• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

What about Dustin Brown. He plays a gritty game and is now redundant with mike Richards in town. He isn't a play maker per se but his game could give kessel the space bee needs. Plus LA could move him with the way their salary is now going
 
I think we'd better tread carefully. Conjuring fantasy trade scenarios involving your team trading for Vinny Lecavalier is sort of a Hab fan specialty, isn't it? We wouldn't want to step on their toes.
 
I'm bored, twitter rumour says Leafs trying to land MPS from Oilers.

Who would you give up for him and what do you think it would take?
 
I'm bored, twitter rumour says Leafs trying to land MPS from Oilers.

Who would you give up for him and what do you think it would take?

The better question is WHERE we fit? He wouldnt be good on the Kessel line, the grabo line is set, he could play the third line but that would mean Kadri/Frattin are buried in the AHL. What would it take to get him? Schenn would be the starting point, I would think they would also want someone like Lupul and a 1st, I also have this gut feeling they would want to dump Horcoff on us.

To Toronto: Horcoff, MPS

To Edmonton: Schenn, Lupul, 1st
 
I think if Burke's interested in anybody from Edmonton, it would be Hemsky. He is looking for guys that can make an impact right now and are a clear improvement over what he has.
 
If Lupul is healthy, are any of those guys a significant upgrade?

Now if somehow we push Lupul down to the 3rd, we can really put ourselves into a position to make noise.

Penner*- Connolly - Kessel
Kulemin - Grabovski - MacArthur
Lupul - Lombardi - Armstrong
Brown - Steckel - Orr

*or some other big winger

Lots of salary, Komisarek would have to go for sure.
 
Volc is right, it only makes sense to trade for another forward if they're a clear upgrade on what we've got now. And guys like Dustin Penner and Sam Gagner sure as hell don't fit the bill there. As for MPS from Edmonton, I'm not really sure why the Oil would be looking to deal him at this point, and I'm also not really sure exactly what hole he fills on our forward lines.
 
i'm kind of curious to see what lupul can do. while penner's size would be welcomed, he isn't really an upgrade on lupul, imo. and if lupul can get his career back on track he might even be a downgrade.

lupul hasn't been healthy since he was 25. now, you can count that as a knock against him, but it is worth recalling that by the time he was 25 he already had 3 20+ goal seasons under his belt, and 46 points in 56 games as a 24 year old.

there might still be some upside left in him. i'd give him some time.
 
If Lupul is healthy, are any of those guys a significant upgrade?

Now if somehow we push Lupul down to the 3rd, we can really put ourselves into a position to make noise.

Penner*- Connolly - Kessel
Kulemin - Grabovski - MacArthur
Lupul - Lombardi - Armstrong
Brown - Steckel - Orr

*or some other big winger

Lots of salary, Komisarek would have to go for sure.

Problem is, where's Frattin and Kadri? Not sure I'd trade those guys for Dustin Penner, and I'm not prepared to sit them for him either.
 
Plus to me that line with Penner-Connolly-Kessel is such a huge question mark. As already mentioned Lupul is looking very good out there..in fact that whole line is getting better with each game..You don't even have Bozak and you have Connolly (which imo might not work as well)..but we'll see.
 
At this point the Leafs need to make another Kessel/Phaneuf deal if they are going to make a big trade. Not for a guy like Penner or Bourque.

The Leafs have some depth and can afford to give up some good assets, and still need a top line forward or two.
 
i'm kind of curious to see what lupul can do. while penner's size would be welcomed, he isn't really an upgrade on lupul, imo. and if lupul can get his career back on track he might even be a downgrade.

lupul hasn't been healthy since he was 25. now, you can count that as a knock against him, but it is worth recalling that by the time he was 25 he already had 3 20+ goal seasons under his belt, and 46 points in 56 games as a 24 year old.

there might still be some upside left in him. i'd give him some time.
Agreed. This is a big season for him. This is the first time in a very long time that he was healthy going into the summer, and was able to get a full summer of conditioning in and participate in a full training camp. Even a return to the form he showed in his last fully healthy season (08/09) when he scored 25 goals and 50 points would be excellent, but if he could ever duplicate the ~30 goal/~70 point pace he put up in 56 games the year before over a full season, that would be an absolute coup.

I'm certainly more interested in seeing what Lupul can do than Penner. Penner got every opportunity to be a top-line forward in Edmonton, but besides that one 30-goal year, he was a huge disappointment. And he's been absolutely terrible with the Kings so far.
 
Trading Lupul to replace him with Penner would be a totally stupid move. Lupul is indeed going to surprise many due to his injury history. He's looked great as soon as he's been with the Leafs. Stick with him - he's going to have a very solid season.

I'm not in favour of making a move for a forward unless it's an elite player, which is unlikely. Let Frattin and Kadri show their stuff before making a move damnit!
 
I'm thinking hold Lupul....the leafs are absolutely due in the karma department and you gotta think that his strong play in the first two games is hinting at some kind of resurgence.
 
Back
Top