• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Pearl Jam isn't quite standing the test of time, IMO.

They were my favorite ever for my high school years, but now listening to Ten is just good, not great.

I think U2 gets overcriticized as most big acts do - they have a shitload of first-rate music, that should satisfy even the most snobby music listeners.

that being said, when I saw them live at the dome they stank.
 
Best live show I've ever seen is Nine Inch Nails. It's funny, because although I like their music, they're probably not even, or just barely in my top 10 favourite bands. But Reznor puts on such a fantastic show that I've seen them live more times than any other band.
 
Im jealous, artnes....maiden must have been an amazing show. Hell, listening to them on recordings is better than many other live shows.
 
that being said, when I saw them live at the dome they stank.

This is what makes Pearl Jam. Live they are incredible. And they bring it every night. Eddie is one of the best frontmen ever IMO. He can read the energy of the crowd and know excatly what to do to blow the roof off the palce.

I've seen them too many times, and every time seems better than the last.
 
I heard they were great.
Started listening to them recently, and went to a concert of theirs at the ampitheatre last Thursday.. blew me away.

[video=youtube;v86dZR93mTg]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v86dZR93mTg[/video]
[video=youtube;2QzGvoUMBoA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QzGvoUMBoA[/video]
[video=youtube;oVJ-DuRZrik]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVJ-DuRZrik&feature=related[/video]
[video=youtube;XhYr1Dc6u-c]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XhYr1Dc6u-c[/video]
 
Not even in the same league. I like Pearl Jam a bit and all and I think Eddie Vedder is great song writer. But as some else posted U2 has 2 of the best albums in rock history (Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby) and not to mention the dozens of other hits they've had.

Sorry but I think I U2 would kick the shit out of a Pearl Jam show.

Also I think Eddie Vedder would laugh in someones face if they tried to tell him his band was better than U2.

Having said all that, I think Pearl Jam is good, Ten is an awesome album.

Just not in the same ballpark.


Yeah, but you also think Led Zeppelin is "okay"
 
Im jealous, artnes....maiden must have been an amazing show. Hell, listening to them on recordings is better than many other live shows.

They will be back for another tour of Canada soon enough so you'll have to check them out when they do.

Dickenson is in a full sprint for 2 hours running around stage and he never misses a note. Amazing singer
 
Not trying to get anyone going, but Maiden? Are you referring to the Aleister Crowley wannabe satanic group? Iron Maiden? Now don't berate the messenger, but if you are going to listen to satanic verse, at least make it enjoyable and go for ACDC or Black Sabbath.

I guess it takes all types and tastes, but Iron Maiden? All I hear is a demonic babble of bad music. But that is your choirboy teederspeak.
 
Not even in the same league. I like Pearl Jam a bit and all and I think Eddie Vedder is great song writer. But as some else posted U2 has 2 of the best albums in rock history (Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby) and not to mention the dozens of other hits they've had.

Sorry but I think I U2 would kick the shit out of a Pearl Jam show.

PJ did have the best debut rock album in history

U2 does not come close to the live show/experience. The best thing about PJ is they change their setlist every night. Im going to 4 shows in 5 nights in Sept. and every show will be different. The energy, the crowd, it changes peoples lives. I have multiple friends who went from being casual to crazy die-hard from going to just one show.

Also I think Eddie Vedder would laugh in someones face if they tried to tell him his band was better than U2.

oh 100%

Having said all that, I think Pearl Jam is good, Ten is an awesome album.

Just not in the same ballpark.

listen to some live shows. It will change your perspective
 
Pearl Jam isn't quite standing the test of time, IMO.

Oh you couldnt be more wrong. Still selling albums, packing large stadiums and believe it or not growing their fanbase. They are also very well respected in the industry and have a huge, huge following.
 
Last edited:
Albums full Teeds, albums

Ten was the greatest debut rock album of all time, and VS was a huge hit. It was right before their tour for Vitalogy when they sued ticketmaster and went into obscurity.

A lot of their stuff after that [mid 90's] was never heard of or talked about because they didnt release any singles or music videos. But No Code, Yield, Binaural are fantastic. Riot Act didn't do so well, and it doesn't translate live well at all. But Self-Titled and Backspacer are also very strong.

If you weren't already a die-hard by the mid 90's you were not in the know. It wasn't until their self-titled album in 2006 where they started to do more publicity again.
 
Last edited:
I don't even like KISS, but a friend did, and I have to admit they kick ass live. Can only handle so much Paul Stanley though,
I've seen Maiden a couple times, best was the first Powerslave tour with Twisted Sister opening.
Seen Ozzy when he was great...and not so great.
I've seen some great concerts, but it's not always the performance that makes it great...sometimes you just have such a great time you can't be objective.
Worst show ever was definitely Motley Crue Shout at the Devil Tour. Chicks were so hot I died, but the band was drunk and couldn't even fake it.
Accept opened so that was good.
 
Yeah, but you also think Led Zeppelin is "okay"
I don't hate Led Zeppelin or anyhing, I own several Zeppelin albums. I'm just not ahuge Zeppelin guy. All of them have an insane amount of talent.

Music is so subjective

PJ did have the best debut rock album in history

Best in terms of what? Sales?

I would think that Appetite for Destruction would have to be up their for sales? And as on overall album AFD kills Ten. And I'm just using Gun N Roses as an example, I'm sure there are a lot more.

listen to some live shows. It will change your perspective

I have. I have a buddy who has played the shit out of Pearl Jam. And like I said, I think some of their music is great. I just don't see/hear all of it.
 
Back
Top