• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

He has some skills no doubt. I see him as a top 15 dman, not top four. But HEY, I would love to be wrong.

If Schenn can reproduce those two amazing offensive rushes/goals/scoring opportunities that freaked us all out, say 30 times next season, he will be better than Phaneuf. I see Schenn working on getting to where he wants to be. And somehow I think he wants to be the best dman in the league. A Denis Potvin circa 2011.
 
I personally started to like Dion as a player for the most part, but I don't think he will ever come close to winning a Norris trophy, he is build a little too heavy to constantly jump into the play a la Lidstrom or even Duncan Keith.

I see him a a tier down from that, but hey, nothing wrong with that I suppose.

No, there definitely isn't. Dion is a legit top-pairing dman and we got him for replaceable crap, whether he ever wins the Norris or not. Getting what looks to be a pretty good #4 or maybe even #3 someday, Aulie, is a nice cherry on top. Horrible, horrible trade for the Flames.

We should see a bounceback year for Phaneuf offensively now that our forwards are upgraded skillwise from most of last season's AHL-ridden lineup. Connolly is no elite centre but he's a massive upgrade on Bozak offensively and should provide a nice boost to both special teams. 11/12 Bozak on the third line should be a significant improvement on both Tim Brent and 10/11 "1st line" Bozak. Liles should step in for Kaberle nicely on the powerplay, and we've got some interesting second unit options like Kadri and Franson now.
 
I like Phaneuf, he plays the game with an edge, and hes surprisingly improved in his own end, however to say hes anywhere near the big boys of the league (the charas, lidstroms and keiths) is a huge laugh. Phaneuf has REGRESSED every year in goals/assists/points, hes headed down the redden route it looks, and its too bad because the guy has a shit load of talent.

Phaneuf on most teams would be on the 2nd pairing IMO, even though he does have the talent to be a #1 guy, he lacks the consistenty and mentality to be there for very long.
 
Phaneuf, TO ME, doesn't look like he enjoys the game all that much. He most likely enjoys the money, but the game that he plays, looks joyless. Once in a while he seems enthusiastic, and that ends up being a Norris trophy like game or game streak,then he goes back to being a bean counter.

Schenn, to me, looks like he enjoys the game and wants to be someone for the history books.
 
I like Phaneuf, he plays the game with an edge, and hes surprisingly improved in his own end, however to say hes anywhere near the big boys of the league (the charas, lidstroms and keiths) is a huge laugh. Phaneuf has REGRESSED every year in goals/assists/points, hes headed down the redden route it looks, and its too bad because the guy has a shit load of talent.

Phaneuf on most teams would be on the 2nd pairing IMO, even though he does have the talent to be a #1 guy, he lacks the consistenty and mentality to be there for very long.

Just stop. Right now. Please.
 
Well the good thing is, and I think ALL here can agree with it, is that Phaneuf had a much better second half than he did a first half. It was very good to see. Vewy pleasing. May it continue.
 
I'm not as high on Phaneuf as most of you Leaf fans, but that post goes way overboard. He's a legit top pair D on virtually every team in the league. I doubt he comes anywhere close to a Norris win again, but he's still a solid defenseman.
 
Just stop. Right now. Please.

Whats so in-accurate about the post I made? Can you honestly sit there and say Phaneuf (the current version) is in the same playing field as guys like Zdeno Chara or Nik Lidstrom, I dont think you can based on his stats.

I'll admit I was wrong about Phaneuf being a no 2 guy, based on his salary, your right by default he'd have to be a top defencemen for most other teams in the league.
 
Well the good thing is, and I think ALL here can agree with it, is that Phaneuf had a much better second half than he did a first half. It was very good to see. Vewy pleasing. May it continue.

I loved Phanuef's 2nd half: he was air tight in his own end, he was levelling guys with hits, his shot was actually hitting the net ( i know rare right? lol) and he even got some goals. Lets hope he keeps this type of play up for next season.
 
Whats so in-accurate about the post I made? Can you honestly sit there and say Phaneuf (the current version) is in the same playing field as guys like Zdeno Chara or Nik Lidstrom, I dont think you can based on his stats.

I'll admit I was wrong about Phaneuf being a no 2 guy, based on his salary, your right by default he'd have to be a top defencemen for most other teams in the league.

So Lidstrom and Chara are the only number 1 D in the league then?

You are a twit.
 
You called him 2nd pairing

You compared him to Redden.

At worst Phaneuf is a number 2 D on most teams....at best a number 1.

I second the suggestion for you to play in traffic
 
No but you said he would be a number 2 (pairing) on most teams...indicating that he is not a true number 1 defender, which is what most are laughing at.
 
Back
Top