• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

No, number17 is right. You're massaging some pretty dubious stats to make...I'm not sure what point. That Turris hasn't actually been a disappointment so far? That he's somehow proved somewhere that he has good offensive potential? That he's worth trading something of value for, and inserting into our top-9?

massaging the numbers would be taking those per minute totals and extrapolating them into real points based on increased ice time.

leafman didn't do that. he just demonstrated that he produced decently given his ice time.
 
exactly. Those numbers show that Turris actually did produce last year, and was efficient offensively given his ice time. Would he score 60 points, or 90 points or 20 points in a larger roll, who knows. Why did he not get more minutes? It doesn't really matter.

There have just been debates over his lack of NHL production, so I looked at the numbers and they showed there wasn't really a lack of production.

I've said it before, but http://www.behindthenet.ca is a great site. We used to have to spend hours just calculating simple stats to compare players and now there is just a wealth of advanced stats out there.
 
Here is another great stat, % of a players shifts that finish in the offensive zone:

1. Lupul - 61.9%
2. Kessel - 58.6%
3. Crabb - 58.0%
4. Bozak - 57.4%
5. Lombardi - 56.8%
6. Connolly 55.6%
7. Dupuis - 55.0%
8. Brown - 54.2%
9. Steckel - 52.8%
10. Grabo - 50.3%
11. Frattin - 48.8%
12. Kulemin - 45.2%
13. Mac - 44.5%

The Leafs have 9 guys in the top 110 players in that stat. Seems like they spend a lot of time in the other teams end.
 
Last edited:
you make it sound like he was playing for a hack team.

phoenix had 99 points last year and 107 points in 09-10.

and leafman didn't give any false perceptions about anything.

he just gave context to the arguments against turris and pointed out that his production wasn't bad in light of his ice time.

the faulty assumption people are making is that he only got that ice time because he stinks. it could be an assortment of reasons... just like (As leafman has argued) there are an assortment of reasons for kadri not getting ice time with the leafs right now, despite the fact that i think the vast majority here think he should be.

that doesn't mean that turris has been great, or hasn't been a disappointment. it is only to say that perhaps people shouldn't write him off entirely. which is a perfectly valid point to make. we're talking about a 22 year old who was a top 3 pick just 4 years ago.

..add to that, it's really not Turris's fault that he was selected at #3. Take a good look at the 2007 draft and tell me who would have been a better selection (at the time) to potentially be a "franchise player" for the Coyotes? The kids barely played a season and a half in the league, has increased his production the last two seasons (averaging 12mins/game for a defensive-minded coach) and played some above average play-off hockey. Really nothing to write-off here.
 
massaging the numbers would be taking those per minute totals and extrapolating them into real points based on increased ice time.

leafman didn't do that. he just demonstrated that he produced decently given his ice time.
Real points ir not is not even the point, but P/60 min and G/60 min are extrapolation based on an incorrect assumption and that's why they are misleading.

It's not against leafman, but P/60 and G/60 minutes essentially takes the player's P and G, divide them by the icetime and then EXTRAPOLATE them into 60 min. That assumes a player can produce on the same pace if given more minutes, which is not true for most players. It completely ignores the fact some players can produce with limited role and limited icetime, but even if you give them more icetime they can't produce more. That's why the stat is misleading.
 
If you say /60 isn't extrapolate, then you clearly have a misunderstanding of the definition of extrapolation.

/60 is calculated by taking a players' PPG or GPG, divide by his icetime, then TIMES 60.

Times 60 is the extrapolation part.
 
you reference a 'faulty assumption', and yet you're the only one making an assumptions.

extrapolating, in the context of turris's statistics, would be using the production per 60 minutes stat to argue he would have scored XX number of points if he played more minutes. that would entail an assumption, and be an example of 'massaging' statistics through extrapolation.

as it stands, 'extrapolating' to 60 minutes serves no purpose other than to provide a common reference point that avoids using infinitesimally small numbers. we could just as easily not do that and look at points per minute (avoiding your extrapolation issue), but then we're dealing with minutia that can be difficult to compare.

in any event, it seems that you're the only one making assumptions here: based on how leafman is using the data (he isn't using it to suggest turris's statistics would have been XX had he played XX minutes), and based on how turris performed last year.
 
Its not extrapolating anything. Its just how many points he scored per 60 minutes of ice time.

Eg if you scored 1 point in 3 games, and played 20 minutes per game, then your p/60 minutes is 1. You played 60 minutes. Scored 1 point. Thats all that stat is.

Its not like taking ppg and multiplying it by 82 games when the guy only played 5 games. Its just how many points a guy scores on average in 60 minutes of ice time.

Points / minute and points /60 minutes is the exact same statistic, just on a different scale.
 
Last edited:
Real points ir not is not even the point, but P/60 min and G/60 min are extrapolation based on an incorrect assumption and that's why they are misleading.

It's not against leafman, but P/60 and G/60 minutes essentially takes the player's P and G, divide them by the icetime and then EXTRAPOLATE them into 60 min. That assumes a player can produce on the same pace if given more minutes, which is not true for most players. It completely ignores the fact some players can produce with limited role and limited icetime, but even if you give them more icetime they can't produce more. That's why the stat is misleading.

No thats not what id does at all. All stats measure is what has occurred. If you want to use them to try and predict the future, thats your business, but that is not what they are saying.

What Turris's production/icetime stats suggest is that he did in fact produce efficiently last season when you consider how little he actually played. That is it. And that is not misleading in the least.
 
Real points ir not is not even the point, but P/60 min and G/60 min are extrapolation based on an incorrect assumption and that's why they are misleading.

It's not against leafman, but P/60 and G/60 minutes essentially takes the player's P and G, divide them by the icetime and then EXTRAPOLATE them into 60 min. That assumes a player can produce on the same pace if given more minutes, which is not true for most players. It completely ignores the fact some players can produce with limited role and limited icetime, but even if you give them more icetime they can't produce more. That's why the stat is misleading.

Players with any offensive pedigree tend to pull away from those that can only produce in limited roles after about 250 NHL games played, or 3 full training camps. At this point it's clear that Turris (and Boedker and Tikhonov) was rushed into the NHL and is therefor behind the curve when it comes to development. That the NHL owns the team and NEEDS playoff revenues in order to recoup some of their lost investment - doesn't bode well for developing youngsters as they're on very short leashes.

I don't blame Turris for a minute about wanting out, I don't agree though with how it all went down. For that I lay blame on his agent.
 
Yeah 17 not sure how you equate posting efficiency stats with extrapolating. Extrapolating involves using a smaller sampler size and then applying the information from that over a larger sample (ex. using the P/60, multiplying it by increased ice-time, and assuming that is what Turris would produce based on the smaller sample). Extrapolating is taking the information you know (P/60), and assuming it will apply and remain consistent over a larger sample. The stat leafman used isn't an extrapolation so much as a ratio; x points : x minutes. The scale he chose to use was 60 because it makes nicer looking numbers. You could do x points : 30 minutes, or 120, etc. It doesn't really matter as the first x will always be proportionate to the second o

Leafman didn't do that, he's just showing the rate that Turris produced in the ice time he received. Nobody has tried to claim this shows that Turris will continue to produce at a comparable rate (for example's sake, let's say Kulemin #s) if given more ice time. It's possible, maybe not plausible, but nobody is making that argument.

The argument is that, relative to his ice-time, Turris has produced efficiently.

The stat leafman used isn't an extrapolation so much as a ratio; x points : x minutes. The scale he chose to use was 60 because it makes nicer looking numbers. You could do x points : 30 minutes, or 120, etc. It doesn't really matter as the first x will always be proportionate to the second one.

And yeah, I can definitely understand why Turris would want out of Phoenix.
 
Some Swedish fan on the other board posted a link of a swedish source that claims the Leafs have interest in two SEL players. Burke was just in Sweden a couple weeks ago I believe.


NHL-klubben Toronto visar intresse för Skellefteåduon Joacim Eriksson och Pierre-Edouard Bellemare.

http://hockey.expressen.se/elitserien/1.2633731/nhl-klubb-ute-efter-skellefteas-stjarnor



Joacim Eriksson, Goalie, 6'2, 187, 21 years old
10/11: 17 gms, 906 SV%
11/12: 11 gms, 940 SV%

He was drafted by Flyers in the 7th round in 08' but the Flyers choose not to offer him a deal. Doesn't look like a wise move at this point, given it looks like he's having a breakout year.



Pierre-Edouard Bellemare, Wing, 5'11, 190, 26 years old
10/11: 53 gms, 10 gls, 18 pts (82 gms, 15 gls, 28 pts)
11/12: 23 gms, 8 gls, 17 pts (82 gms, 29 gls, 61 pts)
 
massaging the numbers would be taking those per minute totals and extrapolating them into real points based on increased ice time.

leafman didn't do that. he just demonstrated that he produced decently given his ice time.
Personally, I think digging for an obscure stat that ranks Turris higher among Phoenix forwards, and then dismissing his lack of ice-time as a result of a coach's bias against young players rather than a result of Turris's poor play/lack of actual tangible offensive production is a good example of "massaging the stats". Especially when you also go on to claim that because of his points per 60 minutes results, scoring 25 points in 65 games actually isn't a disappointing lack of production.

I still maintain my point that I don't have the slightest interest in the Leafs pursuing him, because Turris hasn't proven anything at any level, unless you can extrapolate something useful from BCHL/NCAA production, or you put a lot more stock in points/60 minutes stats than I do.
 
All that other stuff is just pure speculation (other than Tippett not liking to play young players. I'm not the first guy to say that, but for argument sake, whatever). Why he didn't play more minutes is nothing that either of us can say with certainty.

The one thing we can say with certainty is his production, given his minutes, was efficient, and not poor. That is what the stat says. If that doesn't change your mind about Turris, fine, it doesn't have to, it is only one small piece of the whole equation. I'm not using the stat to say Turris is amazing, or that he was one of the better players on the coyotes.

But the bottom line is he produced efficiently given how little he actually played. You don't have to put any stock into the stat, but that is what it tells us.
 
Pierre-Edouard Bellemare, Wing, 5'11, 190, 26 years old
10/11: 53 gms, 10 gls, 18 pts (82 gms, 15 gls, 28 pts)
11/12: 23 gms, 8 gls, 17 pts (82 gms, 29 gls, 61 pts)

Thanks for the info PTBNL.

I dunno about that SEL guy, Rickard Wallin has ruined any overage SEL players for me.
 
Back
Top