on wrapping up Stastny deal & also as backup Weiss
 
I like Aulie, but you put Aulie up against Schenn and you see why Schenn was the 5th overall pick.

Schenn's really shown last season his offensive potential. He's much better than people give him credit for with his outlet pass, with his ability to skate the puck up ice, and his patience with the puck at the point. He still needs to work on his shot, but he's got potential to improve offensively. Defensively he's solid, given his age. McGuire calls him the human eraser for a reason. He just keeps nailing guys and handing out solid hits after hits after hits.

Now, that is not to say I won't trade Schenn. But I see a solid all-round dman in Schenn in the future, and he's got all the intangibles too. It would take a LOT to trade Schenn. OTOH, if there's anyway we can get B Schenn from the Flyers, you gotta go ahead and do that too.
 
Do we ALL have to put, IN MY OPINION, in every post? Its my opinion that Gardiner is a more gifted hockey player than Schenn.

But as the Boston Bruins just showed, with a top goalie and a lot of muscle, you can win, the Stanley Cup. So Schenn definitely fits into the muscle territory.

And Schenn is built for the playoffs also. But guys like Gardiner, the Sedins etc... can get you INTO the playoffs, via, offensive prowess.

Depends on what you want, but if you want a number one center, you have to give up a great prize. Schenn is one, if not, our greatest young prize.

now that you've toned down the Schitt hate to its proper levels, teeds, I pretty much agree with you 100% on your takes on all our young dmen. I think you're pretty much nailing it.

I think Aulie's already better than Schenn, and has a much higher ceiling, and I think Gardiner has the skills to end up ahead of Schenn too. That being said, Schenn is pretty damn good for a 21 year old who plays his type of defensive role, and is worth a good amount.
 
you're overrating aulie and underrating schenn if you think aulie is better.

schenn is better at just about everything. aulie has more speed, but he can't skate the puck at all. and his offensive instincts are nil. a good 3 or 4 notches below schenn's.
 
I don't rate either of their offensive or puckmoving games well enough at the moment to make a difference, and Aulie is already notably better than Schenn defensively, IMO.
 
I don't rate either of their offensive or puckmoving games well enough at the moment to make a difference, and Aulie is already notably better than Schenn defensively, IMO.

i disagree, i think he had the benefit of playing with a very good defenseman who covered a lot of his mistakes (and prevented other ones from happening). as for puck moving.. schenn is very adept at handling the puck on his end of the ice. he does a really good job of holding on to it and fending off the forecheck. it's the most overlooked aspect of his game, and probably his best attribute.

he isn't going to lead the rush, but he's very good at winning possession and skating it to the blueline. very good.
 
if they trade for weiss i'm picking a new team.
Ditto. Thankfully, "incarceratedbob" is full of shit.

Also, no thanks to Christian Erhoff. I used to have some interest in the guy, but when I actually got an extensive opportunity to watch the guy play over the course of the playoffs, I came away pretty unimpressed. The guy's a big shot on the point of the PP, and not a whole lot else.
 
i disagree, i think he had the benefit of playing with a very good defenseman who covered a lot of his mistakes (and prevented other ones from happening). as for puck moving.. schenn is very adept at handling the puck on his end of the ice. he does a really good job of holding on to it and fending off the forecheck. it's the most overlooked aspect of his game, and probably his best attribute.

he isn't going to lead the rush, but he's very good at winning possession and skating it to the blueline. very good.

I think both make plenty of mistakes out there, it's just that Aulie's great skating allows him to recover from them much better.

That's my big problem with Schenn defensively....when he gets beat, he really gets beat.
 
Schenn has been carefully crafted and built by Burke for this ocassion. He is obviously very mentally tough, and loves to bang, but he is NOT as physically gifted as Phaneuf, Gunnarson, Aulie or Gardiner. You hate to lose his amazing attitude and mental toughness, but you have to GIVE to GET.

I swung by my old gym two weeks ago and saw Brayden Schenn going in to workout with Gary Roberts... I can only imagine if Brayden is there, Luke is likely doing the Roberts program as well this summer, so I'm sure he'll be physically ready to go
 
You know who really knows about their ceilings? The guys who play with them IN PRACTISE.

And I cannot get anything negative out of anyone who either played for the Leafs, or is playing for them now. They are terrified of me writing about it. I was up front with all my contacts that I write a lot of spit around here, and as soon as I owned up to that, all I get is the cockamamie rumours.

Since I am potentially doing some huge business with a lot of NHL players, I thought it prudent to be 100% transparent with them, and it sent quite a shock wave down their spines.

Which proves my earlier point made this season, unless these guys are literally on their death bed, and whether they are 21 or 81, NHL personnel and alumni, are terrified these days, of speaking out.

Probably begs another thread, but I won't start it, I am enjoying the peace around here too much.

I think Schenn has the heart of a lion and maybe he plays like young Kovalev in practise, and maybe Aulie does as well.

I think this season will speak volumes about who is better, but for now, its probably only Zeke and myself who feel Aulie is as good or better.
 
Morris says that Richards has other things he's looking for, "He would like to first and foremost, when you've won a Stanley Cup, you want to win another one. He'd like to win again and have an opportunity to be with a team that has younger players coming in to fill and in a market where hockey matters every game, game in and game out with full buildings. A hockey market with an opportunity to win are the top 2 criteria."

There are rumors out there suggesting Brad Richards has his heart set on signing with the Rangers on July 1st. According to his agent Pat Morris, that isn’t the case.

When I asked Pat about this, he told me that “Brad Richards has an open mind to any organization that has an interest in him on July 1st” and that “Any notion of bias to one team or another is purely speculative.” Lastly, Pat noted that “Brad’s refusal to waive his “no trade” is clear evidence of his thoughts.”


...
 
Heh, nice quotes Montana.

But noooo.....Richards to NYR is a lock!!! It's almost like people have forgotten that the source of the whole "Richards to the Rags is a sure thing" stories is Larry Brooks, who is New York's version of Al Strachan or Bruce Garrioch. An old, idiot hack writer that can't think of anything useful to say, so he just devotes his time to making up BS rumours.
 
Back
Top