• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

gunarsson is nothing special.

let's not forget that aulie looked just as good last year. playing next to a norris caliber defenseman will do htat.

gunarsson has been solid and effective but aulie should be able to bring whatever gunnarsson brings to the table. he's less poised but as a guy who has 6 inches on gunnar, and is a better skater to boot, he's should be better in the long run.

gunnarsson looks kind of like a lilja or skrastins type... he can hold down a top four role and in some situations even excel, but he isn't very talented offensively, and while he's solid physically isn't a physical defenseman per se.

the lightning have some interesting pieces, and if they like gunnarsson he should be in play.

the leafs should have varying degrees of interest, but any one of downie, purcell, malone, lecavalier, connolly would fill a need, imo.

and please stop it with the schenn garbage teeds. his stock didn't drop that much because of 15 bad games.

Uhh, msun30, he is our sixth defenceman. And I spent an hour talking with someone who travels all over the world for the Oilers and is thought to be oneof their three best scouts. Yesterday.

Schenn is known amongst 32 NHL teams as a sixth dman, who might be a 5. That is the REALITY of LIFE msun30. And I could say that this guy and I agreed on everything about Schenn and that wouldn't be a lie.

In what universe do you see him as anything else? Basically this guy and I agreed that he has slow feet, behind the flow on the ice constantly and can shut people down WHEN he is playing well, and has an above average first pass. WHAT ELSE are he and I missing???
 
Teeds, your definition of Luke Schenn is maybe where he is right now. But the fact of the matter is he is 22 years old. He will certainly improve. Way too early give him a definitive label.
 
Teeds needs to stop acting like hes some big shot in the NHL world. You spend every saturday night posting on these forums like the rest of us brah.

There's a lot of people here with good hockey knowledge but theres only one person who constantly says shit like

And I spent an hour talking with someone who travels all over the world for the Oilers and is thought to be oneof their three best scouts

to make himself look like he knows what hes talking about.
 
Last edited:
Everyone sells Gunnar so short.

But he's so good.

I think he had just as much to do with Phaneuf returning to form, than, well, Phaneuf.
 
Teeds needs to stop acting like hes some big shot in the NHL world. You spend every saturday night posting on these forums like the rest of us brah.

There's a lot of people here with good hockey knowledge but theres only one person who constantly says shit like



to make himself look like he knows what hes talking about.

Guys, guys, guys. Meeting this guy was a total fluke. And there are two guys here, Jays and Wolfie, who get to meet guys like this 1,000 times MORE than I do. So I DO NOT profess to be a big shot with scouts. In fact, it was the first scout I have met in more than a decade. And it was a ton of fun. As soon as he saw however,that I knew more than most, he clammed up pretty quickly and the conversation switched back to the skateboarding we were observing.

And there are tons of great knowledgeable posters here, the least of which is msun30, who has some extremely interesting insights.

And we are all right at certain times and dead wrong on others. Just like GM's. Our own Brian Burke has stolen huge assets in two trades(Trashbin and Phaneuf trades) and might have given away a franchise center plus in the Kessel trade.

But perhaps his latest potential error was locking up Schenn at 3.5 million. Because based on his play, I personally do NOT believe he should be north of half of that.

And this I know for certain, he is definitely on the Burke trading shelf, IF he improves over the season. Because there are still a lot of old school guys, like you guys, who put an onus on phsyical shut down defencemen.

Burke knows you have to give to GET.
 
Burke LOVES having players that other teams WANT. Just to add to my sermon. And I personally have no problem with the Seguin trade. It was a gamble, a reasonable one, and he lost it. Seguin I would take over Kessel one on one, and getting the amazing Horton for OUR second and drafting Doug Hamilton who is tearing it up in the OHL, just makes the good old Bruins that much stronger.

Thanks to Burkes schmoozing abilities and lack of whining about the Kessel trade, I believe we STOLE Joe Colborne plus from Boston for a guy only Chara wanted, not Chiarelli. So its all good there.

I LOVE Joe Colborne, I just hope he isn't rushed into an Antropov situation.
 
I PMed our local expert Zeke the name of my source. Who I can assure you, is pretty damn impeccable.
 
Msun30 sure might have nailed who was the best player on the GRABO line eh?? MacArthur is shining this year imo. His shot is Bobby Hull like this year. AND accurate.
 
MacArthur, Connolly and Lupul, three guys that were just given up on by other teams. MacArthur by two different teams in the space of a few months.
 
Everyone sells Gunnar so short.

But he's so good.

I think he had just as much to do with Phaneuf returning to form, than, well, Phaneuf.

C'mon. He does a lot of the smart, simple stuff and he isn't toilet paper soft along the walls like he was last year, but to credit him with Phaneuf's return to form?

He's a nice little 2nd pairing quality defender overall, but nothing more. Their are dozens of similar defenders around the league.
 
MacArthur, Connolly and Lupul, three guys that were just given up on by other teams. MacArthur by two different teams in the space of a few months.

It's kinda funny when you think about it 'cause it's not just those three - Phaneuf and Kessel too. And Grabo got a bad rap in Montreal.

Toronto's like the Island of Misfit Toys.
 
Is Kessel the polka dot Elephant?

4toys.jpg
 
i am interested to see how mac progresses.

he lacks his elite speed, but he kind of reminds me of a poor man's martin st. louis. not big, but very good on the boards, very smart, good with the puck, and a good well-rounded skill set.

the truth is that what we saw last year might have been the low end of what you can expect from him. though he's going to have a tough time racking up assists until kulemin starts scoring again.

still, mac has asserted himself very nicely and imo all but proven that last year wasn't a fluke.
 
mac's got a pretty complete skillset - speed, grit, hands, shot - and his arguably elite Hockey IQ has been evident ever since his first leaf camp. I have a hard time seeing how he'll slow down at all.
 
He's a perfect second liner. Just like Kuly. Both could be first liners on most teams.

I just can't figure out where Grabs went though. Those two guys can't fire on all cylinders without a good center.
 
Uhh, msun30, he is our sixth defenceman. And I spent an hour talking with someone who travels all over the world for the Oilers and is thought to be oneof their three best scouts. Yesterday.

Schenn is known amongst 32 NHL teams as a sixth dman, who might be a 5. That is the REALITY of LIFE msun30. And I could say that this guy and I agreed on everything about Schenn and that wouldn't be a lie.

In what universe do you see him as anything else? Basically this guy and I agreed that he has slow feet, behind the flow on the ice constantly and can shut people down WHEN he is playing well, and has an above average first pass. WHAT ELSE are he and I missing???



If you read this carefully, teeds actually did a good job of not telling the truth while never quite lying.


...I guess this means I have multiple accounts as well.
 
If you read this carefully, teeds actually did a good job of not telling the truth while never quite lying.


...I guess this means I have multiple accounts as well.

Well you do have the same join date as hockeylover and have user names related to hockey.

I see right through you !
 
I pmed Zeke the contact that I made, he was the guy responsible for them grabbing Eberle. He has known Eberle since he was 10.

And stop mentioning SAID player. I said I wouldn't mention his name for a week. And he IS our sixth dman when everyone is back. Why do you have such a hard time understanding that this is what he is NOW rated across the league.

If Gardiner continues propping him up a la Pronger to Beauchemin, then he IS our 2011 trade chip. Nothing more, but NOTHING less.
 
Back
Top