• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Lupul-Bozak-Kessel
Mac-Connolly-Ryan
Kadri-Colborne-Armstrong
Brown-Steckel-Dupuis/Crabb/Frattin

Gunnar-Phaneuf
Gardiner-Komi
Liles-Franson
 
How often are legit #1 centers traded though? That is the problem. You can't really pass on an opportunity to acquire a guy who would be your 2nd or 3rd best forward because you would rather he were a center.

The last top flight center to be moved was Thornton almost 7 years ago. Before that you could say Lindros, though he was pretty much done at that point. You might have to go back to Sundin. I guess second tier guys like Turgeon and Damphousse moved around a bit. Teams just don't give up those types of players often enough to pass on a great opportunity to add another elite forward talent.
Agreed 100%, which is why I'm not buying the Staal/Getzlaf rumours. A young, elite #1 center has definitely got to be the least traded commodity in the NHL. And whenever teams do it, they usually end up getting ripped off and soon realize that it was a huge mistake.

After all, just look back to the Leafs' 97/98 season. We were in a similar, but really even worse position than Anaheim or Carolina. In the middle of our third sub .500 season in a row. A crappy coach on the hot seat. No prospects in the system to speak of, thanks to Fletcher's "draft schmaft" years. A rag-tag collection of older, middling and young talent on the roster. And then of course, a 27 year-old franchise #1 center named Mats Sundin. Imagine if we'd traded him to improve our depth, re-stock the cupboard or any of the sort of nonsense that's being suggested the 'Canes/Ducks do with Staal/Getzlaf? Just imagine what a massive, unmitigated disaster such a move would have been for our franchise.
 
The bigger mistake was trading Doug Gilmour when he was still a legitimate top-end centre when Sundin was also on the roster.

That would have been a lite version of Sakic-Forsberg.
 
Kulemin would = Ryan if Kulemin posted the numbers he posted last year, this year and next.

I'm all for loading up with wingers and going with the young guys -- Kadri, Colborne, Bozak up the middle. Because realistically, Staal/Getzlaf ain't getting dealt.
 
Gilmour asked to be moved.

Anyway, as for a hypothetical Ryan/Leafs trade, I'll take a stab at predicting the cost...Luke Schenn and Joe Colborne. Schenn gives them a nice young piece on D, already locked up for several years, that they badly need and Colborne is a cheap young centre with size and skill to play in their top 6 next season.

I believe money is definitely a factor here for the ducks, as outlined by Elliot Friedman in a recent blog. they will want less salary coming back than they're sending out in Ryan.
 
The bigger mistake was trading Doug Gilmour when he was still a legitimate top-end centre when Sundin was also on the roster.

That would have been a lite version of Sakic-Forsberg.
It certainly would have been interesting if Pat Quinn had taken over the 98/99 Maple Leafs with both Sundin and Gilmour in the lineup.
 
Gilmour asked to be moved.

Anyway, as for a hypothetical Ryan/Leafs trade, I'll take a stab at predicting the cost...Luke Schenn and Joe Colborne. Schenn gives them a nice young piece on D, already locked up for several years, that they badly need and Colborne is a cheap young centre with size and skill to play in their top 6 next season.

I believe money is definitely a factor here for the ducks, as outlined by Elliot Friedman in a recent blog. they will want less salary coming back than they're sending out in Ryan.

We would be selling Colborne way low by making that kind of deal. For all we know, Colborne can be a 60+ point guy right now if given the proper ice time and linemates.

At least with Schenn, we have a pretty decent idea of what we're parting with. But in Colborne, we could be giving away a player who is as good as or better than Ryan, and giving them Schenn as an added bonus.

I'm very much against that kind of deal. We could have a legit stud on our hands in Colborne, and one who is massive and plays the center position, to boot. It could do down as one of the worst deals ever if Burke is stupid enough to make it.
 
I think Burke has plans for Colborne, and I hope he keeps him. In fact Colborne/Ryan could be a lethal combination for the Leafs if it were ever to happen.
 
We would be selling Colborne way low by making that kind of deal. For all we know, Colborne can be a 60+ point guy right now if given the proper ice time and linemates.

At least with Schenn, we have a pretty decent idea of what we're parting with. But in Colborne, we could be giving away a player who is as good as or better than Ryan, and giving them Schenn as an added bonus.

I'm very much against that kind of deal. We could have a legit stud on our hands in Colborne, and one who is massive and plays the center position, to boot. It could do down as one of the worst deals ever if Burke is stupid enough to make it.

Schenn is the exact same age as Colborne and plays a position that requires considerably more years of development.
 
I think it would take Schenn + signed top 6 forward (MacArthur, Kulemin, Colborne, Kadri etc) to get Ryan.

And that would be a big price to pay, unless Ryan gets to a 70-80 point level.
 
I don't think Reimer is untouchable. I don't think any goalie is really untouchable with the exception of maybe Lundqvist and Thomas. There's just too many good ones around.
 
Back
Top