he's career faceoff percentage is like 42 or something, no? without showing any signs of improving?
i wouldn't fall into a trap of defining whether or not a player is capable of playing centre based on his faceoff %.
going back to 07-08 malkin is
39.3
42.4
40
38.5
45.4
now, i understand that malkin's talent is such that you play him where he wants to play and feels more comfortable. but it's an example of a team playing a player at centre despite ineptitude in the faceoff circle and it not really affecting the team whatsoever.
a more apt comparison might be connolly, who is also bad on the faceoffs (he trends around the 45% mark). but when you factor in his abilities and style of play i think we can all agree that it would be patently stupid to play him on the wing.
i think that the importance of faceoffs can sometimes be overstated. yes, you need a guy or two who is capable of winning key draws in the defensive zone. it can also help if your top centre can win them in the offensive zone on the powerplay (since it immediately gives you position).
but the truth is that the difference between a first line centre who wins 55% of his draws (which is very good) or 45% of his draws (which is bad) is only, on average, a swing differential of about 2-3 per game on an average night for a first liner.
to illustrate, let's assume that 18 is an average number of faceoffs for a first, second or third line centre to take (that was about the average from the leafs' game against nashville: steckel had 17, bozak had 20, connolly had 19).
55% is 10/18
44.4% is 8/18
this is just a quick and easy example, but, without disregarding that there is a benefit to being strong in the faceoff circle, having a centre who is bad on the draws really doesn't have an enormous impact on outcomes.
some guys are just better at centre. they need the extra ice to maximize their effectiveness. maybe that isnt' the case with gagner, but his early expereinces on the wing suggest that might be the case. and i woudln't rule him out as a centre just because he isn't great on the draws. it isn't htat big of a deal.