• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Doan is old. Really old.

Is that a guy we want to invest good prospects into? Sure he is a nice player, but given his age and the likely wear and tear on his body i would have to say no thanks. Tyler Bozak or Carl Gunnarsson are both young enough to grow with this team. If we are giving up prospects who look like they can play in the NHL, we should be getting a guy that is:

A. Substantially better
or
B. Can grow to be substantially better

Now if this was 8 years ago, you might be on to something.

Turris on the other hand, no thank you.
 
doan is the sort of guy you go after as the last piece. if the leafs are in the playoff hunt, and could use that sort of player and veteran presence, and he's available at the deadline then they absolutely should make a move.

but, yeah, not right now.
 
I'd love to pick up a guy like Doan, or Smyth as a UFA next year, but the Leafs cant give up major assets for a 35 year old rental at this point..
 
doan is the sort of guy you go after as the last piece. if the leafs are in the playoff hunt, and could use that sort of player and veteran presence, and he's available at the deadline then they absolutely should make a move.

but, yeah, not right now.
Yep. If the Leafs are cruising into a home-ice playoff spot once the deadline rolls around, I'd be fine with us coughing up future assets for a veteran like Doan. But since I strongly suspect that this hockey club is not yet at that level of its development, I'd rather them pass on such a move for now. Just get back to the playoffs, and then see what the young guys we've got can do once we get there.
 
So hopefully Lashoff does not get snagged from another team on waivers.

Any interest in Brule? If he comes to us on waivers, I would take a look at how he performs in the minors- looks like another case of a talented player being rushed too quickly to the NHL.
 
So hopefully Lashoff does not get snagged from another team on waivers.

Any interest in Brule? If he comes to us on waivers, I would take a look at how he performs in the minors- looks like another case of a talented player being rushed too quickly to the NHL.
Well, the problem with that idea being that if you claim a player on waivers, you have to put them on your NHL roster. If you then wanted to send him down to the minors, you'd have to put him on waivers yourself. Either way though...no thanks. Brule's just yet another bust in a long line of busts picked by Doug MacLean during his time with the Blue Jackets. And it's not like he's some recently drafted young player that just needs a chance of scenery. He was drafted in 2005, he's played over 260 NHL games and he's already on his second team. He's just a bust, plain and simple. This is his upcoming career path: he'll go through waivers unclaimed, have an unremarkable season or two in the AHL, maybe one more failed training camp tryout with another NHL team and then he'll be headed for Europe.
 
As far as waivers are concerned, this is a funny time of year for them. You'd expect that a lot more players would be scooped up, but by and large they're all snuck down to the minors. I get the sense that there is an unwritten code that GMs don't poach waivered players early season.

It also sucks for players who do get scooped, as they get a quick audition with another team and are usually waived again.
 
As far as waivers are concerned, this is a funny time of year for them. You'd expect that a lot more players would be scooped up, but by and large they're all snuck down to the minors. I get the sense that there is an unwritten code that GMs don't poach waivered players early season.

It also sucks for players who do get scooped, as they get a quick audition with another team and are usually waived again.

Nick Johnson got picked up
 
I don't think it's really an unwritten code per se BG. It's a combination of a couple of things. One is that the teams haven't played a single game yet, so all the GM's are still hopeful about the teams they've put together and the players they've acquired. They want to at least see them play a handful of games before they start making changes.

The other thing to consider is that claiming someone at this stage of the game sort of undermines the idea of earning a job in camp. Imagine Burke taking Matt Frattin aside now and saying "hey Matt, we like what you did in camp and you've played well enough to be one of our top 13 forwards...but we've decided to demote you and give a chance to this Gilbert Brule guy that couldn't earn a spot on the Oilers."

You don't do that unless you're absolutely sure the guy you're picking up is a substantial improvement on what you've got.
 
Also the majority of guys who are waived are waived because they aren't good enough for the NHL or make too much money.
 
yeah these guys all stink. they're table scraps, and unless you have a scout really pushing for a particular player why would you give a spot to a guy who wasn't really good enough for the nhl over players who busted their asses trying to hack it on your team?

the difference between contending or not isn't picking up brule to replace dupuis or boyce....
 
Never hurts to bring him in and play him on the Marlies though and have him available for depth.

Or, package Bozak, Kadri, Franson and get something good, and then stick Brule on the 4th line.
 
Never hurts to bring him in and play him on the Marlies though and have him available for depth.

Or, package Bozak, Kadri, Franson and get something good, and then stick Brule on the 4th line.
Again though, as was already said above...not an option. If you take somebody off waivers, then you have to keep him on the NHL roster. Otherwise, if you want to send him down to the AHL, just like the Oilers you have to put him on waivers yourself. Seriously though, some people are actually interested in Gilbert Brule? I don't get it.

As well...Franson's not getting traded. If Burke has to pick a defenseman to ship off and the choice comes down to a Swedish John Ferguson Jr. draft pick or a 6'5" BC boy that Burke just traded for this summer, do you honestly think he'll decide to trade Franson?
 
Back
Top