• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Turris makes a case for arguments that budding stars >> top 5 picks. :)

Seriously, while you can argue Turris already has bust written all over them (and wouldn't be the first for the Coyotes organization), he does have plenty of 'but's in his defense.

Turris was a classic case of a prospect rushed into the NHL. He was promoted directly from junior to the NHL at the age of 18, and though he has struggled he has only played a grand total of 9 AHL games between then and now. He isn't in the best development program, and his contract hold-out could simply be seen as a case where instead of being greedy, he's simply looking for an out of a depressing organization with no future.
 
My first reaction is no because of the deal he's looking for.

Yeah, but we have the cap room, and I am assuming it would not be long term. 2-3 years at $3m is not hard to swallow.
 
if he WANTS in to the Leafs organization, or out of the Yotes, I'd do it. If this is just a case of him wanting more than Pheonix thinks he's worth, no thanks.
 
Well, to be fair, if Turris makes even a semi-legit contract request, there's no way the Yotes organization would let a former #3 overall pick go at the age of 21.
 
Turris is still really young. He'll be a good player. But the guy doesn't bust out by 21 and people freak out.

I think he was a little overhyped to begin with in the first place, but the guy has talent, and will be a good NHL player. Whether or not he becomes a front line talent like people think he can be remains to be seen.

I'd for sure try and steal him from Phoenix over a contract dispute. Not sure about moving Bozak though.
 
No thanks to Turris. I'd rather roll the dice on Bozak.

Turris is just way too unproven and difficult to project. He never played junior hockey. Instead he played two years in the second rate BCHL and then one year in the NCAA after being drafted by the Coyotes. So, who knows what to make of his BCHL stats, and then NCAA stats are notoriously hard to project. The fact that he'd make the contract demands that he's making after accomplishing nothing in the NHL so far also severely reduces my interest in him.
 
Well, there's a pretty big difference between 13th overall pick and 3rd overall pick, I'd think. When was the last time a team gave up on their 3rd overall pick after 3 years?
 
No thanks to Turris. I'd rather roll the dice on Bozak.

Turris is just way too unproven and difficult to project. He never played junior hockey. Instead he played two years in the second rate BCHL and then one year in the NCAA after being drafted by the Coyotes. So, who knows what to make of his BCHL stats, and then NCAA stats are notoriously hard to project. The fact that he'd make the contract demands that he's making after accomplishing nothing in the NHL so far also severely reduces my interest in him.
Turris would be a gamble for sure, no question about that.

If you want young, high end talent without drafting them yourself, it will always require a gamble. And I'd think if not for an excellent preseason opener, a lot more ppl would be willing to give up Bozak after his sophomore season.
 
Well, there's a pretty big difference between 13th overall pick and 3rd overall pick, I'd think. When was the last time a team gave up on their 3rd overall pick after 3 years?
Jack Johnson would be the last one. But here are a bunch of other examples of recent high picks getting dealt:

Nikita Filatov: Drafted 6th overall in 2008, dealt in 2011
Jakub Voracek: Drafted 7th overall in 2007, dealt in 2011
Phil Kessel: Drafted 5th overall in 2006, dealt in 2009
Peter Mueller: Drafted 8th overall in 2006, dealt in 2009
Jack Johnson: Drafted 3rd overall in 2005, dealt in 2006
Andrew Ladd: Drafted 3rd overall in 2004, dealt in 2007

...anyways, that's a few.

The other thing to consider is that being drafted 3rd overall in 2007 may not really be a huge deal, as most of that year's top-10 (and first round) is shaping up to be busts or marginal players. Patrick Kane at #1 has obviously turned into a franchise player, and van Riemsdyk seems to be turning into the player people thought he would be. Besides that, only Logan Couture at #9, Brandon Sutter at #11, Max Pacioretty at #22 and David Perron at #26 have shown definite signs of being good NHL players by this point.
 
Turris would be a gamble for sure, no question about that.

If you want young, high end talent without drafting them yourself, it will always require a gamble. And I'd think if not for an excellent preseason opener, a lot more ppl would be willing to give up Bozak after his sophomore season.
Trading Bozak now would definitely be a move from the JFJ playbook: SELL LOW.

Now, that being said, I do understand the logic behind a move like this: in general, if you can get yourself a top pick that you still think has potential, a player like Bozak isn't a steep price to pay. I just don't happen to think much of Kyle Turris, individually, as a prospect.
 
Jack Johnson would be the last one. But here are a bunch of other examples of recent high picks getting dealt:

Nikita Filatov: Drafted 6th overall in 2008, dealt in 2011
Jakub Voracek: Drafted 7th overall in 2007, dealt in 2011
Phil Kessel: Drafted 5th overall in 2006, dealt in 2009
Peter Mueller: Drafted 8th overall in 2006, dealt in 2009
Jack Johnson: Drafted 3rd overall in 2005, dealt in 2006
Andrew Ladd: Drafted 3rd overall in 2004, dealt in 2007

...anyways, that's a few.
So first of all, I do agree, 2007 was a POOR year for drafts. After Kane, and JVR, pretty much the only top line player is Couture.

That said, your other examples aren't exactly comparable.

Ladd was drafted in 2004, traded in 2008, 4 years later not 3. Ladd also had a rather injury-prone start to his career, the Canes weren't sure how well he would hold up in the long run and that was part of the consideration. Finally, Ladd's past season with Atlanta was actually a case of a gamble paying off ... albeit for the 3rd team.

Jack Johnson was actually a TERRIBLE trade by (again!) the Canes, where Rutherford was mad he couldn't get Johnson under contract and made it personal. He was traded for only Gleason and Belanger, and the 24 year old, who had 42 points with the Kings last season, will be a fixture on the Kings' blueline for YEARS to come.

Mueller actually asked for a trade and it was a trade where the Coyotes actually got very good value for him. Coming off two 40-ish points seasons Wolski was in the middle of a very good season at the time of the trade. It is not comparable to the Turris for Bozak rumor.

in Kessel the Bruins got again a very good package, including two 1st rounders, a 2nd rounder and a 3rd roudner. That is again not comparable to the Bozak rumor. Not to mention, Kessel was already a developed player at the time of the trade, thus further differentiating from the Turris trade.

Filatov is the only situation here that's somewhat close to the Turris trade, and I think it was a good trade for Ottawa as well. Obviously, Bozak carries higher value than 3rd rounder, but both Filatov and Turris has top end talent and potential. You also have to keep in mind Filatov has all kinds of bad blood with CBJ, including the whole flying back to Russia and bad-mouthing Hitch and CBJ ... the whole ordeal.
 
Turris for Bozak? In a heartbeat. Please, the Coyotes wouldn't do this trade, even if we sweetened the deal by throwing in Komisarek. :sarcasm
 
Wasn't really saying those examples were comparable #17....just gave you a list of all the most recent top picks I could find that were dealt within three years of getting drafted.
 
You left off Schenn too.

Its too soon to say about Voracek, Schenn, Mueller (because of injuries) and Filatov,
but LA certainly didn't regret picking up Johnson, and Chicago didn't regret picking up Ladd.

Kessel is debatable, but not because of his addition as a player, but rather what the cost ended up being.
 
I'm onboard, Turris just wants out of PHO by the looks of it (and he won't be the last). Wheeler (a 5th overall pick in 2004), refused a contract and made himself a free agent just a few short years ago.
 
Both the Ladd/Ruutu and the Mueller/Wolski trades were just scenery changers for both teams.

In Filatov, the Sens risk having to match any KHL offers next season and could realistically lose the player regardless of how good/bad he is this season.

In Turris, the Coyotes have no leverage. If Turris is unhappy with his situation there (GM, coaching etc...) his agent has convinced him that he can back out.

A Bozak/Turris trade has the potential to be highway robbery for the Leafs.
 
Back
Top