• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

the stakes were raised significantly this summer.

the carter/richards trades suggest that there's no point in looking at trades like the phaneuf deal as a basis for comparison.
 
exactly, Spezza, like Phaneuf go cheaper because of the cap hit they have. That was one of the main reasons Pheneuf was dealt with for so little.

Murray will want Kadri, but I bet Burke turns it into Grabs +....

Again not saying this is happening AT ALL. but Connolly at 4.5 mill could easily slide into the second spot and Spazza into the first.
 
you aren't going to get a first line centre in a deal centred around a 2nd liner, whose a whole year younger than spezza, and has pending ufa status this summer.
 
Well, when you put it that way, sure. But alot of that is innacurate.

Spezza is not the defensively defficient player that he was when he joined the league 5+ years ago. He'll never be a two-way forward, but he's capable of keeping himself in the + category by keeping the puck on his stick. He's a puck possession type player. His lack of "grit" is a fair knock, ala Joe Thornton. Both are big guys that aren't overly physical.
I think we're pretty much in agreement about his defensive issues. I realize he's not 19 year old Jason Spezza anymore, but he's never consistently going to be a guy who you can count on in your own end or on the backcheck. Which like his lack of grit, may be less of an issue, if one of the main motivations for a hypothetical Spezza to Toronto trade wouldn't be to pair him up with Phil Kessel.

As for the money, you did just spend nearly 5 million dollars for a player who has been less productive and more injury prone over the past 3-4 years.

Giving up assets to your largest rival is certainly a point addressing why he wouldn't be moved over though. That's for sure.
Yep, Connolly is definitely a clear notch below Spezza. More injury prone, and less productive. But besides this past year, his production numbers aren't really too far off:

Tim Connolly:

10/11: 0.62 PPG
09/10: 0.89 PPG
08/09: 0.98 PPG
07/08: 0.83 PPG

Jason Spezza:

10/11: 0.92 PPG
09/10: 0.95 PPG
08/09: 0.89 PPG
07/08: 1.21 PPG

....and at $2.25 million dollars less per season, on a two year deal instead of four years left on his deal and no cost in terms of trade assets, that makes Connolly's deal look pretty reasonable, and like the smart alternative to this team to trading for Spezza.
 
Wouldn't say I hate Spezza. He's undeniably talented, and I'm sure he'd be a lethal combination with Phil Kessel. But when you combine his injury problems, his defensive issues, his lack of "grit" (which may not be a huge issue if a good portion of our forwards weren't already of the smallish/not gritty variety), the huge amount of money getting paid out to him over the next few years and the steep price in terms of players that we'd have to pay to a division rival...I don't think he's the right fit for us.

Couldn't agree more..Spot on!
 
the stakes were raised significantly this summer.

the carter/richards trades suggest that there's no point in looking at trades like the phaneuf deal as a basis for comparison.
In general, the Phaneuf deal is probably a bad comparison to any other trade scenario. From the day it was made, I think it was universally acknowledged around the league that it was an absolutely atrocious deal that made no sense whatsoever for Calgary. That hasn't really changed for the better since then, especially with Keith Aulie playing on our first pairing with Phaneuf as an extra kick in the teeth to the Flames.
 
Wouldn't say I hate Spezza. He's undeniably talented, and I'm sure he'd be a lethal combination with Phil Kessel. But when you combine his injury problems, his defensive issues, his lack of "grit" (which may not be a huge issue if a good portion of our forwards weren't already of the smallish/not gritty variety), the huge amount of money getting paid out to him over the next few years and the steep price in terms of players that we'd have to pay to a division rival...I don't think he's the right fit for us.

i agree with this until the last sentence.

spezza absolutely isn't the ideal option.

but this team desperately needs a first line centre and this guy, when he's on, is a top ten centre in this league.
 
kadri + grabovski + franson/gunnarsson + a pick

Oh my dear lord. Throw in the ACC as part of the deal too, while you're at it.

That would make the Phaneuf trade look like a ripoff FOR Calgary.

Why would any of you want Spezza? He's talented, but he's been born and bred in an organization that turned choking into a fine art. The guy would lead us to a few more goals, but nowhere near the Stanley Cup.
 
Don't want Spezza ... Burke keep saying if we're paying a hefty price (i.e. not a band-aid solution like Connolly) then you gotta get someone who on the ice and off the ice is someone you identify as someone you can build the team around.

Unfortunately, Spezza isn't that guy.
 
Oh my dear lord. Throw in the ACC as part of the deal too, while you're at it.

That would make the Phaneuf trade look like a ripoff FOR Calgary.

Why would any of you want Spezza? He's talented, but he's been born and bred in an organization that turned choking into a fine art. The guy would lead us to a few more goals, but nowhere near the Stanley Cup.
Spezza as a #1 centre took that "choking" team closer to a cup than Sundin ever did.
 
Banks and institutions realize something that you guys almost never do. We are sliding into a very steep financial abyss right now, and guys like Melynyk who have made their money off the back of a bloated stock bull market can see that we are going into the opposite atmosphere right now. Forget that the US dollar just snuck up like I said it would( and everyone attacked me for) and is now higher than the CDN dollar.

Kadri for Spezza would make Melynyk drool, forget Murray. This ain't about talent or equal billing for Ottawa. Ottawa has lost two CFL football teams, even Toronto supports that shit.

The NHL is a business, and its the business of hockey. Murray likes Kadri, our management doesn't, and Spezza is part of what Ottawa wants to divest themselves of. Burke will trade Kadri AND Grabovski this year, IF he can.
 
What is your point?

Put Sundin on the Pizza Line-era sens instead of Spezza and they go just as far if not further.
Trust me, no part of me thinks Spezza >=Sundin.

I'm just countering the idea that Spezza wouldn't help a team get closer to the cup...afterall, he already did help one team get within 3 wins.
 
Banks and institutions realize something that you guys almost never do. We are sliding into a very steep financial abyss right now, and guys like Melynyk who have made their money off the back of a bloated stock bull market can see that we are going into the opposite atmosphere right now. Forget that the US dollar just snuck up like I said it would( and everyone attacked me for) and is now higher than the CDN dollar.

Kadri for Spezza would make Melynyk drool, forget Murray. This ain't about talent or equal billing for Ottawa. Ottawa has lost two CFL football teams, even Toronto supports that shit.

The NHL is a business, and its the business of hockey. Murray likes Kadri, our management doesn't, and Spezza is part of what Ottawa wants to divest themselves of. Burke will trade Kadri AND Grabovski this year, IF he can.
Ottawa can only get rid of about 3 million dollars worth of coin before hitting the cap floor. That fact kinda blows this entire post out of the water.
 
I have always liked Spezza. I like Kadri, quite a bit, but if someone on the Leafs doesn't kick the shit out of him, someone on another team most likely will. He can apparently really smoke out a room. Anyways, like a lot of rumours, one side or another will most likely chicken out at the last minute.

Burke would love to dish Grabovski and Kadri and get a Spezza or a Lecavellier instead somehow. He likes BIG, skilled, center ice men. Heck, he would probably slice of a finger on his left hand still for Joe Thornton.
 
Ottawa can only get rid of about 3 million dollars worth of coin before hitting the cap floor. That fact kinda blows this entire post out of the water.

I didn't want to say anything too controversial, other names are involved. Grabovski for one. Komisarek for another. But lets face it, MURRAY and MELNYK aren't stupid enough to take Komisarek. So the deal will most likely fail. Toronto also would love to have Cowen.

100% Burke wishes he had taken Cowen over Kadri. 100%.
 
heh ... if Burke wanted Cowen, he would have grabbed him.

And seriously, when's the last time Toronto and Ottawa made a trade?
 
Back
Top