• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I wouldn't say Kessel "wanted out".

What happened was in the middle of a slump, the media pressure got to Kessel, and he said he would look at the possibility of a trade if it comes up, and said he's had that discussion with Burke. Of course, 2 days later he back-tracked.

That was a different time though, when Kessel was under pressure to do it all by himself offensively and he also had a sophomore center who couldn't do squat to help him on the ice. When things got better, especially after Reimer got here, I never heard about the "t" word from Kessel anymore. I don't think he really wanted out, and I don't think he'd even look at that alternative evne if Burke asks him now things have changed. It was kindda crazy Burke had 6 young players in his top 6 and let them fend for themselves all year long. In a city like Toronto you really want some veteran to take some pressure off, which is why I think the Connolly signing is needed, and the Lupul trade also helped.

The fact he's working out with Gary Roberts in Toronto during the summer tells you he's determined to be a better player, I will not trade Kessel at this point.
 
Given the silly contracts handed out over the past few days $4.5mn for Malone -- who can score 25-30 goals but also brings size and toughness to the table -- is no longer much of an overpayment. Better yet, his contract was all front loaded over years one through four. He will make $5.5mn in real dollars this year (cap hit of $4.5). That goes down to $3.5 in 2012-13, and $2.5 for the final two years of the deal. In short, he goes from having a Leafs-friendly deal (more money than cap hit) to a small-to-mid-market team-friendly deal (less salary than cap hit).

His value will actually increase next summer.

And given that the problem TBay seems to be having now is real dollars rather than cap hit, he'd be a good contract for them to ship out (same with Lecavalier but finding a suitor will be much, much more difficult).

I would be all over that if I were the Leafs. Macarthur might be of some interest to them given the season he just had and success they've had with the similarly styled (though obviously much, much, much more talented) St. Louis.
 
Yes that's what I was thinking too. If Erik Cole, given his injury history, gets close to $20M / 4 yrs, then Malone's contract only reflects market value today, or even below market value.

Burke has always been tied to Malone rumors in the past, and you gotta think he's not enthusiastic about going to arbitration to find out how much MacArthur is really gonna cost him. He might simply replace the 2nd line winger with Malone.

And that sucks for MacArthur, but that's what happens when you're too focused on the penny and dime.
 
Well, you can't blame him. And I actually kind of like that he isn't just trying to cash in on a long term deal because of one good season. If he repeats with another 55-60 point year then his value increases substantially and he can command more money. Given that he's willing to sign another one-year deal tells me that he's pretty confident he can repeat. That's a good thing.

Still, like zeke said a few weeks back, they need some size in the top six... that precludes trading Lupul and Kulemin (because they bring a bit of size). Kessel is their best player. Connolly was just signed, and between his injuries and question marks in Bozak and Kadri they need to hang on to Grabovski for now.

That leaves Mac as the odd man out...
 
At the same time MacA is confident about himself, he gotta realize this is the first time in his career he's found 1. a key offensive role with a club and 2. the right chemistry with his linemates. Assuming Burke is reasonable, he would be much better off reaching an agreement with Burke than to go to arbitration, because there's a real chance you end up with another team when you do that.
 
At the same time MacA is confident about himself, he gotta realize this is the first time in his career he's found 1. a key offensive role with a club and 2. the right chemistry with his linemates. Assuming Burke is reasonable, he would be much better off reaching an agreement with Burke than to go to arbitration, because there's a real chance you end up with another team when you do that.

okay, but after a 35 point year he was awarded $2.4mn in arbitration... meanwhile he scored 9 more points than leino (who is a pretty similar player), and leino just got a 6 year $27 committment.

With the way free agency is going macarthur could well be in line to demand up to $5mn per on a long term deal when he's a ufa next summer.
 
okay, but after a 35 point year he was awarded $2.4mn in arbitration..

He was never really awarded $2.4 million though, they never went through the process.....Atlanta knew they were walking away regardless, and told them to just award the full amount, which they did.

Luckily for us, the Leino contract also can"t be used as a comparable, during the process......he can only bring up other RFA contracts, to plead his case.


We should still be in a good position for MacA's award to be pretty reasonable, but you're 100% right that if he backs it up again, next years contract would be absurd.

If we could get Malone for him today, I'd pull the trigger.
 
It's actually funny you mention Leino. People talk about how it was a good signing for the Sabres and how he is going to break out in buffalo but in the same breathe if Mac got the same money term people would say he is a one trick pony and Burke over paid again
 
10 years/$90 million

Breakdown:
$12 million
$12 million
$12 million
$10 million
$10 million
$8 million
$8 million
$6 million
$6 million
$6 million

You think Tampa can afford to pay $12 million per year for the first 3 years? At the end the contract becomes trade-able so if we are looking to deal him, smaller market teams might find him attractive at that real-dollar cost.
 
Of course Tampa can afford it. Tampa can afford anything.

Look, they are going to be spending $50+ million next year. There is no better use for any of that money than spending it on Stamkos.

If they have to move guys like Malone, or Downey, or even Hedman or St Louis to keep Stamkos, they will.
 
****. This Stamkos stuff shouldn't even be in here. This is worse than the Eklund crap that's made it's way on here in the past.

Feel like we need a rumours thread and a bat-shit crazy idea thread...so i dont keep coming here to find this crap.

Hope he signs, so then we can move on.
 
He was never really awarded $2.4 million though, they never went through the process.....Atlanta knew they were walking away regardless, and told them to just award the full amount, which they did.

not saying you're wrong, but that's the first time i've heard this. regardless, this would run totally counter to the entire process. given that they use past arbitration awards as a gauge in making their decisions i doubt that the thrashers, nhl, or arbiter would be particularly interested in inflating a player's worth just because the team decided to walk away before the process unfolded.

Luckily for us, the Leino contract also can"t be used as a comparable, during the process......he can only bring up other RFA contracts, to plead his case.

you might have confused my point here. my point wasn't to say that in arbitration he'll get a $4.5mn rewards. rather, arbitration might be an attractive option to macarthur because it will make him an unrestricted free agent next summer, at which point he may be able to command a long term committment appropaching $30mn... whereas it looks like burke only wants to offer him something in the 3 year, $3mn range.
 
StamkosLeafs.jpg
 
not saying you're wrong, but that's the first time i've heard this. regardless, this would run totally counter to the entire process. given that they use past arbitration awards as a gauge in making their decisions i doubt that the thrashers, nhl, or arbiter would be particularly interested in inflating a player's worth just because the team decided to walk away before the process unfolded.

The Thrashers decided before the hearing than they were walking away regardless, and never sent anyone to plead their case....in fact they asked the arbiter to simply award the player their requested sum, to finalize the process as quickly as possible. Which is what he did.
 
****. This Stamkos stuff shouldn't even be in here. This is worse than the Eklund crap that's made it's way on here in the past.

Feel like we need a rumours thread and a bat-shit crazy idea thread...so i dont keep coming here to find this crap.

Hope he signs, so then we can move on.
Agreed. That's the way we did it when a lot of people were convinced people like "Eklund" and "Code" were reputable sources. We had one rumours thread where you could only post stuff from reputable main stream media sources, and then rumours or ideas from anywhere else got posted in another thread. Hell, it may even just be sufficient to start up a "Stamkos fantasy thread" until he finally re-signs in Tampa Bay, and all the rest of the Leaf rumours can continue here.
 
not saying you're wrong, but that's the first time i've heard this. regardless, this would run totally counter to the entire process. given that they use past arbitration awards as a gauge in making their decisions i doubt that the thrashers, nhl, or arbiter would be particularly interested in inflating a player's worth just because the team decided to walk away before the process unfolded.

.

you haven't heard that before? that's what happened.
 
Agreed. That's the way we did it when a lot of people were convinced people like "Eklund" and "Code" were reputable sources. We had one rumours thread where you could only post stuff from reputable main stream media sources, and then rumours or ideas from anywhere else got posted in another thread. Hell, it may even just be sufficient to start up a "Stamkos fantasy thread" until he finally re-signs in Tampa Bay, and all the rest of the Leaf rumours can continue here.

How about we just make it a rule that if you want to post any rumors on this forum you need to provide a source. I mean a real source too. Not eklund. Not "my buddy from so and so". An actual link or some kind of proof that the stuff being said comes from a legitment person with real hockey knowledge.

It will improve the quality of the discussion. Talking about stuff thats made up or is cited from Eklund does acomplish this.
 
Back
Top