• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Doesn't really matter. Dupius is a better hockey player though. You don't have to limit his ice time like you do with brown, and he's been almost as physical as Brown and is a better Pker, which is pretty much all Brown brings to the table other than the odd, needless fight.

A Steckel-Bozak-Dupuis line can play 12-15 minutes a game if need be, and you don't have to worry about them being on the ice against anyone other than the other teams 4th line, which is a big positive from a 4th line IMO.

I kinda disagree with this. I think Brown and Dupuis are on a similar level with both offensive ability and pk. You are going to tell me a guy like Brown who gets to the point as quick as anyone and will block a shot with his face is somehow less valuable on the pk? If anyone should sit it's Steckel..I don't care for a guy who only has face off abilities..I'll say it again, if this guy is so good at other things why is this his 3rd team in just over a year?..Are the other teams that stupid to get rid of him so easily? Anyways, I want speed, hitting, sacrificing the body and some offensive ability..he doesn't bring much of that. Plus we can imagine that 4th line all we want but you can be sure that one of Orr/Rosehill will be there..Wilson and Burke always seem to think it's important to have at least one big fighter on there.
 
Brian Burke, adding one slightly better player to the roster, while adding a great dressing room presence, one player at a time.

And if you are looking to humanize yourself, and check in with lost parts of your soul, in other words, get a decent cry going, watch this. I like a good cry once in a while, reminds me that I am not a PS3 player piece.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrgazfgOk80
 
Yeah, Brown isn't as good of a PKer as Dupuis. Brown blocks shots, but he stinks at reading the play and getting his stick in the passing lanes which is one of the most important aspects of PKing from a forward. Plus Dupuis is better on the forecheck, and there have already been a couple of instances so far this year, of him being able to kill some time by keeping the puck down low in the other teams end which is something that Brown can't do.

Steckel is more valuable than both of them. And as for being physical, he's been by far the most physical Leafs forward so far this season with 6 hits in 2 games.
 
Just to further that point here is the players PK GAon/60 from last year:

Brown - 9.85
Dupuis - 7.15

further they both averaged the exact same pk time per game:

Brown - 1:35
Dupuis - 1:35

And while the Leafs shitty goaltending was a factor in their poor PKing, Colorado was one of the few teams in the NHL with goaltending that was worse:

Toronto - .904
Colorado - .890

Lastly, overall both guys played on a bottom 3 PK:

28. Toronto - 77.5%
30. Colorado - 76.1%

So both guys played on similar PK units, with similar shitty goaltending and received similar minutes, and Dupuis was on the ice for an average of over a full 2.5 less short handed goals against per 60 minutes than Brown. He's a much better PKer.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, Brown isn't as good of a PKer as Dupuis. Brown blocks shots, but he stinks at reading the play and getting his stick in the passing lanes which is one of the most important aspects of PKing from a forward. Plus Dupuis is better on the forecheck, and there have already been a couple of instances so far this year, of him being able to kill some time by keeping the puck down low in the other teams end which is something that Brown can't do.

Steckel is more valuable than both of them. And as for being physical, he's been by far the most physical Leafs forward so far this season with 6 hits in 2 games.

I have a feeling you will be very dissappointed with Steckel. Can you point out exactly what you like about him besides the face off ability? His hitting? Anybody on the 4th line should be able to hit..You say Brown doesn't do it as well but the best hit of the game was his during start of the game when he nailed Ottawa dman and put him on his ass. To me Steckel will be Ron's new Wallin (except not sure if Wallin was good at face offs)..The guy stinks at reading the play yet he will be given plenty of chances to ruin our games when it comes to last minutes of the game.
 
Have to say, I don't really see what you're seeing with Dupuis leafman. I suppose I'll have to watch him more carefully, but at this point I don't even like him as much as Boyce to be honest. There isn't really any part of his game that's stood out to me, so if I'm picking between him and Brown, who is good defensively and can also create plays and momentum with his speed and physical presence (see: game 1 vs. Montreal), it's an easy choice for me.
 
I have a feeling you will be very dissappointed with Steckel. Can you point out exactly what you like about him besides the face off ability? His hitting? Anybody on the 4th line should be able to hit..You say Brown doesn't do it as well but the best hit of the game was his during start of the game when he nailed Ottawa dman and put him on his ass. To me Steckel will be Ron's new Wallin (except not sure if Wallin was good at face offs)..The guy stinks at reading the play yet he will be given plenty of chances to ruin our games when it comes to last minutes of the game.

I won't be disappointed in Steckel, I know exactly the type of player he is. He is a big bodied, solid 4th liner, who is maybe the best faceoff man in the NHL. I'm not expecting any more than that.

And I value faceoffs very highly.
 
Have to say, I don't really see what you're seeing with Dupuis leafman. I suppose I'll have to watch him more carefully, but at this point I don't even like him as much as Boyce to be honest. There isn't really any part of his game that's stood out to me, so if I'm picking between him and Brown, who is good defensively and can also create plays and momentum with his speed and physical presence (see: game 1 vs. Montreal), it's an easy choice for me.

Dupuis is not a great player or anything, but the only real benefit guys like him and Brown bring to the team is on the PK. And the numbers flat out show that Dupuis is better there.

And Brown really isn't that good defensively. He blocks shots, but that is it. Every time the 4th line has got caught on the ice against anything but the other teams 4th line the last two years they cant get the puck out of their end. Dupuis can take a regular shift, and guys like Brown, Rosehill and Orr can't really.
 
Have to say, I don't really see what you're seeing with Dupuis leafman. I suppose I'll have to watch him more carefully, but at this point I don't even like him as much as Boyce to be honest. There isn't really any part of his game that's stood out to me, so if I'm picking between him and Brown, who is good defensively and can also create plays and momentum with his speed and physical presence (see: game 1 vs. Montreal), it's an easy choice for me.

If you like Brown, you will like Dupuis, just give him some time. Overall they are pretty similar players (both are quick and can create offensive chances from good forechecks, good pk players too).
 
I have a feeling you will be very dissappointed with Steckel. Can you point out exactly what you like about him besides the face off ability? His hitting? Anybody on the 4th line should be able to hit..You say Brown doesn't do it as well but the best hit of the game was his during start of the game when he nailed Ottawa dman and put him on his ass. To me Steckel will be Ron's new Wallin (except not sure if Wallin was good at face offs)..The guy stinks at reading the play yet he will be given plenty of chances to ruin our games when it comes to last minutes of the game.

His face off ability is more than enough reason to like him. Throw in the fact that he appears to be a heady guy on the PK, has good size and decent enough hands to work a cycle and help keep the puck deep and he's almost exactly what I'd want as my 4th line centre. Leave the hitting on the forecheck to the wingers (you don't really want your 4th line C getting that deep into the offensive zone without puck possession anyway.
 
Well, like I said, I'll have to watch Dupuis a bit more closely. For now, I think you're reaching a bit if you think those stats prove Dupuis is a "much better PK'er" than Brown. And based on what I've seen, i like what Brown brings to the table and haven't really seen anything that demonstrates Dupuis can take a regular shift.

But yeah, in the end it isn't like we're talking about dressing Tim Brent instead of Nazem Kadri. Both Brown and Dupuis are 4th line plugs.
 
I prefer guys like brown and boyce on my 4th line, just because they can actually boost the entire team when needed with a superlative energy shift.
 
Boyce is a 5th line center. Brown is awesome for his role.

Brown provides the energy, Dupuis is really good with that too from what I see, and Steckel provides the faceoffs and defensive presence. They all play physical, two of them are really fast, a really good 4th line overall.
 
Connolly seeming less and less likely, leaving after only 15 min of practice today.

I really hope they give Kadri a chance (if he's ready)

Lupul – Kadri – Kessel
MacArthur – Grabovski – Kulemin
Lombardi – Bozak – Armstrong
Steckel – Dupuis – Brown

I think he'd rise to the challenge...
 
I still think Connolly can be a very solid contributor for us, but it's definitely easy to turn against the guy when he's having serious injury problems before he's even played a game for us. And as long as Kessel and Lupul keep on producing without him, it doesn't matter a whole lot when he gets back.

And Aberdeen, I'd absolutely love to see Kadri get a chance to center that line, but I think that ship has sailed. The Leafs seem committed to keeping the guy as a winger.
 
I'm cautiously optimistic... and if we're worried mainly about the quality of our 4th liners - then we're probably doing okay.
 
Back
Top