• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I wouldnt consider it a panic move. Given Nabby's salary and term length its a quick solution for the time being. I like Scrivens but you are essentially gambling seeing he is not a proven starter. And we have all seen how the gambling with goalies has turned out for us before
 
Funny, when I suggested one of the best things we could do to improve this past offseason was to bring in a veteran goalie, I was scoffed at.

Burke can't afford to screw around again this year though. if he can get a goalie he should do it ASAP while we've still got our heads above water in the standings.
 
Let's not ruin Scrivens ... he's clearly not ready for NHL now but he's still got a future IMO

Burkie, make a call to Turco, sign him for cheap and he can be the band-aid until Reimer's ready.
 
He had a .897 through 26 games. So he'd actually be a huge upgrade on Gus, but probably not enough.
 
It still shocks me that Nabokov's star fell as quickly as it did. Here was a goaltender coming off of three consecutive seasons in which he won at least 41 games (albeit on an excellent team), and posted a .922 save percentage in his final full NHL season, and he simply couldn't find work.

With that said, he's more of a .910-.915 guy but that still makes him a good NHL goaltender and certainly is the type of performance that the Leafs would love to receive from Reimer over the rigours of a full regular-season. If they can nab him from the Islanders without giving up the proverbial farm you would think Burke would be all over it. He knows that the Leafs cannot afford to take another season-killing chance on giving the reigns to Gus or an unproven Scrivens, especially when its unknown if Reimer's concussion will negatively impact him during the rest of the campaign.
 
There were rumblings of Komisarek to NYI earlier in training camp/preseason... I wonder if that could be part of a package for Nabby + ...

Isles definitely need d-men, and have some interesting young forwards I imagine would appeal to Burkie.
 
Funny, when I suggested one of the best things we could do to improve this past offseason was to bring in a veteran goalie, I was scoffed at.

Burke can't afford to screw around again this year though. if he can get a goalie he should do it ASAP while we've still got our heads above water in the standings.

the point is, in case of emergency (i.e. your #1 getting seriously injured), it's always easy to pick up one of these vet backups if needed.

Scrivens should get a real shot before any middling vet backup anyways, though.
 
At what point do you throw the towel in on Scrivens if you do give him a shot if he falters?

5gms? 10 gms?

I like Scrivens and think he will be a good goalie but we have been bitten a few times gambling with goalies.
 
No need to throw Scrivens under the bus. Gus obviously stinks. replace him immediately, and go with Scrivens/Solid Vet.

And if/when Reimer's back the best guy can be the backup.

But the last thing this team needs is to go an extended amount of time with Gus and Scrivens sharing the net. And unless Scrivens is awesome and can play 82 games in a row, you need another goalie.
 
Well, we've got this discussion going in a few threads and I'm kind of repeating myself, but here goes as far as the goaltending situation is concerned:

1) Gus should be finished. Give Scrivens one or two more starts.
2) If Scrivens doesn't get the job done, acquire another goalie ASAP.
3) NO Turco. Turco stinks, and now he's also old and finished.
4) Nabokov should be choice #1, due to his contract length, size and his track record of regular season success.
 
Im with leafman and say get Nabby regardless. Who knows how long Reimer will be out and like he said, you need two capable goalies. Gus shouldn't even be in the building anymore let alone on the bench
 
At what point do you throw the towel in on Scrivens if you do give him a shot if he falters?

5gms? 10 gms?

I like Scrivens and think he will be a good goalie but we have been bitten a few times gambling with goalies.

well, depends on what "falters" means.

If he plays like he has the last two outings, then it's one or two games, tops.
 
Im with leafman and say get Nabby regardless. Who knows how long Reimer will be out and like he said, you need two capable goalies. Gus shouldn't even be in the building anymore let alone on the bench
Probably true. Especially in light of his comments last night regarding our goaltending, you have to wonder how hard our coach, who happens to be Nabokov's former coach, is pushing for such a move? And you also have to wonder how willing the Isles will be to trade him to another Eastern conference team, especially when it's a team that conventional wisdom says will be battling for the same last few playoff spots that the Islanders would like to be in competition for this year.
 
The thing about grabbing one of these vet backup goalies is that whatever we give up for them, we can likely get right back come the deadline if/when Reimer is healthy again.
 
Back
Top