• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Malone is the big physical offensively capable forward that this team sorely lacks. We don't have to watch another season from this team to realize that. We saw them play last year and it was a huge weakness... and we have added a total of one forward this offseason.. and he's not exactly the toughest dude in the world.

This player that you believe Ryan Malone to be....he has never consistently been in his NHL career.

More pertinent though, is what he is now...

2 Yr splits

62GP 18G 25A 43PTS

Why do you want to pay 4.5 x 4 for that?
 
Wow what a horrendous post.

Malone is the big physical offensively capable forward that this team sorely lacks. We don't have to watch another season from this team to realize that. We saw them play last year and it was a huge weakness... and we have added a total of one forward this offseason.. and he's not exactly the toughest dude in the world.

How was that a horrible post?

The scope of the team has changed so much since last year.

As an example, where was Bozak on the depth chart last year? Where is he this year?

The lineup is tremendously different, so its not even fair to compare the two (this roster vs. last seasons). we have not even observed how players/line mates are going to interact with each other, we have not seen how any of our youngsters/new draft picks will do in training camp.

Are you really that sold on putting Malone into our lineup? Who, in the top 3 lines, would you have Malone replace? I just do not see a spot where he is worth replacing another player.

And that does not even take into account his terrible contract, as Mindz pointed out.
 
Everyone gets so stressed about the cap. I'm interested in good players that fit my team. If you're not willing to overpay for players, you're going to continue losing like the Leafs. The cap is high enough now that it really doesn't mean shit. Guys like Komisarek and Malone can easily be traded to plenty of poorer teams in the later years of their contracts (when the salary is lower than the cap hit) to help them reach the cap floor. This cap paranoia that everyone is obsessed with is so stupid.
 
How was that a horrible post?

The scope of the team has changed so much since last year.

As an example, where was Bozak on the depth chart last year? Where is he this year?

The lineup is tremendously different, so its not even fair to compare the two (this roster vs. last seasons). we have not even observed how players/line mates are going to interact with each other, we have not seen how any of our youngsters/new draft picks will do in training camp.

Are you really that sold on putting Malone into our lineup? Who, in the top 3 lines, would you have Malone replace? I just do not see a spot where he is worth replacing another player.

And that does not even take into account his terrible contract, as Mindz pointed out.
Yea, you're right. Our forwards have changed drastically. We have gotten much tougher at center with the addition of Connolly and we're just too good for Malone to fit into our lineup. We have such great forwards that Malone can't even crack our lineup.
 
Everyone gets so stressed about the cap. I'm interested in good players that fit my team.

I still don't see how Ryan Malone (the real Ryan Malone, not the mythical creature you call Ryan Malone) is a good player who fits our team. He's big and not useless offensively for a big guy...that's it. Surely if you see that calibre and type of player as a necessity, you'd rather see someone who isn't on the wrong side of his peak added instead, even if it's more costly.

If you're not willing to overpay for players, you're going to continue losing like the Leafs

Overpaying for the sake of overpaying is stupid. It's where in your lineup that you overpay that is the trick. You overpay on Brad Richards, you don't overpay on Ryan Malone.

The cap is high enough now that it really doesn't mean shit.

Tell that to the Flyers

Guys like Komisarek and Malone can easily be traded to plenty of poorer teams in the later years of their contracts (when the salary is lower than the cap hit) to help them reach the cap floor. This cap paranoia that everyone is obsessed with is so stupid.

If it was easy, Komisarek would be elsewhere right now. So would Jeff Finger for that matter
 
I know who Ryan Malone is. 4.5 million doesn't get you the "mythical player" that you think I think he is. I just don't see him as THAT overpaid for what he brings to the table. Flyers didn't need to trade Carter and Richards at all if you look at their cap situation. They could have kept both, went with Bobrovsky instead of Bryz, and still be under the cap. Or they could have just traded one of the two and got Bryz.. either way, they would have made out just fine. Those were hockey moves by Holmgren (which I didn't think were good moves necessarily), but he got pretty good value for those two and he pulled the trigger. Richards and Carter were known party animal alcoholics and I think they just wanted a culture change. Not to mention Richards known feud with Pronger and locker room divisions developing as a result.

As for your Komisarek theory.. he's making 5.5 million dollars this year. Not exactly attractive for a small market team. Next summer will be the time to trade him when his salary drops to 3.5 for the last two years. Malone's drop in his latter years is even more drastic, but I'm thinking we'll want to keep him if we acquire him.
 
Yea, you're right. Our forwards have changed drastically. We have gotten much tougher at center with the addition of Connolly and we're just too good for Malone to fit into our lineup. We have such great forwards that Malone can't even crack our lineup.

You didn't answer my question. Who, in our current top 3 lines, would you take out of the lineup to replace with Malone?
 
Whoever doesn't earn their spot in training camp. This isn't a good enough team to gift wrap spots in the lineup.

And there are always injuries.. whoever doesn't crack the healthy lineup will still likely end up playing a shitload of games. And if you're really concerned about this, we can trade someone easily.
 
Last edited:
I know who Ryan Malone is. 4.5 million doesn't get you the "mythical player" that you think I think he is. I just don't see him as THAT overpaid for what he brings to the table. Flyers didn't need to trade Carter and Richards at all if you look at their cap situation. They could have kept both, went with Bobrovsky instead of Bryz, and still be under the cap. Or they could have just traded one of the two and got Bryz.. either way, they would have made out just fine. Those were hockey moves by Holmgren (which I didn't think were good moves necessarily), but he got pretty good value for those two and he pulled the trigger. Richards and Carter were known party animal alcoholics and I think they just wanted a culture change. Not to mention Richards known feud with Pronger and locker room divisions developing as a result.

AKA...the Flyers wanted to fix their goaltending problems, but couldn't afford to without making drastic roster moves...due to the cap.

As for your Komisarek theory.. he's making 5.5 million dollars this year. Not exactly attractive for a small market team. Next summer will be the time to trade him when his salary drops to 3.5 for the last two years. Malone's drop in his latter years is even more drastic, but I'm thinking we'll want to keep him if we acquire him.

My theory? It's your theory that mistakes like him are easy to move.
 
AKA...the Flyers wanted to fix their goaltending problems, but couldn't afford to without making drastic roster moves...due to the cap.
AKA Ed Snider and/or Paul Holmgren didn't like having chronic partying alcoholics on their team and guys who cause problems in the locker room so he traded them for some great returns and they are still a pretty damn good team in the end.

But yea, Komi and ESPECIALLY Malone will be easy to move starting next summer. Low annual salaries + high cap hits are attractive to small market teams whether you like it or not.
 
AKA Ed Snider and/or Paul Holmgren didn't like having chronic partying alcoholics on their team and guys who cause problems in the locker room so he traded them for some great returns and they are still a pretty damn good team in the end.

After they signed the same two guys to decade long contracts....designed to keep their cap hit lower than players of their calibre would usually demande. All sorts of moves being effected by the "meaningless" cap apparently.

But yea, Komi and ESPECIALLY Malone will be easy to move starting next summer.

So which part of having to wait a calender year to move them makes it "easy" to do so?
 
They just got embarrassingly swept by Boston after a season of rumored locker room tension and off-ice partying. Changes were going to be made regardless. They were a cup favorite to start the season and had a horribly disappointing second half+playoffs.

And again, for the last time.. low annual salary+high cap hit players are attractive to small market teams. Especially with Malone, because not only is his annual salary going to be lower than Komisarek's (with a higher cap hit to boot), but he can actually play hockey. He is not comparable to Jeff Finger at all. Komisarek will be tougher to trade and a lot may depend on the season he has this year, but it is still very possible we trade him next summer.
 
They just got embarrassingly swept by Boston after a season of rumored locker room tension and off-ice partying.

Swept in a series that they again received hilarious goaltending in...using all 3 of their goalies unsuccessfully...after hearing this song numerous times, they decided to bring in a legit #1 star starter and would have happily kept everyone in place had it not been for the "meaingingless" cap.

Changes were going to be made regardless. They were a cup favorite to start the season and had a horribly disappointing second half+playoffs.

and they didn't have the capspace to make the major move they wanted to make without moving some major salaries. They picked the salary with decade long contracts signed to be cap friendly...None of what has occurred in Philly points to the salary cap being "meaningless". In fact...doing things like trading for the shitty Meszaros contract and trading for the middling Hartnell and signing him to 4+ million is exactly what got in the way of Philly adding the goalie they wanted without trading 2 of their top forwards.

And again, for the last time.. low annual salary+high cap hit players are attractive to small market teams. Especially with Malone, because not only is his annual salary going to be lower than Komisarek's (with a higher cap hit to boot), but he can actually play hockey. He is not comparable to Jeff Finger at all. Komisarek will be tougher to trade and a lot may depend on the season he has this year, but it is still very possible we trade him next summer.

If Ryan Malone continues his trend of higher missed game totals, with lower point production, you're still going to have trouble finding a dance partner regardless of the gulf between his real salary and cap hit.

Bad contracts are bad contracts...when you have to tell yourself before you even trade for the guy "when this goes bad, yeah, I'll be able to move him" it's probably a bad idea to bring him in at all.

Ryan Malone is a bad contract, and isn't a good enough player to make up for it.
 
If Leafs are taking on Malone's contract, the Leafs will likely get a good draft pick or prospect along with him -- like they did in the Lupul and Lombardi deals.

And if that's the case, bring on Malone.
 
Lupul was much younger, signed to much less term. Lombardi ditto...All 3 are similar offensive performers overall though.

Tampa doesn't have an asset other than Brett Connolly that should be of interest to us to take on Malone's salary (unless we're sending Komi back of course)

Carter Ashton just isn't (nearly) enough, and he's one of their top prospects.
 
2yr:

R.Malone (31): 123gms, 35gls, 85pts (82gms, 23gls, 57pts) - $4.5/4yrs


that's a much better pickup than, say, signing Erik Cole.
 
Back
Top