• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Seams like a very good team guy, hits, skates, hard.... and isn't afraid to drop the mits with anyone. Good 13th forward for games where we need a little toughness.
 
I would qualify all of these as overreactions to a $600k signing.

nonsense.

you can focus on teh dollar amount all you want, but it's irrelevant.

the problem is that they're tying up a spot with another hack. teh dollar amount is irrelevant. sure, they can demote him, but you don't give one-way contracts to guys who you intend on demoting.
 
Seams like a very good team guy, hits, skates, hard.... and isn't afraid to drop the mits with anyone. Good 13th forward for games where we need a little toughness.

except that he IS. he refuses to fight heavyweights.

that's the problem here. they didn't sign an enforcer. they signed a middle weight with no tangible hockey skills, who refuses to fight against guys who know how to throw a punch.
 
Its not nonsense. People overreacted to a minor signing.

Your initial response was the most rational of the bunch, but even you said they had 'cemented' him into the lineup.

To me, this seems like Burke going out and paying a guy for bleeding/fighting for his team. The 1 way part just means that he is getting the same pay in the AHL.

There's no overreaction. Nobody is saying OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE HOW STUPID THEY ARE FOR OVERPAYING FOR HIM.

That can't be right......please god.
 
Dreger says the Leafs have their eyes on Richards Erhoff Upshall and Talbot.

Sorry, the 'reply with quote' button isnt working for me.

Upshall is a new name to the mix, no? Would be interested in him at the right price, I suppose.
 
Its not nonsense. People overreacted to a minor signing.

Your initial response was the most rational of the bunch, but even you said they had 'cemented' him into the lineup.

To me, this seems like Burke going out and paying a guy for bleeding/fighting for his team. The 1 way part just means that he is getting the same pay in the AHL.

well i didn't say 'cemented' i said PRETTY MUCH.

and that's just a fact. the 1 way part means he is going to play in the nhl. in theory somebody could knock him out of a spot, i have never denied that. but the fact that they gave him a one way contract means that is unlikely. and no, it doesn't simply mean that they pay him the same whether he plays in the nhl or ahl. teams don't just hand out 1-way contracts. if they didnt' see him as part of their plans then he wouldn't have gotten a one way commitment.

and people are reacting the way they are reacting because we already have enough hacks wtih no hands. if rosehill were a heavyweight i think people would be just fine with it. but he isn't. and it sure would be nice for this team to bring in a couple of guys for the 3rd and 4th line who can chip in a little offense. especially if they don't end up shoring up the first line.

the fact that they had a bunch of no offence hacks on the 3rd and 4th lines really hurt them in some close games last year. they were almost entirley dependent on 4 forwards for their offence for the first 60 games of the season. that can't happen again. part of fixing that is fixing the first line. but a big part of it is also finding guys for the 3rd and 4th lines who at least bring SOME tnagible skill to the table. rosehill doesn't do that.. and he isn't a heavyweight enforcer whose limitations you overlook because of their fighting ability.

the dollar amount, once again, doesn't matter. neither does the fact that this is a 'minor' signing. the problem is burke sees him in his plans, and shouldn't.
 
his fighting foes last year:

lucic
rupp
lessard
clarkson
gleason
godard
thornton

uhh...

Lucic= arguably a heavyweight. picks his spots, but has held his own (and not held his own) against heavyweights in the past
Rupp= 6'5 and fought most of the heavyweights in the league
Lessard= one of the toughest guys in the AHL and clearly a legit heavyweight
Clarkson= See Lucic, Milan
Gleason= obviously not a heavyweight, but I seem to recall that was more a beating for something Gleason did
Godard= see Rupp
Thornton= A bit undersized but again, has fought most of the heavyweights in the league.
 
I don't mind Upshall, at a reasonable price of course.

Talbot we knew all along.

I don't know why we are interested in Ehrhoff though. I don't believe it, especially knowing Ehrhoff's asking price is ridiculous (and why the Islanders re-traded his rights after a day) ... but if we are seriously interested in adding another top 4 defenseman, then bye bye Luke.
 
uhh...

Lucic= arguably a heavyweight. picks his spots, but has held his own (and not held his own) against heavyweights in the past
Rupp= 6'5 and fought most of the heavyweights in the league
Lessard= one of the toughest guys in the AHL and clearly a legit heavyweight
Clarkson= See Lucic, Milan
Gleason= obviously not a heavyweight, but I seem to recall that was more a beating for something Gleason did
Godard= see Rupp
Thornton= A bit undersized but again, has fought most of the heavyweights in the league.

sorry, but this post is just dumb.

lessard is the only good fighter in the group. and he isn't even good enough of an enforcer to be an nhl regular.

lucic isn't 'arguably a heavyweight' -- he isn't even a fighter. neither is clarkson. neither is gleason. rupp is not a heavyweight, or even an enforcer. and comparing rupp to godard pretty much proves that... you really don't know what you're talking about.

godard and thornton are at least enforcers, though.
 
i don't give a shit about rosehill. i care about burke who needs to make this team better and isn't doing it.

anaheim's and boston's truculence worked because they had guys who were truculent but who could actually play hockey.

burke seems to think that boston won because of thornton and anaheim won because of guys like moen and parros. that just isn't the case.
 
Rosehill might not even play for the Leafs this season. His one way contract doesn't mean he'll be in the lineup every night.
 
yeah but if orr is healthy then he shouldn't be the 13th forward (orr should be), and if orr isn't healthy then he still shouldn't be the 13th forward because i'd much rather go otu and bring in a guy who isn't afraid to fight real fighters.
 
and people are reacting the way they are reacting because we already have enough hacks wtih no hands. if rosehill were a heavyweight i think people would be just fine with it. but he isn't. and it sure would be nice for this team to bring in a couple of guys for the 3rd and 4th line who can chip in a little offense. especially if they don't end up shoring up the first line.

Well there seems to be a fair amount of people that are fine with this signing.

But people were overreacting. You said they weren't. I called you out on it.

the fact that they had a bunch of no offence hacks on the 3rd and 4th lines really hurt them in some close games last year. they were almost entirley dependent on 4 forwards for their offence for the first 60 games of the season. that can't happen again. part of fixing that is fixing the first line. but a big part of it is also finding guys for the 3rd and 4th lines who at least bring SOME tnagible skill to the table. rosehill doesn't do that.. and he isn't a heavyweight enforcer whose limitations you overlook because of their fighting ability.

The much bigger part is fixing the 1st line.

and that's just a fact. the 1 way part means he is going to play in the nhl. in theory somebody could knock him out of a spot, i have never denied that. but the fact that they gave him a one way contract means that is unlikely. and no, it doesn't simply mean that they pay him the same whether he plays in the nhl or ahl. teams don't just hand out 1-way contracts. if they didnt' see him as part of their plans then he wouldn't have gotten a one way commitment.

the dollar amount, once again, doesn't matter. neither does the fact that this is a 'minor' signing. the problem is burke sees him in his plans, and shouldn't.

I disagree. I do not think its a problem, precisely for the fact that it is a minor signing. I would be willing to bet that he plays less than 30 games next year. Interested?
 
they didn't sign him toa one way contract to play him on the marlies and use him on the leafs as an injury fill in.
 
You guys over-react to everything. Rosehill is a Marlie and can fill in on the 4th line if needed

The Marlies also need players, and he has NHL experience playing in the tough guy/grinder role.

This is not a big deal at all
 
Back
Top