It's the top six bottom six thing. Kadri is a scorer--they want him on the top two lines. They only want him to play if he can hack that. I was watching the Tampa Buffalo game the other day, and it got me thinking about Kadri and why he wasn't playing. There is such a small margin of difference between winning and losing in the league these days. In days gone by, a 2-0 lead like Buffalo had would have been end of the game--but not any more. A bounce and some sloppy reads by Buffalo later, and the game was tied despite a terrible performance by the Lightning in the first.
The blind passes and turnovers deep in the opposition zone turn into scoring chances against in the trap world that is the NHL now. Although Orr and Rosehill suck, they are not competing directly with Kadri. They are the kinds of players who can sit or play depending on the team and the mood of the coach. Kadri needs big minutes on top lines--wherever that may be.
As far as Frattin goes, despite his lack of points, you can clearly see why the Leafs love him. He does something every game (flashes)--whether it is driving to the net, hitting posts (getting scoring opps), slapping people around on the forecheck, or staying out of the way on a puck that might have been called back due to kicking--to show the Leafs he is ready to contribute in any way possible. Because of his ability to create out of power, he can play on many lines and produce whatever his role. He's a smart, strong skating, useful player.
It's unfortunate that the Leafs didn't just forgo Connolly and let Kadri take over the job--but they don't see him as a center because of his lack of ability on draws or in the corners. Basically, he's become a finesse winger that needs to score and create offence without making the turnovers.
To be honest, this isn't Kadri's first kick at the cat. By now, he must know he can't turn the puck over like he did against Philly and stay in the lineup. Especially for a coach who is dealing with defensive issues and has a mandate to win immediately--AND there are salaried players who need spots and have proved to the coach they can help out defensively and play a two way game better than Kads (Wilson has already commented he feels Bozak is excellent defensively, despite his lack of O). Kadri can't kill penalties, hit effectively, or frankly, be dominant enough offensively to keep a spot on a team that can ill afford mistakes.
It's all upstairs for him now. He's as big as he's going to get. If he was a bigger stronger player he'd be given more of a leash. Because he isn't, he's got to play more like a Marty St. Louis--a smallish player who uses his anticipation and speed to create opportunities and break up chances for the opposition. That's the kind of play they want from him--but I think the coaching staff and the GM don't trust him enough yet to develop that way. So, it's back to the minors again until he proves he can use his head ALL the time.